MLB Mock Drafts: Cubs and Meyer, Shaw, Lowder, Teel

We are still a month and a half away from the 2023 MLB Draft, but with amateur seasons drawing closer to their end, the clarity at the top of the draft – as in, which players comprise the top talent (apparently it’s among the best groups in recent memory in the top 5/6, thanks a lot draft lottery). So it’s a good time to look at some of the latest mock drafts, and it’s also a time when we start getting more of them …

  • Kiley McDaniel’s fresh mock at ESPN is a wealth of big picture information on the draft, in addition to some of the individual player scouting bits. You get a good sense for how teams could try to structure their drafts this year to pick up later round talent (in an exceptionally deep pool, you’re more likely to have “first-round-caliber” high schoolers who drop because of bonus demands). You also get some rumors on the Cubs at their mocked pick:
    1. Chicago Cubs
      Noble Meyer, RHP, Jesuit HS (OR)

    I’ve heard the Cubs linked to prep infielder Kevin McGonigle and this is probably the top spot where Florida RHP Hurston Waldrep is in play (who has some similarities to Chicago’s first rounder last year, Cade Horton). Some scouts also think Tommy Troy and (Matt) Shaw are targets here. Meyer, however, has one of the best collection of pitcher traits in recent memory, with other recent comps to him going at least this high. He has true frontline potential but isn’t as polished at this stage as some of the other elite prep arms that have traits of that caliber: Mick Abel, Andrew Painter, Jackson Jobe and Dylan Lesko.

  • If the Cubs wound up with a pitching prospect of the caliber of those four when picking at 13, yeah, I would not be surprised to see them go the rare route and take a high school pitcher in the first round.
  • Keith Law’s first mock draft of the year, which has Meyer going 15th to the White Sox, has the Cubs taking one of the other names mentioned by McDaniel:
  • 13. Chicago Cubs – Matt Shaw, SS, Maryland
    Shaw is one of the best pure hitters in the draft class with metrics to match, something the Cubs are clearly aware of given their choice of Cade Horton with their first pick last year. I could see them going for Stanford shortstop Tommy Troy or Vandy centerfielder Enrique Bradfield Jr., as well.

  • Meanwhile, Jonathan Mayo’s first mock of the year has Rhett Lowder falling to the Cubs:
  • 13. Cubs: Rhett Lowder, RHP, Wake Forest (No. 9)
    He might not have Lowd stuff (sorry, couldn’t resist), but he’s been extremely consistent and has an ERA under 2.00. He’s had back-to-back seven-inning shutouts, which certainly doesn’t hurt his stock.

  • Although Paul Skenes is obviously the top college arm in this draft, some have Lowder as the second best, right there with Chase Dollander. If he’s still on the board at 13, I’m sure the Cubs will have serious interest. Not sure he will be, though, because his season has just gotten better and better.
  • Baseball America’s second mock draft was earlier this month, and if you missed it, and it was a college bat for the Cubs:
    1. Cubs — Kyle Teel, C, Virginia

    The clear-cut best college catcher in the class has been on a rampage all season. He’s hitting .423/.482/.665 with nine home runs and 20 doubles and he has lowered his strikeout rate to 9.2%—though he was never a huge strikeout guy in the first place. It’s an excellent foundation of athleticism with plus arm strength who should benefit from professional catching development. The swing won’t be for everyone, as it’s full of violence and effort, and his approach might need to be toned down in pro ball, but Teel should be the beneficiary of a down catching class and he’s played his way into the middle of the first round.

  • It seems like, in more recent mocks, Teel’s stock has continued to climb as his performance at the plate has continued to shine. And, to the extent you would start to say things like, “But what about Miguel Amaya, Pablo Aliendo, and Moises Ballesteros? Would the Cubs really draft another catcher when three of their top 15/20 prospects are catchers?” Yes. They would. If they think he’s the best value at that spot and they really believe in the bat, they would.
  • written by

    Brett Taylor is the Lead Cubs Writer at Bleacher Nation, and you can find him on Twitter at @BleacherNation and @Brett_A_Taylor.

    more cubs news

    Pete Alonso Reportedly Wants to Come to the Cubs

    When the New York Mets reportedly made Pete Alonso available at the Trade Deadline, I'll cop to getting awfully excited. The fit for the Cubs at that time was just so obvious - a huge bat that transforms the lineup...

    Jed Hoyer’s End-of-Season Press Conference, Rolling Updates

    Chicago Cubs President of Baseball Operations Jed Hoyer is set to address the media at 11am CT, and I'll be rolling out the updates as fast as I can type them below. I don't expect anything earth-shattering, but sometimes there...

    Cubs Prospect All-Star Nods: PCA, Horton, Caissie

    A trio of Chicago Cubs prospects landed on the first or second All-Prospect Team from MLB Pipeline, with Owen Caissie getting first team honors and Pete Crow-Armstrong and Cade Horton landing on the second team. That's three out of 24...

    Playoffs Begin, Cubs Attendance, Vote of Confidence, Manager Vacancies, Velocity, and Other Cubs Bullets

    The MLB Postseason begins today, and boy is my day different based on what happened over the weekend. If the Cubs had made the playoffs, I would be an absolute wreck all day today. Nervous. Fretting over the roster. Overreacting...

