Matt Garza Impressed at Least One Scout Last Night, But There’s Still a Trading Hang-Up

matt garza chinTo even the casual observer, Matt Garza’s outing last night was impressive. He was showing pre-injury velocity, good breaking stuff, and he was getting plenty of swings and misses. Good, good, right?

Did scouts see the same thing that we did? According CBS’s Danny Knobler, at least one scout did. That scout, who partly joked to Knobler that he’d take Garza “NOW,” said that the velocity looked good, the stuff looked good, the ability to throw all of his pitches looked good, and Garza wasn’t “babying” his breaking pitches. All very good signs.

Obviously it’s great to hear that scouts were impressed, and it would be great for the Cubs to have the option of shopping Garza to the highest bidder in July. But don’t let the buzz get to your head just yet.

Even if Garza is completely healthy, and even if teams have no fear that he will remain healthy throughout the rest of the season, there is still a reason to clutch your prospects tightly when dealing for Garza.

He’s merely a rental.

By the time the Cubs seriously shop Garza – if they do at all – there will be just two or two and a half months left in the season. Garza might give your team 10 to 12 starts over that stretch. How much is even the best pitcher worth for just a handful of starts? In the days of the prior CBA, a team could send off a top prospect or two for Garza, and resign itself to the fact that, even if it couldn’t re-sign Garza after the season, the team would still get a compensatory draft pick or two for its trouble.

Now, players traded midseason do not qualify for draft pick compensation. So, a team trading for Garza is getting nothing more than just those handful of starts and a shot at the playoffs.

That said, teams greatly value that shot at the playoffs. And a guy like Garza very much could be the difference between playing in October or sitting at home. Indeed, Garza may prove to be the single best trade chip available on the market for improving your 2013 team.

These competing concepts make the Garza value proposition difficult to articulate. Team A might be willing to part with no more than a top ten system prospect for him. Team B might be willing to part with a top 100 overall prospect.

It seems like, assuming health and effectiveness, the majority of interested trade partners are likely to fall into the latter category. And, if their recent trading history tells us anything, we can safely assume that Theo Epstein and Jed Hoyer aren’t going to pull the trigger on a Garza trade until they feel like they’ve maximized value (indeed, sometimes they hold out to a fault).

Hopefully this year it works.

… if they don’t sign him to an extension, that is.

written by

Brett Taylor is the Lead Cubs Writer at Bleacher Nation, and you can find him on Twitter at @BleacherNation and on LinkedIn here. Brett is also the founder of Bleacher Nation, which opened up shop in 2008 as an independent blog about the Chicago Cubs. Later growing to incorporate coverage of other Chicago sports, Bleacher Nation is now one of the largest regional sports blogs on the web.

more cubs news

Chicago Cubs Lineup: PCA Back in Center with the Wind Blowing Out

CUBS LINEUP — The Cubs are now a season-low four games under .500 and a season-high 7.5 games out of first place. And it's mid-June. If the turnaround doesn't happen soon, it's probably not going to happen at all. But...

Wicks Becomes Hendricks, Roberts and Roster Decisions, Wisdom Versus the Wind, and Other Cubs Bullets

The Cubs should just start cheating at this point. I'm not 100% on the how, but just figure it out. Craig Counsell says Jordan Wicks will get imaging on his oblique today and is likely to be placed on the...

Moises Ballesteros Hit For The Cycle!

Starting the day with something positive, since so much of what else is going on is ... not. Chicago Cubs prospect Moises Ballesteros, for whom you could make a strong argument as the best hitting prospect in the org, had...

Tennessee Walking Off At the Men’s College World Series Was Incredible! (I was there!)

I mentioned earlier this week in my Blackhawks bullets that my middle son's travel baseball team is playing in the enormous "Slumpbuster" tournament in/around Omaha this week/weekend and we made a stop to see the beautiful Charles Schwab Field, the...

Watch A Minor-League Sammy Sosa Hit an Inside the Park Homer Because You Deserve It

Take it from someone who writes far too many words about the Chicago Bulls – sometimes you need to look into the past to feel any sort of happiness. As the Chicago Cubs continue their remarkably frustrating play, a clip...

Enhanced Box Score: Cardinals 3, Cubs 0 – June 14, 2024

The Cubs lost their starting pitcher, barely even threatened to score, wasted a brilliant bullpen day, and lost the game. It's not quite the same 'ole story, but it might as well be. Jordan Wicks injured his oblique in the...

