Lukewarm Stove: Cruz, Trading Starters, Struggling Free Agents, Exploiting an Inefficiency

Jan 03, 2014

The quiet of the holidays is likely to end next week. Still, there’s plenty to discuss …

The Nelson Cruz market continues to be slow, to put it kindly. The outfield slugger appears to have scared suitors off earlier in the offseason with some hilariously lofty demands (complete with rumors that he turned down a five-year, $75 million offer from the Mariners), and now budgets are shrinking and cocked eyes are becoming even cockier about a 33-year-old coming off a PED suspension. FanGraphs reviews the possible landing places for Cruz, and comes up with just one fit – Baltimore – though the Cubs and a handful of other teams qualify as a “stretch.” In terms of outfield composition and the theoretical desire to add a couple wins in 2014, the Cubs could use Cruz. At the outset of the offseason, I targeted him as an intriguing buy-very-very-low candidate for the Cubs, given their needs and the subsequent possibility of flipping him (for greater value than the second round pick it would cost to sign him). I suppose I could still see some surplus value if he has to settle for a two-year, $20 million contract – but, at that point, would he consider just sitting out until after the draft to remove the noose of draft pick compensation?

Ken Rosenthal continues to believe the Diamondbacks, who are among the suitors for Masahiro Tanaka, are more likely to sign a free agent starter than trade for one (i.e., Jeff Samardzija).

Speaking of trading for starters, once the Tanaka market sorts itself out (and the subsequent Garza/Jimenez/Santana market), we’ll see an uptick in trade rumors once again. With the Red Sox having more veteran starters than they can use, and John Lackey presenting a clear “sell-high, nice contract” opportunity, will he be another presence on the market to compete with the Cubs’ efforts to shop Samardzija (should that occur)? Ian Browne says it would take a “stunning development” like signing Tanaka to get the Red Sox to trade Lackey. Instead, they seem more likely to deal one of Jake Peavy or Ryan Dempster, should they feel a trade is necessary.

Kiley McDaniel got folks talking earlier in the week with a report that the Yankees are going to pull a Cubs and go nuts on the international free agent market this year, and he now offers a little more clarity on the “why Yankees, why now” questions that popped up in the aftermath. He works in an apt tragedy of the commons reference, which means it’s a good read.

In an untended consequence that was foreseen by anyone paying attention long before the 2012 season, the market for non-elite free agents who received qualifying offers has once again been jacked. Jeff Passan writes about it here. Buster Olney here. As we’ve discussed, the problem isn’t solely the attachment of draft pick compensation; nor is it solely the draft changes (effective hard slotting with a bonus pool). It’s the combination of the two. Draft picks – and the pool space associated with them – are more valuable than ever. That’s tough noogies for Cruz, Ervin Santana, Ubaldo Jimenez, Stephen Drew, and Kendrys Morales. The current CBA doesn’t expire until after 2016, and you can bet these twin issues will be addressed. It’s possible they could be changed even sooner, but I wouldn’t count on it.

Any time there are problems like this, inefficiencies arise. The inefficiency I see here? Teams with a protected first round pick, and with the ability to sit around and wait on the tough noogies free agents until January/February, should go nuts and grab as many of those types as they can in a single year. Why? Well, they stand to benefit not only from the depressed prices on the free agents, but they lose only a second round pick (and pool money) for the first guy they sign, and then a third/fourth/etc. pick for the latter guys. In other words, the effective price goes down for each additional guy you sign. Very few teams are going to be in a position to execute this kind of strategy, but the Cubs certainly are. The problem this year? Morales and Drew are not fits, and Cruz (as discussed above) is barely a fit. One of Santana or Jimenez could make sense, but probably not both. And then you’ve got the issue of convincing guys like these to actually sign with a rebuilding club whom you know is probably just looking to sign you for surplus value (which can later be captured in the form of a trade). Maybe next year?

written by

Brett Taylor

Brett Taylor is the Lead Cubs Writer at Bleacher Nation, and you can find him on Twitter at @BleacherNation and on LinkedIn here. Brett is also the founder of Bleacher Nation, which opened up shop in 2008 as an independent blog about the Chicago Cubs. Later growing to incorporate coverage of other Chicago sports, Bleacher Nation is now one of the largest regional sports blogs on the web.

more cubs news

Chicago Cubs

Chicago Cubs Lineup: Loading Up on Righties

CUBS LINEUP — The Cubs have played thirteen series so far this season, and this is already their eighth rubber match. Let's see if Kyle Hendricks and the Cubs can bring this one in. Chicago Cubs Lineup: Nico Hoerner, SS...

Michael Cerami

May 12, 2024

Chicago Cubs

Horrible History, Morel’s Knee, Almonte’s Shoulder, Hoerner, Wesneski, Hendricks, Mervis, and Other Cubs Bullets

Happy Mother's Day to the mothers among you, and to the mothers in my life! I'll be doing some extra family stuff today, so I'm gonna cruise through these Bullets ... Up front, because this was certainly the thing most...

Brett Taylor

May 12, 2024

Chicago Cubs

Kyle Hendricks Will Start for the Big League Cubs Tomorrow

The Sunday TBD has been D'd, and it's going to be Kyle Hendricks coming back an outing early. Instead of making another rehab start at Iowa, Hendricks is going to be activated from the IL to rejoin the rotation tomorrow:...

Brett Taylor

May 11, 2024

Chicago Cubs

Enhanced Box Score: Pirates 10, Cubs 9 – May 11, 2024

The Cubs came within 90 feet of keeping that ridiculous game going. No dice. Stupid game. Early on, it just kinda seemed like the Cubs might lose a perfectly normal - bad, but normal - game. Justin Steele did not...

