Love it or Hate it? The Ha Ha Clinton-Dix and Buster Skrine Signings Are Drawing Very Different Reviews

Losing Adrian Amos was always going to hurt, but signing Ha Ha Clinton-Dix appears to have already softened the blow. Pro Football Focus’ team of analysts placed the Clinton-Dix signing among the highest-graded class of signings this offseason, giving the move an “elite” grade on that particular scale.

Elsewhere at PFF, Michael Renner viewed the shrewd, albeit low-key move one that could have a big impact. And that’s not all! Pete Prisco of CBS Sports gave a tip of the cap to Chicago for inserting Clinton-Dix to fill the vacancy left behind by Amos, giving the Bears a “B-minus” grade. Hooray for mostly praise.

The Clinton-Dix signing headlines a second consecutive heralded Bears offseason, especially from PFF. Because in addition to bringing Clinton-Dix aboard, the site also shares positive grades for the Cordarrelle Patterson and Mike Davis signings. Patterson’s arrival grades out as “very good” as PFF’s Josh Liskiewitz believes Matt Nagy’s creativity will allow the Bears to get the most out of Patterson’s skills the way the Patriots did in 2018. Davis’ deal received an “average” grade from PFF, but Cam Mellor sees the the reserve rusher as a possible pivotal piece to Chicago’s backfield trio. In fact, Mellor thinks the Bears might have signed a player who could be their top ball-carrier to what looks like a team-friendly deal.

(Photo by Kevin C. Cox/Getty Images)

And on the opposite end of the grading scale is the deal that brought nickel cornerback Buster Skrine to Chicago. Skrine’s deal isn’t the worst that was given out to a free agent this offseason, but grading as “below average” isn’t what anyone had in mind when the team was courting Bryce Callahan’s replacement.

PFF’s assessment: “Skrine has massive shoes to fill as Bryce Callahan was the top slot cornerback in the league last year but will not be returning to the Bears in 2019. Reliable in terms of health (he has logged over 400 coverage snaps each of the past seven seasons), he has surrendered 39 touchdowns into his coverage over the past seven years. That’s good money to a player who allows over five touchdowns a season in coverage.”

Yikes! Not only is that far from a glowing review, it makes me wonder how that guy can be the same as the one Nagy once said was “one of the better nickels in the league, if not the best.” What gives!?

Skrine took home PFF’s seventh worst coverage grade among corners, but was stellar elsewhere as he picked up the site’s 12th best pass-rush grade and 17th best grade against the run last season. Clearly, Skrine’s coverage grade leaves much to be desired. But perhaps new DC Chuck Pagano (who has long been revered as one of the best when it comes to coaching defensive backs) can raise his level of play. It’s possible that a different scheme loaded with big-play defenders makes things easier for Skrine in the slot. There is definitely room for upside and growth, even if there is notable cause for concern.

In the end, the Bears are still looking at an offseason in which they have satisfied some glaring positional needs. GM Ryan Pace entered the offseason with minimal holes to fill on a roster that won the NFC North and has received some positive reviews with how he has patched up perceived soft spots. This offseason is far from over, but the Bears are off to go a good start – even if one move appears to be less-than-flattering.

written by

Luis C. Medina, who you can find on Twitter at lcm1986, has been covering the Chicago Bears at Bleacher Nation since 2017. Since then, he has written about 3 head coaches, 5 play-callers, and 11 starting quarterbacks. Previously, Luis wrote about the Cubs and MLB at BN (2015-16) and worked in the Chicago Tribune sports department (2011-16). He also co-hosted a Cubs postgame show, Outside the Ivy, in 2019.

more bears news

The Lions Got Busted For OTA Rule Violations

The Detroit Lions are being punished for violating the NFL's rules on permissible contact during organized team activities. ESPN's Adam Schefter has the news of the Lions' punishment, while the team has issued a statement on the matter: https://twitter.com/Lions/status/1799237945477534086 "On...

Steve “Mongo” McMichael Won’t Travel to Canton For Hall of Fame Induction

Steve McMichael's Hall of Fame enshrinement and induction into the Pro Football Hall of Fame is one of the top stories of 2024. And while it isn't tarnished one bit by the fact that he won't be in attendance for...

Another 1st Round Pick Signs, Precautionary Measures on the Injury Front, How Much Football Do You Want? And Other Bears Bullets

I get to play the role of Uncle Lu today for my other godchild. Hopefully, the weather stays nice enough for long enough for us to make her first trip to Chicago worthwhile. Chicago Bears rookie quarterback Caleb Williams on...

Caleb Williams Has High Hopes For the Bears: “We’re Gonna Be Pretty Damn Good”

'Tis the season for endless optimism. And when it is coming from QB1, you know I'm going to re-share it. "There's a light at the end of that tunnel," said Chicago Bears quarterback Caleb Williams, via the Chicago Sun-Times. "Right...

