Mock Draft Medley: The Consensus is, There isn’t Much Consensus Atop the NFL Draft

We’ve arrived, friends. We’re just over 72 hours from the Carolina Panthers being on the clock in Kansas City on Thursday evening. Unfortunately, we know less about the top of the first round than we thought weeks ago. We’re almost done with mock drafts, but not quite yet.

C.J. Stroud’s slide, Bryce Young’s S2 scores, Arizona’s desire to move back, teams waiting in the weeds for a potential stab at a quarterback, etc. Things have gotten muddy in the NFL Draft waters and the endless catalouge of mock drafts are drastically changing in completion at the top.

After reading the final mocks by some of the biggest names in the mock draft world, the consensus is that there is little consensus atop the NFL Draft. Let’s look at the top five picks in the most recent mock drafts by Matt Miller, Peter King, Mel Kiper, and Todd McShay and then discuss.

Matt Miller, ESPN

  1. Panthers: QB Bryce Young, Alabama
  2. Texans: EDGE Will Anderson Jr., Alabama
  3. Cardinals: EDGE Tyree Wilson, Texas Tech
  4. Colts: QB C.J. Stroud, Ohio State
  5. Seahawks: DT Jalen Carter, Georgia

Peter King, NBC Sports

  1. Panthers: QB Bryce Young, Alabama
  2. Texans: EDGE Tyree Wilson, Texas Tech
  3. Titans: QB C.J. Stroud, Ohio State
  4. Colts: QB Will Levis, Kentucky
  5. Seahawks: DT Jalen Carter, Georgia

Mel Kiper and Todd McShay (Joint Mock Draft), ESPN

  1. Panthers: QB Bryce Young, Alabama
  2. Texans: QB C.J. Stroud, Ohio State
  3. Cardinals: EDGE Will Anderson Jr., Alabama
  4. Colts: QB Anthony Richardson, Florida
  5. Seahawks: DT Jalen Carter, Georgia

So, no one really knows what’s going on inside the top five …

Bryce Young goes to the Carolina Panthers in all three mock drafts, and at this point, you can take that to the bank. There’s just too much smoke around that theory for it not to be all but a lead pipe lock. All three mocks also have the Seahawks taking Georgia DT Jalen Carter at No. 5.

However, no one shares an opinion on picks No. 2-4. Ohio State QB C.J. Stroud goes second to the Texans (Kiper/McShay), third to the Titans (via trade, King), and fourth to the Colts (Miller) in the three mock drafts. So, while no one is sure where Stroud will go, everyone agrees that he will not slide out of the top five despite the rough week of headlines that he’s endured.

Only one of the drafts (Kiper/McShay) has Florida QB Anthony Richardson in the top five. Kiper and McShay have the Colts taking Anthony Richardson with Young and Stroud off the board in their mock. Will Levis’ name is called inside the top five (also to the Colts) in only one of the mocks (King) as well.

The top two EDGE rushers Tyree Wilson and Will Anderson Jr. each appear in two of the three with each going as high as second and as low as third.

Again, we have no idea right now. Would new Houston head coach DeMeco Ryans be amendable to taking a defensive player at No. 2? Will someone take the No. 3 pick off of the Cardinals’ hands? Who has the edge at (the) edge, Wilson or Anderson? So many factors can influence what is shaping up to be a wild top of the draft on Thursday night.

