Attempting to Remake Kyle Hendricks, and What Qualifies As Success

Touching on Marcus Stroman this morning in the Bullets, and, specifically, how the Cubs might be having to prepare for his departure after this season, I had the rotation on the brain. And I was thinking about the other possible departure after this season: Kyle Hendricks.

By now, you know the story with Hendricks: after years of being a steadily excellent presence in the Cubs’ rotation with his unique mix of impeccable command, pitch tunneling, and pristine mechanics, Hendricks started to really fall on hard times in 2021, and fell offer further in 2022. He was not really a guy you wanted starting competitive games, as painful as that is to say about a guy who was so important – and good! – for such a long time.

Hendricks’ 2022 season ended early with shoulder issues that were later diagnosed as a capsular tear – the kind of injury that can end a career if it’s bad enough, particularly for a 33-year-old who was already trying to succeed with limited velocity.

The good news is that Hendricks’ tear did not require surgery – which REALLY would have left the rest of his career an open question – and he’s been rehabbing, strengthening, and getting himself prepared in Arizona for the better part of the offseason already. We know that he’s likely to miss the start of the season as he is slowly brought along, but there’s hope that he could get back to a place where he contributes at the back of the rotation for, say, the latter two-thirds of the season.

Which is where I had the whole after-this-season thing on the brain. Unlike Stroman’s deal, which effectively has a player option for 2024, Hendricks’ deal has a team option for 2024 at $16 million, with a $1.5 million buyout. If Hendricks bounces back and is even close to a useful four or five, I’m thinking the Cubs would be happy to bring him back at that $14.5 million decision point, given that he can not only provide depth, but also veteran leadership and institutional knowledge for a young pitching staff.

But if Hendricks doesn’t bounce back this year, it’s possible this is the end, and the Cubs will have another couple openings in the rotation after the season.

Patrick Mooney at The Athletic spoke with Hendricks about where he’s been and about his recovery process, and it gave me a much better understanding of the relationship between Hendricks’ degraded performance the last couple years and the way injuries can impact a pitcher.

The way I *usually* think about pitcher injuries and their impact on performance is that the injuries do one of two things (or both): 1.) The injury throws off a player’s mechanics, which in turn reinforces the injury, creating a terrible feedback loop of injury and performance degradation; and/or 2.) the injury, itself, causes a direct reduction in stuff/command/velocity, and that version of the pitcher simply isn’t big-league effective anymore.

But, as Hendricks explained, there’s kind of a third way to think about how injuries impact performance, especially as a player ages.

“Once these health things started popping up, the red flags were there,” Hendricks told Mooney. “It happens, in general, just after you get past 30 as a pitcher. You’re probably going to have things pop up — if you haven’t to that point — so some of that’s just natural. But once something happened, we were able to go back and look and see, ‘OK, (my way) was doing me a lot of good while I was doing it.’ My command, the action of my pitches, it all fed off of my arm path and how my mechanics worked. A lot of the deception came from that, too.

“But, obviously, if that’s not going to be sustainable — which it wasn’t — then that’s when you kind of step back and see, ‘OK, now let’s make some changes.’”

It’s a subtle distinction, but it’s not one I’d given much thought before: a guy who is dealing with injury issues *can* get his mechanics “right” again and *can* get healthy, but even once he does, he is physically changed in a way that means doing everything exactly like he did before is no longer sustainably effective. It’s probably because of aging and the accumulation of smaller physical wear and tear, and it’s a factor in why pitchers – almost across the board – have to make so many changes after age 30.

To put it another way, even if this 33-year-old, post-shoulder-capsule-rehab version of Kyle Hendricks could keep his mechanics and arm path and body muscle/mass composition the same as it was when he was 28, the results of his pitches – the command, the tunneling, the deception – just wouldn’t be the same. I get the sense that there were times over the last two years when Hendricks *DID* get everything back where it was “supposed” to be, and yet we saw it play out again and again: the sinker command was just not there, the changeup just didn’t have as much bite, and batters too often were able to feast.