    Pete Crow-Armstrong Wins Defensive Player of the Year for All of Minor League Baseball

    Although we didn't get to see a whole lot of it, and there was at least one youthful hiccup in there (the dive in Atlanta), I think we definitely did get to see some big league flashes of what Pete...

    Cubs Are Going to Do “Everything They Can” to Trade for Pete Alonso

    Bruce Levine joined Matt Spiegel on 670 The Score tonight (7:30 mark if you're looking for it), and ... boy did he have a lot to say. Specifically, Levine discussed the Cubs interest in trading for Mets first baseman Pete...

    Turns Out Alexander Canario Won’t Be Playing in the Arizona Fall League After All (UPDATE: Winter Ball Instead)

    As the month of September went on without Alexander Canario playing - pretty much at all - I was comforted in knowing that the 23-year-old outfield prospect would soon be playing in the Arizona Fall League. Even if he'd missed...

    Tom Ricketts Speaks: No Consolation Prizes, Consistency, Hendricks, Bellinger, Overall Spending

    Chicago Cubs Owner and Chairman Tom Ricketts was in Milwaukee for the season finale, speaking to the media and speaking on the Marquee broadcast. In comments to the media, Ricketts wasn't about to start celebrating a season that ended in...

    Brandon Woodruff Has a Shoulder Injury, Taking Him Out of the Wild Card Series at Least

    The Milwaukee Brewers' postseason chances just took a major hit: Brandon Woodruff is out. One of three dominant starters who could have carried the Brewers through short series, Woodruff missed much of the season with a shoulder injury. He only...

    2023 MLB Playoff Bracket and Wild Card Schedule

    If you are able to withstand the absence of the Chicago Cubs and the pain of knowing how close they were to being in the mix, here's the full Major League Baseball postseason slate for 2023. First, the participants and...

    Latest News

    James Harden Reportedly Now Expected to Join 76ers Training Camp

    James Harden's brief holdout against the Philadelphia 76ers is about to come to an end. After not reporting for Media Day on the first full day of training camp, the superstar point guard is reportedly set to rejoin the team....

    Pete Alonso Reportedly Wants to Come to the Cubs

    When the New York Mets reportedly made Pete Alonso available at the Trade Deadline, I'll cop to getting awfully excited. The fit for the Cubs at that time was just so obvious - a huge bat that transforms the lineup...

    Blackhawks Forward Philipp Kurashev Regular Season Start In Question

    The update on Philipp Kurashev from Blackhawks head coach Luke Richardson wasn't ideal on Tuesday before Chicago hosts Detroit in preseason action. It sounds like the young forward's regular season start might be delayed by injury. "I think he’ll probably...

    Phillies vs. Marlins Probable Starting Pitchers – NL Wild Card Game 1

    The Philadelphia Phillies (90-72) host the Miami Marlins (84-77) on Tuesday to kick off a two-game series at Citizens Bank Park. The matchup starts at 8:08 PM ET.The Phillies will give the ball to Zack Wheeler (13-6, 3.56 ERA), who...

    Brewers vs. Diamondbacks Probable Starting Pitchers – NL Wild Card Game 1

    The Arizona Diamondbacks (84-78) kick off a two-game series on Tuesday against the Milwaukee Brewers (92-70). The contest starts at 7:08 PM ET at American Family Field.The Brewers will give the ball to Corbin Burnes (10-8, 3.39 ERA), who is...

    Eddie Jackson Sounds Ready to Return (But the Bears Are Preparing Contingency Plans In Case He Isn’t)

    The Chicago Bears secondary has been playing short-handed in recent weeks with Kyler Gordon (IR stint), Jaylon Johnson (hamstring injury), and Eddie Jackson (foot) being out of action. But help appears to be on the way with the potential return...

    OG Anunoby Tricked Damian Lillard Into Thinking He Was Going to Toronto

    OG Anunoby pulled a fast one on Damian Lillard. While the superstar point guard sat in limbo waiting for the Portland Trail Blazers to find a trade partner, the Toronto Raptors' forward took advantage. In a conversation with Chris Haynes...

    Jed Hoyer’s End-of-Season Press Conference, Rolling Updates

    Chicago Cubs President of Baseball Operations Jed Hoyer is set to address the media at 11am CT, and I'll be rolling out the updates as fast as I can type them below. I don't expect anything earth-shattering, but sometimes there...

    Phillies vs. Marlins Prediction: Expert Picks, Odds, Stats & Best Bets – NL Wild Card Game 1

    The Philadelphia Phillies will host the Miami Marlins to start the NL Wild Card Series on Tuesday at 8:08 PM ET, live on ESPN from Citizens Bank Park. The Phillies are -152 favorites to pick up the win, while the...

    Blame Game, Arlington Demolition, Where Has This O Been Hiding? And Other Bears Bullets

    A collection of thoughts strung together to start the football-writing portion of my day. Now that I've been able to sleep on it, re-watch it, and sleep on it again, I had fun watching Sunday's Bears game. No, I didn't...

    more cubs news