Other notable picks …

  • In both mock drafts that Tyree Wilson and Will Anderson Jr. fall out of the top five, they land in Detroit at No. 6. Peter King has Will Anderson Jr. to the Lions, and Kiper and McShay have Tyree Wilson heading to Detroit.
  • All three mock drafts have Illinois cornerback Devin Witherspoon going ahead of Oregon cornerback Christian Gonzalez. Miller has Witherspoon going to the Lions at No. 6, while King, Kiper, and McShay have him going to the Raiders at No. 7.
  • No one agrees on the Bears’ pick at No. 9 … Miller has the Bears taking Iowa’s Lukas Van Ness, King has them addressing the o-line with Paris Johnson Jr., and the Kiper/McShay combo has the Bears taking Peter Skoronski.
  • Kentucky QB Will Levis is there for the Titans at No. 11 in both of the mocks that Tennessee didn’t trade up in.
  • Peter King has the Texans taking QB Hendon Hooker at No. 12 after taking Tyree Wilson with the second overall selection. The other two mocks have the Texans taking Jaxon Smith-Njigba.
  • All three mock drafts agree with my Packers mock, sending Utah TE Dalton Kincaid to Green Bay.
  • Matt Miller has the Chargers taking Texas RB Bijan Robinson at No. 21, drafting Austin Ekeler’s replacement, and giving Justin Herbert another weapon. Haven’t seen that one before, but I like it.
  • Matt Miller also has the Minnesota Vikings drafting an eventual replacement for Kirk Cousins, taking QB Hendon Hooker at No. 23.
  • written by

    Patrick grew up in Chicago's Bridgeport and Garfield Ridge neighborhoods before moving to the Western Suburbs of Chicago before eventually relocating to the Las Vegas area with his family in 2023. He started with Bleacher Nation in 2021 and has spent time as a Staff Writer and on the Chicago Blackhawks beat. He is currently a writer and editor at Bleacher Nation covering the Chicago Bears and the NFL at large and the author of the Bleacher Nation Newsletter. Patrick is a member of the Pro Football Writers of America (PFWA).

    more nfl news

    Pittsburgh Steelers 3-Round Mock Draft: Exploring Potential Picks Along The Offensive Line

    Pittsburgh Steelers 3-Round Mock Draft - The decision is far from easy. On the one hand, a strong offensive line is the bedrock of any successful team, and the long-term benefits are undeniable. On the other hand, a game-changing offensive weapon could breathe...

    Tampa Bay Buccaneers 1st Round Mock Draft: Exploring Potential Picks at 26th Overall

    The Tampa Bay Buccaneers enter the 2024 NFL Draft in a familiar position – contenders with a need to retool. Baker Mayfield solidified the quarterback position sans Tom Bracy, and while the Bucs boast a talented roster, key departures and...

    New York Jets 1st Round Mock Draft: Exploring Potential Picks at 10th Overall

    The pressure is on for the New York Jets. With the 10th overall pick in the 2024 NFL Draft, the team faces a crucial decision that could define their future. Years of rebuilding have yielded progress, but the playoffs remain...

    New England Patriots 3-Round Mock Draft: Exploring Potential Picks After Selecting Jayden Daniels in Round 1

    New England Patriots 3-Round Mock Draft - The curtain has closed on the Tom Brady and Bill Belichick era in New England. The Patriots, once a dynasty of consistency, now find themselves at a crossroads. With the number three pick in the 2024 NFL Draft,...

    Chicago Bears 3-Round Mock Draft: Exploring Potential Picks To Surround Caleb Williams

    The winds of change are howling through Halas Hall. After years (decades) of searching, the Chicago Bears appear set to finally land their franchise quarterback, Caleb Williams, with the top overall pick. This signals a new era for the Bears, but the...

    Las Vegas Raiders 2024 First-Round Mock Draft: Raiders Wait on QB, Instead Bolster Offensive Line

    With just one week until the Las Vegas Raiders are on the clock, it's crunch time leading into one of their biggest drafts in a while. The Raiders brought in veteran general manager Tom Telesco this offseason to lead the...

    Las Vegas Raiders 3-Round Mock Draft: Exploring Potential Picks For The Silver and Black

    Las Vegas Raiders 3-Round Mock Draft - It's a new era in Las Vegas, and while they still have questions surrounding the most important position on the team, there's a lot of discussion about what the Raiders will do with their first-round selection....

    New England Patriots 1st Round Mock Draft: Patriots Snag Drake Maye

    The New England Patriots enter the 2024 NFL Draft at a crossroads. This New England Patriots 1st Round Mock Draft focuses on them addressing the most important position. The post-Tom Brady era has seen a carousel of quarterbacks, with none...