So, then, there was a comprehensive process to remake Hendricks. First, you rehab the shoulder to get it strengthened and in a good place, physically. Then you work on the body to do whatever it is that the Cubs’ health and performance analysis said his new body should be like. Then, lastly, you modify the pitching mechanics to work with the current version of the shoulder and the body.

That could allow you to maximize performance, even if it’s kind of like a totally different version of Hendricks. He probably can’t be the guy he was in his 20s, realistically, and I’m going to speculate that the differences will look really subtle to amateur scouts like me. But it sounds like this was the approach the Cubs and Hendricks had to take if they wanted a chance for him to succeed in 2023, and not just continue to be an older version of the guy he was the last two years.

Will it work? Well, nobody can say for sure, and the nature of injuries and aging curves very generally would tell you to bet against it. But I am very glad that there wasn’t any surgery. And I am also going to retain some hope because of the Cubs’ improved pitching development infrastructure. We have focused on it mostly because of the young pitchers and external reclamation projects, but maybe the Cubs can show that they are also good at a comprehensive internal project like this.

And if, at the end of this, Kyle Hendricks winds up giving the Cubs 20+ starts with a league-average ERA in 2023, I think you’d have to call that a success. If he’s even a touch better than that? Enough that the Cubs definitely want to bring him back in 2024? Then that would be a MASSIVE success.

For much more on Hendricks’ rehab process and on his time with the Cubs, make sure to check out Mooney’s piece. You will be reminded just how likable Hendricks is, and how much you want to see him succeed with the Cubs.

written by

Brett Taylor is the Lead Cubs Writer at Bleacher Nation, and you can find him on Twitter at @BleacherNation and on LinkedIn here. Brett is also the founder of Bleacher Nation, which opened up shop in 2008 as an independent blog about the Chicago Cubs. Later growing to incorporate coverage of other Chicago sports, Bleacher Nation is now one of the largest regional sports blogs on the web.

more cubs news

Enhanced Box Score: Cubs 4, Rays 3 – June 12, 2024

The Cubs don't "win" games anymore. They survive them. So it was tonight, with Hector Neris called upon to close out the game again, after last night's fiasco. His pitches generally fell into two categories, either noncompetitive balls or absolute...

Cody Bellinger Gives the Cubs the Lead with a Three-Run Home Run!

THAT is the kind of big swing the Cubs needed with runners on base. Take any kind of batted ball luck out of the equation by just sending the ball to the seats. Cody Bellinger gives the Cubs the lead:...

Seiya Suzuki Sends One Out to Center

Need the guys who are here to supply power to, you know, supply power. So it was good to see Seiya Suzuki get into one. This fourth inning blast tied the game up (for now):

Pre-Gamin’: Cubs at Rays (5:50 CT) – Lineups, Broadcast Info, Game Thread

CUBS LINEUP — If you aren't going to beat the Cardinals and Reds and Rays, who are you going to beat, exactly? At least Craig Counsell is significantly shaking up the lineup tonight. This is one hell of a different...

The Cubs Have Signed Jorge Lopez – Yes, That Jorge Lopez

Even as he was being punted quickly from the New York Mets organization following the glove-throwing incident, it wasn't clear that pitcher Jorge Lopez was done pitching this year. After all, the 31-year-old reliever had a long big league track...

Chicago Cubs 1st Round Mock Draft: Exploring Potential Picks

The Chicago Cubs are set to make their first-round selection in the 2024 MLB Draft with the 14th overall selection. Oct 1, 2022; Chicago, Illinois, USA; Chicago Cubs Chairman Tom Ricketts (R) smiles next to Chicago Cubs President of Baseball...

Owen Caissie Just Hit a Monster 10th Inning Home Run (And Then Other Stuff Happened)

If the big league Cubs aren't going to supply us with many thrilling moments, at least the prospects can step up. This afternoon, the Iowa Cubs had played the Columbus Clippers to a 1-1 tie in regulation. In the top...

MLBits: Aaron Judge’s Hot Streak, Paul Skenes Standing O, Cubs Need a Spark, More

MLB Notes — Aaron Judge was incredible in May, hitting .361/.479/.918 with 14 home runs in 97 at-bats for the Yankees. He helped New York post a 21-5 record in May, taking them to the top of the American League...