Jordan Wicks Just Had to Leave with the Athletic Trainer (UPDATE)

Just two appearances into his return from the Injured List (forearm), and having just taken over the rotation spot vacated by Ben Brown (neck stress reaction), something's not right with Jordan Wicks. And he had to leave today's game after...

Cubs Farm Report | June 14, 2024: A Day to Forget, Wiggins Solid Again, More

Cubs Prospects — It was a day to forget for the Cubs affiliates as there wasn't a victory in the lot. Cubs Farm Report | June 14, 2024 Triple-A Iowa Cubs Prospects The Iowa Cubs lost to the Columbus Clippers...

Pre-Gamin’: Cardinals at Cubs (1:20 CT) – Lineups, Broadcast Info, Game Thread

CUBS LINEUP — Friday. 1:20. Cardinals. Wrigley Field. The Cubs are a mess right now, but that's a combination that still gets me excited. Here's a look at the Cubs lineup for Game 1 in Chicago. Chicago Cubs Lineup: Mike...

Jose Abreu Released by the Houston Astros

A former American League MVP is now officially on the market. According to Jeff Passan, the Houston Astros have released first baseman Jose Abreu, despite owing him more than $30 million on the free agent deal he signed with Houston...

Latest News

Dodgers vs. Royals Prediction: Expert Picks, Odds, Stats & Best Bets – Saturday, June 15, 2024

Shohei Ohtani, batting .309 this season, leads the Los Angeles Dodgers (43-28) into a matchup with one of the league's other top hitters, Bobby Witt Jr. (.325 AVG) and the Kansas City Royals (40-31). Ohtani and the Dodgers are -218...

Pirates vs. Rockies Prediction: Expert Picks, Odds, Stats & Best Bets – Saturday, June 15, 2024

Bryan Reynolds (12 games) will look to add to his hitting streak when the Pittsburgh Pirates (33-36) and Colorado Rockies (24-45) meet Saturday at 9:10 PM ET, live on COLR from Coors Field. Reynolds and the Pirates are favored by...

Saturday’s WNBA Picks and Predictions – June 15

Today's WNBA schedule has lots in store. Among those two games is the New York Liberty playing the Las Vegas Aces.Keep reading and you'll find WNBA best bets for the contests on today's slate.WNBA picks todayNew York Liberty at Las...

Diamondbacks vs. White Sox Probable Starting Pitchers – June 15

The Arizona Diamondbacks (34-36) play at home against the Chicago White Sox (18-53) on Saturday. The matchup is set to begin at 10:10 PM ET.The Diamondbacks will give the nod to Scott McGough (1-3, 5.85 ERA), who is eyeing win...

Dodgers vs. Royals Probable Starting Pitchers – June 15

The Kansas City Royals (40-31) visit the Los Angeles Dodgers (43-28) for a road game in Los Angeles on Saturday. The game begins at 9:10 PM ET.The Dodgers will give the nod to Yoshinobu Yamamoto (6-2) against the Royals and...

Pirates vs. Rockies Probable Starting Pitchers – June 15

The Pittsburgh Pirates (33-36) face the Colorado Rockies (24-45) in Denver at 9:10 PM ET on Saturday.The Pirates will give the nod to Jared Jones (4-5, 3.27 ERA), who is eyeing win No. 5 on the season, and the Rockies...

Chicago Cubs Lineup: PCA Back in Center with the Wind Blowing Out

CUBS LINEUP — The Cubs are now a season-low four games under .500 and a season-high 7.5 games out of first place. And it's mid-June. If the turnaround doesn't happen soon, it's probably not going to happen at all. But...

Mariners vs. Rangers Prediction: Expert Picks, Odds, Stats & Best Bets – Saturday, June 15, 2024

The Seattle Mariners (41-31) are favorites (-142) on the moneyline when they square off against the Texas Rangers (33-36) Saturday at 7:15 PM ET, live on FOX.Seattle's George Kirby gets the start, and he'll go against Texas' Nathan Eovaldi.Mariners vs....

Yankees vs. Red Sox Prediction: Expert Picks, Odds, Stats & Best Bets – Saturday, June 15, 2024

Carlos Rodon will take the mound for the New York Yankees (50-22) Saturday looking for his 10th win of the season in a matchup with the Boston Red Sox (35-35). The Yankees are -173 favorites to pick up the win...

Kmet, Pace, Cunningham, Poles, Bagent, and Other Bears Bullets

A brief and random collection of scatter-brained Bears thoughts for your Saturday morning because my head is all over the place. I still can't believe the Atlanta Falcons turned down a fourth-round pick from the Bears to move back one...

more cubs news