There May Be No Perfect Answer, But It’s Time for Another Change at Leadoff

Statistically, viewed as numbers on a sheet with a large enough sample, we all know that players are supposed to perform/produce at the same level in any one specific situation as they otherwise would have throughout their career. And yet, in reality, we know that’s not always the case.

Well, I should clarify: under some circumstances and/or with some players, that uniformity of performance seems to hold true. And yet for others, well, humans are humans. Not everyone is cut out for the 9th inning. Not everyone can take the hill for Game 7 of the World Series. And, of apparent recent note for the Cubs, not everyone can lead off.

Since Dexter Fowler left the team after the 2016 season, Joe Maddon and the front office has tried just about everything to fill the void he left behind, without much success. They’ve played the matchups (Albert Almora Jr.), they’ve tried forcing the issue (Kyle Schwarber), they’ve used it as a slump buster (Anthony Rizzo), they’ve gone with veterans (Ben Zobrist), they’ve gone with rookies (Robel Garcia), they’ve been unorthodox (Willson Contreras), and they’ve tried the hot hand (Jason Heyward). And yet … here we are, three years later, with no consistent answer to the leadoff question.

But it’s not like they can just throw their hands up and call it a day, because someone has to bat first. Lately, it’s been Heyward, much more out of necessity than out of a sense of a perfect fit.

Which brings me to the point of today’s post: it’s time for another change.

Those were Heyward’s leadoff vs. anywhere else numbers before going 0-4 with a walk and two strikeouts last night, which only strengthens the point. It’s time for a change, and it really could be better for everyone, including Heyward, who has always hit a little worse out of the top spot:

Leadoff (166 games): .249/.333/.396
Not Leadoff (1,165 games): .264/.345/.416

For whatever reason – you can try to play armchair psychologist, you can point out tougher matchups (especially later in the game), you can point to the extra at-bat every now and then, whatever – Jason Heyward has hit for a lower average, OBP, and SLG when he leads off than when he does not. Perhaps it hasn’t always been as dramatic as it has been this season, but, well, it’s this season right now, so let’s not keep square-peg-round-holing this thing.

Ideally, a move to another player would (1) improve the production the Cubs have gotten out of the leadoff spot this season (though that’s obviously no guarantee, as the spot has been a black hole all year) and also (2) shake Heyward out of the rut that has begun spoiling what was previously shaping up to be a really nice freakin’ season offensively. (Note: the guys at Cubs Insider got to this topic a little earlier than us, so if you want to check their perspective out, too, it’s a good read.)

The risk in making a swap, of course, is that Heyward doesn’t bounce back in his new spot (likely batting 6th again), and the new guy gets ruined, too, but it almost literally cannot get worse for the Cubs at the top …

wRC+ Leaderboard (batting first):

  1. Rays: 136 wRC+
  2. Astros: 135 wRC+
  3. Mets: 128 wRC+
  4. Twins: 124 wRC+
  5. Yankees: 123 wRC+

  1. Cubs: 72 wRC+
  2. Tigers: 70 wRC+

Good Lord.

But what are the options? Well, there aren’t many great ones. I get that.

Based on my experience with Joe Maddon, I won’t be surprised to see Ben Zobrist up there immediately upon returning this September when he starts, and I think when he’s not in the lineup, the Cubs could probably give Ian Happ a look. He hasn’t been perfect since his return to the Cubs from Triple-A, but he does have a 109 wRC+ built primarily on a 12.9% walk rate and a vastly improved 24.7% strikeout rate.

And if deployed primarily against right-handed pitchers, Happ could bring a 14.8% walk rate, 19.7% strikeout rate, and a .344 OBP to the leadoff role (plus a little speed, to boot). I have very little confidence that he or Zobrist, for that matter, are definitely going to be the answer the rest of the way, but that’s no reason not to try, especially when the current solution is not working for the player or the team. Also, both guys have done it before.

But whatever. It doesn’t have to be one of them on a dedicated basis, but something does have to change. And until Joe Maddon concedes to permanently moving a guy like Anthony Rizzo or Kris Bryant there, the Cubs will probably continue dealing with issues and inconsistencies at the top of the lineup.

Then it will once again be a huge offseason talking point …

(Photo by Stacy Revere/Getty Images)

written by

Michael Cerami covers the Chicago Cubs, Bears, and Bulls at Bleacher Nation. You can find him on Twitter @Michael_Cerami

more cubs news

Internal and External Improvements, Morel, Hendricks, Taillon, Soto, Molina, Leeper, and Other Cubs Bullets

The Winter Meetings are over, and although that always means something of an exhale for me after four days of very late nights and trying to grind through the day, this year's installment doesn't have the benefit of ... anything...

Stray Morning After Winter Meetings Thoughts: Cubs, Candelario, Reds, Soto, Padres, Rodriguez, More

When I sat down this morning to start writing, I realized I was just kind of piling up some stray after-the-meetings thoughts ... Transactionally, the Chicago Cubs did nothing this week at the Winter Meetings, other than picking up a...