My Reaction on Some of Jed Hoyer’s Comments Today — Offense, Potential for Trades, Internal Improvements, More

This morning, Jed Hoyer joined Mully and Haugh on 670 The Score to talk about his team and where things are headed. The conversation (which you can catch in full at the bottom of this post) was mostly a collection...

Something Has to Change, and I Have Some Suggestions

Last night, the Chicago Cubs lost the way they always lose this season: No timely hitting (1-7 w/ RISP) + a bullpen meltdown (3.0 IP, 4H, 5ER, 3BB, 4K). Only the Chicago White Sox have more blown saves than the...

Latest News

How to Watch Diamondbacks vs. Angels: Live Stream or on TV

Brandon Pfaadt will take the mound for the Arizona Diamondbacks (32-35) when they host starter Griffin Canning and the Los Angeles Angels (25-41) on Thursday, with first pitch at 9:40 PM ET.Find out how to watch the Arizona-Los Angeles matchup...

Twins vs. Athletics: Start Time, Streaming Live, TV Channel, How to Watch

Joe Ryan takes the mound for the Minnesota Twins (36-32) when they host starting pitcher Luis Medina and the Oakland Athletics (26-44) at 7:40 PM ET on Thursday.Keep reading to find out all the details on how to watch Minnesota...

Mariners vs. White Sox: Start Time, Streaming Live, TV Channel, How to Watch

Luis Castillo will take the mound for the Seattle Mariners (39-30) when they host starter Garrett Crochet and the Chicago White Sox (17-51) on Thursday, with first pitch at 9:40 PM ET and the Mariners going for a series sweep.The...

Minnesota Twins vs. Oakland Athletics Series June 13-16: Odds, Starting Pitchers & Predictions

On Thursday, June 13 at 7:40 PM ET, a four-game series featuring the Minnesota Twins and the visiting Oakland Athletics will get underway.Twins vs. Athletics Series Info Athletics @ Twins Time: Thursday, June 13 at 7:40 PM ET Twins Starting...

Cardinals vs. Pirates: Injury Report, Updates & Probable Starters – June 13

In the final game of a two-game set at Busch Stadium, the St. Louis Cardinals (31-34) meet the Pittsburgh Pirates (32-34), Thursday at 2:15 PM ET.Curious about who's available to play for the Cardinals and the Pirates? Keep scrolling to...

Yankees vs. Royals: Injury Report, Updates & Probable Starters – June 13

The Kansas City Royals (39-29) will host the New York Yankees (48-21), Thursday at 2:10 PM ET, with the Yankees on a three-game winning streak.Want to see who's available to play for the Yankees and the Royals? Keep reading to...

Yankees vs. Royals: Start Time, Streaming Live, TV Channel, How to Watch

The New York Yankees (48-21), led by Aaron Judge and going for a series sweep, visit the Kansas City Royals (39-29) at 2:10 PM ET on Thursday.Keep reading to find out all the details on how to watch New York...

How to Watch Cardinals vs. Pirates: Live Stream or on TV

On Thursday, looking for a series sweep, Bryan Reynolds and the Pittsburgh Pirates (32-34) take on the St. Louis Cardinals (31-34), with first pitch scheduled for 2:15 PM ET at Busch Stadium.Keep scrolling to find out all the details on...

Mets vs. Marlins: Start Time, Streaming Live, TV Channel, How to Watch

Luis Severino will take the mound for the New York Mets (28-37) when they host starter Roddery Munoz and the Miami Marlins (23-43) on Thursday, with first pitch at 7:10 PM ET and the Marlins going for a series sweep.Find...

Phillies vs. Red Sox: Start Time, Streaming Live, TV Channel, How to Watch

The Philadelphia Phillies (46-20), with Aaron Nola on the hill, visit the Boston Red Sox (33-34) who will counter with Tanner Houck, at 7:10 PM ET on Thursday.Keep reading to find out all the details on how to watch Philadelphia...

more cubs news