    New Orleans Saints 1st Round Mock Draft: Saints Strengthen the Trenches with Offensive Line

    The New Orleans Saints enter the 2024 draft with a glaring need on their offensive line. This New Orleans Saints 1st round mock draft focuses on addressing their biggest needs. With questions surrounding the long-term health of Ryan Ramczyk and...

    Green Bay Packers Draft Picks: Full List of NFL Draft Selections

    The Green Packers made some noise in the playoffs last season and hope to build on that success in the 2024 NFL Draft. Take a look at the Packers draft picks for 2024. Green Bay Packers 2024 NFL Draft Picks...

    Latest News

    Cubs vs. Marlins Probable Starting Pitchers – April 19

    The Miami Marlins (4-15) kick off a four-game series on Friday against the Chicago Cubs (11-7). The contest starts at 2:20 PM ET at Wrigley Field.The Cubs will look to Jameson Taillon versus the Marlins and Andrew Jacob Puk (0-3).Cubs...

    Reds vs. Angels: Free Live Stream, TV Channel, How to Watch

    Spencer Steer and the Cincinnati Reds (9-9) host Mike Trout and the Los Angeles Angels (9-10) on Friday in a series opener, with first pitch at 6:40 PM ET.Keep reading to find out all the details on how to watch...

    Kings vs. Pelicans Predictions, Best Bets and Odds: NBA Playoffs Game 1 – Friday, April 19, 2024

    The Sacramento Kings and the New Orleans Pelicans take the court to start the opening round of the NBA Playoffs. The Kings are favored by 1.5 points in the contest, which airs on TNT at 9:30 PM ET. The over/under...

    Nick Foligno Calls Out Blackhawks Teammates, Says Changes Are Needed

    The Blackhawks put the worst regular season of more than 70 games in the history of the franchise to bed on Thursday night in a manner that sums up the season fairly well. Connor Murphy was banged up and Nikita...

    2024 NBA Playoffs Odds: Mavs vs Clippers Odds to Win Series, Spreads, Lines

    It's a first-round matchup with a history of fireworks! The Dallas Mavericks and Los Angeles Clippers lock horns once again in the NBA Playoffs. This year marks the third time in five years these two teams meet in the opening...

    2024 NBA Playoffs Odds: Pacers vs Bucks Odds to Win Series, Spreads, Lines

    The NBA Playoffs are here, and the Eastern Conference first-round ignites with a clash of styles. The Indiana Pacers, boasting the league's top-scoring offense, bring their high-octane attack to Milwaukee to face the experienced Bucks. Giannis Antetokounmpo's status adds further...

    Pirates vs. Red Sox: Start Time, Streaming Live, TV Channel, How to Watch

    The Pittsburgh Pirates (11-8), led by Bryan Reynolds, host Jarren Duran and the Boston Red Sox (10-10) at 6:40 PM ET on Friday in a series opener.If you're planning on watching this game, keep reading for TV and streaming options...

    Padres vs. Blue Jays: Free Live Stream, TV Channel, How to Watch

    On Friday, Matt Waldron will start for the San Diego Padres (11-10) against Yariel Rodriguez and the Toronto Blue Jays (10-9), with first pitch scheduled for 9:40 PM ET at PETCO Park.Keep scrolling to find out all the details on...

    How to Watch Giants vs. Diamondbacks: Live Stream or on TV

    Michael Conforto and the San Francisco Giants (9-11) host Ketel Marte and the Arizona Diamondbacks (9-11) on Friday, with first pitch at 10:15 PM ET.Keep reading to see how to watch the San Francisco-Arizona matchup below.When is Giants vs. Diamondbacks...

    How to Watch Dodgers vs. Mets: Live Stream or on TV

    The Los Angeles Dodgers (12-9), who will give the start to Yoshinobu Yamamoto, host the New York Mets (10-8) with Sean Manaea on the hill, Friday at 10:10 PM ET.Keep scrolling to find out all the details on how to...

    more nfl news