Around the NFL: Colts Center Doesn’t Hold Back on 18-Game Schedule, Jacobs Apologizes, Gregory Sues, More

NFL Notes — Indianapolis Colts center Ryan Kelly didn't mince words when asked about the NFL's proposal to eventually add an 18th regular-season game to the schedule. Colts Center to Roger Goodell on the 18-game Schedule: "Put a helmet on...

The Pressure is Shifting to the Bears to Put More into Their Stadium Proposal

It was around this time last year when momentum for the Chicago Bears building a new stadium in Arlington Heights began slowing down. If you'll recall, it was on June 2 of last year when reports surfaced that building on...

Caleb’s Bounce-back, Herbert’s Last Stand, 93 Days, and Other Bears Bullets

I have a friend in town who is bringing their two children to visit Chicago for the first time. From the time I pick them up from the airport, they'll be getting a full lesson on Caleb Williams and Bears...

Caleb Williams Rookie Contract Status Update: When Will He Sign?

Here's how peaceful things are at Halas Hall: Caleb Williams, the No. 1 overall pick in the 2024 NFL Draft, has yet to sign his rookie contract. And yet, there have been no whispers of a holdout and no buzz...

How and When You Can Get Chicago Bears Training Camp Tickets

Summer break is underway for the Chicago Bears. Next up, training camp! The Bears just announced their training camp schedule, so clear your calendars. Chicago Bears 2024 Training Camp Practice Schedule These are the dates in which Chicago's football team...

Summer Break Begins Now For the Chicago Bears

The 2024 season promises to be an entertaining one for the Chicago Bears and their fans. This team has games on Sunday Night Football, Monday Night Football, and Thursday Night Football on its schedule. It also has a trip to...

Latest News

Tigers vs. Brewers: Injury Report, Updates & Probable Starters – June 9

On Sunday, the Detroit Tigers (31-33) are hosting the Milwaukee Brewers (38-26), at 1:40 PM ET. The Tigers have lost three in a row.Looking to see who's available to play for the Tigers and the Brewers? Continue reading to get...

Royals vs. Mariners: Injury Report, Updates & Probable Starters – June 9

The Kansas City Royals (39-26) will host the Seattle Mariners (36-30), Sunday at 2:10 PM ET, with the Royals on a three-game winning streak.Hoping to find out who's available to play for the Royals and the Mariners? Keep reading to...

Red Sox vs. White Sox: Injury Report, Updates & Probable Starters – June 9

At Guaranteed Rate Field on Sunday, the Boston Red Sox (32-33) meet the Chicago White Sox (17-48), with first pitch at 2:10 PM ET.Hoping to find out who's in and who's out for the Red Sox and the White Sox?...

Rangers vs. Giants: Injury Report, Updates & Probable Starters – June 9

On Sunday, the San Francisco Giants (32-33) are visiting the Texas Rangers (30-34), at 1:05 PM ET. The Giants have won three straight.Want to see who's in and who's out for the Rangers and the Giants? Keep reading to see...

Phillies vs. Mets: Injury Report, Updates & Probable Starters – June 9

On Sunday, the Philadelphia Phillies (45-19) are hosting the New York Mets (27-36), at 10:10 AM ET. The Phillies have taken four straight.Looking to see who's in and who's out for the Phillies and the Mets? Continue scrolling to see...

Cubs vs. Reds: Injury Report, Updates & Probable Starters – June 9

On Sunday, the Chicago Cubs (31-34) are visiting the Cincinnati Reds (32-33), at 1:40 PM ET. The Cubs have lost three straight.Want to see who's playing for the Cubs and the Reds? Continue reading for full injury reports for both...

Marlins vs. Guardians: Injury Report, Updates & Probable Starters – June 9

The Cleveland Guardians (40-22) will visit the Miami Marlins (22-41), in the final game of a two-game series, Sunday at 1:40 PM ET.Looking to see who's in and who's out for the Marlins and the Guardians? Continue reading for full...

Braves vs. Nationals: Injury Report, Updates & Probable Starters – June 9

The Washington Nationals (29-35) and Atlanta Braves (35-27) will meet on Sunday at Nationals Park, with first pitch at 1:35 PM ET.Hoping to find out who's playing for the Braves and the Nationals? Keep scrolling to see full injury reports...

Cardinals vs. Rockies: Injury Report, Updates & Probable Starters – June 9

The St. Louis Cardinals (30-33) will host the Colorado Rockies (23-41), in the final game of a four-game series, Sunday at 2:15 PM ET.Looking to see who's in and who's out for the Cardinals and the Rockies? Continue reading to...

Orioles vs. Rays: Injury Report, Updates & Probable Starters – June 9

The Tampa Bay Rays (31-33) and Baltimore Orioles (41-22) will meet on Sunday at Tropicana Field, starting at 1:40 PM ET.Curious about who's in and who's out for the Orioles and the Rays? Keep reading for complete injury reports for...

more bears news