Why C.J. Stroud Isn’t Just the Best Rookie QB in the NFL, But One of the Best QBs in the NFL

It’s been a dream start to the season for Houston’s C.J. Stroud, who has repeatedly set rookie records through the first half-season of his NFL career. He’s, without a doubt, the best rookie quarterback in the NFL right now.

But what about the rest of the league?

Here’s where C.J. Stroud ranks in individual passing statistics this season:

  • Yards: 2,270 (7th)
  • TD: 14 (T-7th)
  • INT: 1 (1st)
  • Passer Rating: 102.9 (4th)
  • In the staple quarterback metrics, Stroud is a top-10 quarterback in the NFL this season. He has more passing yards than Jared Goff, Dak Prescott, Joe Burrow, Trevor Lawrence, and Brock Purdy (to name a few). Stroud has a higher passer rating than anyone except Tua, Purdy, and Kirk Cousins. He has more touchdowns than Dak Prescott, Justin Herbert, Jared Goff, Joe Burrow, and Trevor Lawrence (again, to name a few). And no regular starter in the NFL has as few interceptions as Stroud’s one pick this season.

    The Texans‘ rookie quarterback is also 11th-best regarding total offensive grades over at PFF and passer grades.

    This week, Stroud broke the single-game record for passing yards by a rookie quarterback, throwing for 470 yards and five touchdowns in Houston’s 39-37 win over the Buccaneers. According to NFL senior researcher Tony Holzman-Escareno, Stroud is the youngest player (22 years, 33 days) since at least 1950 with 450+ pass yards & 5+ pass TD in the same game. Patrick Mahomes was the previous youngest at 23 years and 63 days.

    So, yeah, there’s a case to be made that C.J. Stroud is not only the best rookie quarterback in the league this season, but also one of the best quarterbacks regardless of tenure this season.

    C.J. Stroud Texans
    (Photo by Cooper Neill/Getty Images)

    The most exciting thing about Stroud is that he looks the part. It’s not just a matter of pulling numbers that have me believing Stroud is among the NFL’s elite. I remember watching the All-22 of Stroud’s Week 2 performance against the Colts and thinking, “f—, this kid is good!” 

    In his second NFL start, he was dropping pinpoint dimes, pushing the ball down the field, getting through his reads with ease, extending plays while keeping his eyes upfield, and playing a brand of mistake-free football that we don’t often see from rookies.

    Being a rookie in the NFL is about making mistakes. The best of them sprinkle in a play that makes you go “wow!” between the growing pains. C.J. Stroud has done very little of the former and a bunch of the latter.

    It was in Week 6 against the Saints that Stroud threw his first interception. He hasn’t thrown one since. Since that first-quarter interception against the Saints, he’s thrown seven touchdowns and racked up 809 yards through the air. The Texans are 2-1 in that three-game span. They’re 4-4 on the season. They’re on the wild card bubble right now, which is incredible, given their preseason expectations. While DeMeco Ryans and OC Bobby Slowik have plenty to do with those results, Stroud has made it possible with his near-flawless rookie campaign.

    I re-watched his record-setting performance against the Buccaneers this morning, and I came away with the exact same sentiment that I did after the last film session on Stroud: “f—, this kid is good!” This time, with even more emphasis. 

    More impressive than anything else has been the way that Stroud has elevated the players around him. He’s not halfway through the season with only one interception because the Texans are dumbing down the gameplay and asking him to play safe football. He’s also not stepping into an insanely talented roster with an established system like Brock Purdy did in San Francisco last season.

    He’s doing the exact opposite. He stepped into an offense in which Nico Collins was his No. 1 target on paper, entering the season with a rookie defensive-minded head coach and a rookie offensive coordinator.

    Nico Collins needs two catches next week to establish a new career-high in receptions. He already has almost 200 more yards this season than in his first two seasons and two more touchdowns than he had previously.

    On Sunday, the quarterback managed to get impressive performances from both tight end Dalton Schultz and receiver Noah Brown. Throughout the season, he has played with backup players more than starters along the offensive line.

    Oh, and in case you forgot … he’s a rookie. That means that unlike his peers, he’s as cheap as elite QB play comes in the NFL right now. Exciting times in Houston.

    written by

    Patrick is the Lead NFL Writer at Bleacher Nation. You can follow him on Twitter @PatrickKFlowers.

    more nfl news

    2024 NFL Mock Draft: Who Trades Up To Take Caleb Williams First Overall?

    The Chicago Bears currently hold two top-five picks in the 2024 NFL Draft. And after the Patriots win on Thursday Night Football, Chicago's chances at the first overall selection increased a ton. Will they take a quarterback or go a...

    Jaguars Place WR Christian Kirk on IR

    The Jacksonville Jaguars are going to be without wide receiver Christian Kirk for at least the next four weeks after placing him on injured reserve today. Kirk suffered an injury on the first play of the game on Monday night...

    NFL Week 14 Preview: Tracking the AFC Wild Card Race

    The AFC wild card race is one of the most intriguing storylines down the stretch. It's been heating up for weeks, and it's going to be packed with fireworks down the stretch. Heck, we already saw some last night when...

    NFL Notes: Sean McDermott Apologizes for Brutal 9/11 Comments, TNF Thoughts, More

    Bills head coach Sean McDermott is coming under fire as the Bills cling to their thin playoff hopes heading into the season's final leg. But his coaching didn't have him in hot water on Thursday. Well, it could be seen...