Brett Taylor

May 11, 2024

Chicago Cubs

Pre-Gamin’: Cubs at Pirates (3:05 CT) – Lineups, Broadcast Info, Game Thread

CUBS LINEUP — After a little tease yesterday, Seiya Suzuki is actually, officially in the Cubs lineup today. And he'll be greeted with a tough matchup against the top pitching prospect in Major League Baseball. Welcome back! Chicago Cubs Lineup:...

Michael Cerami

May 11, 2024

Chicago Cubs

Oh, Good, Yency Almonte is Now Also Hurt

Today the Chicago Cubs placed reliever Yency Almonte on the Injured List with a right shoulder strain. Jose Cuas has been recalled from Iowa to take his place in the bullpen. Almonte, together with Mark Leiter Jr., had been performing...

Brett Taylor

May 11, 2024

Chicago Cubs

Credit to Assad, Huge Ups to Brown, Hopes for Taillon, Happ’s Bat and Glove, Bellinger History, and Other Cubs Bullets

How did I not know that the Aurora Borealis was going to be visible last night?!?!? I woke up this morning to all these awesome pictures from friends and other people in the area, and I'm MISERABLE ABOUT IT. With...

Brett Taylor

May 11, 2024

Chicago Cubs

24 Years Ago Today, Glenallen Hill Hit a Home Run ONTO a Wrigley Field Rooftop

In 2015, Kyle Schwarber hit a monster home run onto the top of the right field scoreboard at Wrigley Field, where it stayed for the remainder of the postseason. Watching the game live, I remember thinking "Dang, he got all...

Michael Cerami

May 11, 2024

Chicago Cubs

Cade Horton Had His First Really Rough Night

Usually, I like to use this space to celebrate a great game from a top Cubs prospect, but sometimes, it's important to note when the other thing happens. Last night, Cade Horton had his very first really bad start. He...

Brett Taylor

May 11, 2024

Chicago Cubs

Enhanced Box Score: Cubs 7, Pirates 2 – May 10, 2024

Although I'm sure Craig Counsell would've preferred not to have to use Ben Brown today, just in case Jameson Taillon can't go on Sunday. But *if* you were going to have to use Brown today, that was an absolute best-case...

Brett Taylor

May 10, 2024

Picks

Braves vs. Mets Prediction: Expert Picks, Odds, Stats & Best Bets – Sunday, May 12, 2024

Expect a display of power when Marcell Ozuna (12 HR) and the Atlanta Braves (24-12) take on Pete Alonso (4 HR) and the New York Mets (18-20) at Citi Field at 7:10 PM ET live on ESPN. Ozuna and the...

Data Skrive

May 12, 2024

Chicago Bulls

What are the 2024 NBA Draft Lottery Odds?

The NBA Draft Lottery has arrived. Despite the lackluster nature of this year's prospect pool, this remains a highly-anticipated day for teams around the league. The truth of the matter is that the opportunity to snag a high pick is...

Elias Schuster

May 12, 2024

Chicago Cubs

Chicago Cubs Lineup: Loading Up on Righties

Michael Cerami

May 12, 2024

Picks

Top Player Prop Bets for Pacers vs. Knicks Eastern Conference Semifinals Game 4 on May 12, 2024

Player props are listed for Pascal Siakam and Jalen Brunson, among others, when the Indiana Pacers host the New York Knicks at Gainbridge Fieldhouse on Sunday at 3:30 PM ET.How to Watch Pacers vs. KnicksDate: Sunday, May 12, 2024Time: 3:30...

Data Skrive

May 12, 2024

Picks

Braves vs. Mets Probable Starting Pitchers – May 12

Following a stretch of four consecutive wins, the Atlanta Braves (24-12) play the New York Mets (18-20) at 7:10 PM ET on Sunday.The Braves will give the nod to Bryce Elder (1-1, 5.28 ERA), who is eyeing win No. 2...

Data Skrive

May 12, 2024

Picks

Avalanche vs. Stars NHL Playoffs Second Round Game 4 Prediction: Picks, Live Odds and Moneyline – Monday, May 13, 2024

The sportsbooks prefer the Colorado Avalanche at home (-135) over the Dallas Stars (+114) when they meet on Monday, May 13 at 9:30 PM ET.Watch the NHL on Fubo!Avalanche vs. Stars Favorite, Moneyline, TotalFavorite: Avalanche (-135)Underdog: Stars (+114)Total: 6.5Best Avalanche...

Data Skrive

May 12, 2024

Chicago Bulls

Release the Ping Pong Balls, Second Round Picks, MJ’s 3-Point Shooting, and Other Bulls Bullets

If there was an Equipment Manager of the Year award, I think my aunt might deserve it. Having to leave at about 5 a.m. to drive to my sibling's college graduation on Saturday, I may have kinda sorta broken my...

Elias Schuster

May 12, 2024

Picks

Hurricanes vs. Rangers NHL Playoffs Second Round Game 5 Prediction: Odds, Picks, Best Bets – Monday, May 13, 2024

The oddsmakers are expecting a close game between the Carolina Hurricanes and New York Rangers on Monday in New York City, with the Hurricanes given moneyline odds of -118 and the Rangers at -102.Watch the NHL on Fubo!Hurricanes vs. Rangers...

Data Skrive

May 12, 2024

Chicago Blackhawks

World Championships Updates, Great Stars, Canes Survive, Still No Q, and Other Blackhawks Mother’s Day Bullets

Happy Mother's Day to all of the wonderful moms out there. My sons are incredibly fortunate to have a great mom and two wonderful grandmas still in their lives. We hear Blackhawks players talk about hot much they appreciate their...