    Patriots 21, Steelers 18: Panic in Pittsburgh?

    The New England Patriots are a different kind of bad this season. They're so bad that the league flexed them out of a Monday Night Football game that included Patrick Mahomes and the Kansas City Chiefs next week. Which makes...

    NFL Week 14 Preview: Cowboys and Eagles Meet in a Pivotal NFC East Showdown

    If your significant other is itching to go see Christmas lights or partake in some holiday festivities, you would be wise to make sure that you steer them clear of Sunday evening because this week's Sunday Night Football matchup between...

    Would Marvin Harrison Jr. Return to Ohio State?

    Marvin Harrison Jr. is arguably the most talented player in the 2024 NFL Draft class. Depending on how the Chicago Bears handle the Justin Fields decision — and the Carolina Panthers continue to lose — Harrison could be the first...

    Chargers Backfield Could See “Competition for Carries”

    Austin Ekeler entered the season as the No. 1 running back in the Chargers backfield. He actually got a raise this offseason after he received permission to seek a trade, which didn't culminate in a move from Los Angeles. But...

    NFL Notes: Former Jaguars Employee Accused of Stealing More than $22 Million, Robbie Gould Retires, More

    According to a report by The Athletic's Katie Strang and Kalyn Kahler, a former Jacksonville Jaguars employee is accused of stealing more than $22 million from the franchise from 2019 to 2023 by exploiting the team's virtual credit card program....

    Panthers’ Hayden Hurst Dealing With Post Traumatic Amnesia

    It was almost a month ago that Carolina Panthers' tight end Hayden Hurts entered the league's concussion protocol. Hurst took a big hit against the Chicago Bears on Thursday Night Football in Week 10, and he has been sidelined since....

    Latest News

    Dallas Goedert Fantasy Week 14: Projections vs. Cowboys, Points and Stats, Start or Sit

    Philadelphia Eagles tight end Dallas Goedert will take on the fifth-ranked passing defense of the Dallas Cowboys (181.1 yards conceded per game) in Week 14, at 8:20 PM ET on Sunday.When setting your fantasy football lineup this week, is Goedert...

    Joshua Dobbs Fantasy Week 14: Projections vs. Raiders, Points and Stats, Start or Sit

    Quarterback Joshua Dobbs has a matchup versus the 13th-ranked passing defense in the league (216.8 yards allowed per game) in Week 14, when his Minnesota Vikings take on the Las Vegas Raiders, Sunday at 4:05 PM ET.When setting your fantasy...

    Josh Reynolds Fantasy Week 14: Projections vs. Bears, Points and Stats, Start or Sit

    Detroit Lions wide receiver Josh Reynolds will take on the 25th-ranked pass defense of the Chicago Bears (239.5 yards conceded per game) in Week 14, at 1:00 PM ET on Sunday.Is Reynolds' game versus the Bears this week a good...

    Derek Carr Fantasy Week 14: Projections vs. Panthers, Points and Stats, Start or Sit

    Quarterback Derek Carr has a matchup against the fourth-ranked passing defense in the NFL (180.8 yards conceded per game) in Week 14, when his New Orleans Saints meet the Carolina Panthers, Sunday at 1:00 PM ET.With his upcoming game versus...

    Allen Lazard Fantasy Week 14: Projections vs. Texans, Points and Stats, Start or Sit

    Allen Lazard and the New York Jets will face the Houston Texans and their 26th-ranked passing defense (245.2 yards allowed per game) in Week 14, on Sunday at 1:00 PM ET.With his upcoming matchup against the Texans this week, should...

    Noah Brown Fantasy Week 14: Projections vs. Jets, Points and Stats, Start or Sit

    Wideout Noah Brown has a matchup versus the third-ranked pass defense in the NFL (176.6 yards conceded per game) in Week 14, when his Houston Texans take on the New York Jets, Sunday at 1:00 PM ET.When setting your fantasy...

    Jonnu Smith Fantasy Week 14: Projections vs. Buccaneers, Points and Stats, Start or Sit

    Tight end Jonnu Smith has a matchup versus the 28th-ranked pass defense in the league (257.9 yards conceded per game) in Week 14, when his Atlanta Falcons meet the Tampa Bay Buccaneers, Sunday at 1:00 PM ET.Is Smith's game versus...

    Dalvin Cook Fantasy Week 14: Projections vs. Texans, Points and Stats, Start or Sit

    Dalvin Cook and the New York Jets will meet the Houston Texans and their ninth-ranked run defense (97 yards conceded per game) in Week 14, on Sunday at 1:00 PM ET.With his upcoming tilt against the Texans this week, should...

    Dak Prescott Fantasy Week 14: Projections vs. Eagles, Points and Stats, Start or Sit

    Quarterback Dak Prescott faces a matchup versus the 29th-ranked pass defense in the NFL (260.3 yards allowed per game) in Week 14, when his Dallas Cowboys take on the Philadelphia Eagles, Sunday at 8:20 PM ET.With his upcoming tilt versus...

    Zach Charbonnet Fantasy Week 14: Projections vs. 49ers, Points and Stats, Start or Sit

    Running back Zach Charbonnet has a matchup against the top-ranked run defense in the league (79 yards conceded per game) in Week 14, when his Seattle Seahawks play the San Francisco 49ers, Sunday at 4:05 PM ET.Is Charbonnet's game versus...

    more nfl news