REPORT: Jeimer Candelario Signing with the Reds (UPDATES)

Well, for the second time in his career, Jeimer Candelario is leaving the Chicago Cubs for another team. Only this time, he's headed to one of their division rivals: The Cincinnati Reds. Mark Feinsand has the scoop: The Cubs,...

On the Anniversary of the “Arson Judge” Tweet, the Yankees ROAST Jon Heyman

Oh, this is so good. This isn't just "good for the social media manager of a baseball team" good. This is full on excellent comedy execution. The official Yankees' Twitter/X account just landed an all-time burn — one that's both...

Diamondbacks Reportedly a Finalist for Eduardo Rodriguez, Conflicting – Wrong? – Reports About Reds Involvement (UPDATE: DBacks Get Him)

Although he's not necessarily in that top tier of available starting pitchers this offseason, lefty Eduardo Rodriguez could be a very good number three in many rotations. He would, for example, be a noticeable upgrade for the Cincinnati Reds' rotation....

Kinda Sounds Like Yankees Might Get Juan Soto Today (UPDATES: Finally Happening)

It was picking back up last night, but the steam behind a Juan Soto trade to the Yankees seems to be quite robust right now. To such an extent that it sounds like it's going to happen today:

Winter Meetings Wednesday Night: Cubs Have to Head Down Various Paths, Available Trades, Glasnow, Stephenson, More

There will be more to say about the Winter Meetings, and the Juan Soto deal is still likely to be completed eventually ... but man alive, that was absolutely the worst and most boring and awful Winter Meetings ever. Just...

Craig Kimbrel “Close to a Deal” with the Orioles (UPDATE: It’s Done)

Late last night, Joel Sherman reported that the Orioles were "seriously engaged" with free agent reliever (and former Cubs closer) Craig Kimbrel. And this morning, it seems those talks have progressed to "close to a deal" status, which, from Ken...

The 2023 MLB Rule 5 Draft is Underway (UPDATES)

The 2023 MLB Rule 5 Draft has arrived, and I'll be tracking any Cubs-impact-related picks down below. For the uninitiated, the Rule 5 Draft is an opportunity for teams to poach players from other organizations that meet certain criteria. The Draft comes...

Is Cody Bellinger Seeking Upwards of $300 Million in Free Agency?!

Sorry to make today pearl clutching about exorbitant prices day, but I have one to add to the ever-exploding Yoshinobu Yamamoto expectations and the apparent high price the Yankees are paying to acquire Juan Soto from the Padres. This one...

Latest News

Robbie Gould Announces His Retirement

Robbie Gould, long held as the gold-standard of Chicago Bears kickers, announced his retirement from the NFL in social media posts via Instagram and The Players' Tribune. Gould dives deep in his retirement post at The Players' Tribune. And,...

NFL Notes: Former Jaguars Employee Accused of Stealing More than $22 Million, Robbie Gould Retires, More

According to a report by The Athletic's Katie Strang and Kalyn Kahler, a former Jacksonville Jaguars employee is accused of stealing more than $22 million from the franchise from 2019 to 2023 by exploiting the team's virtual credit card program....

Panthers’ Hayden Hurst Dealing With Post Traumatic Amnesia

It was almost a month ago that Carolina Panthers' tight end Hayden Hurts entered the league's concussion protocol. Hurst took a big hit against the Chicago Bears on Thursday Night Football in Week 10, and he has been sidelined since....

DeVante Parker Player Props Week 14: Anytime TD Props and Odds vs. the Steelers

[lasso ref="draftkings-promo-1" id="299003" link_id="896437"]Will DeVante Parker get into the end zone when the New England Patriots and the Pittsburgh Steelers come together in Week 14 on Thursday at 8:15 PM ET? In the piece below, we dive into his anytime...

Brook Lopez Player Props: Three-Pointer Props and Odds vs. the Pacers – Thursday, December 7, 2023

To beat his 3-point prop, Brook Lopez must make two from downtown on Thursday, when his Milwaukee Bucks play the Indiana Pacers on Thursday at 5:00 PM ET.Brook Lopez's Three-Pointer Prop Odds vs. the PacersBrook Lopez's over/under for three-pointers in...

Myles Turner Player Props: Three-Pointer Props and Odds vs. the Bucks – Thursday, December 7, 2023

The Indiana Pacers face the Milwaukee Bucks at 5:00 PM ET on Thursday, and one of the 3-pointer props available for this clash requires two triples from Myles Turner.Myles Turner's Three-Pointer Prop Odds vs. the BucksMyles Turner's over/under for three-pointers...

Tyrese Haliburton Player Props: Three-Pointer Props and Odds vs. the Bucks – Thursday, December 7, 2023

Will Tyrese Haliburton drain five 3-pointers when the Indiana Pacers play the Milwaukee Bucks on Thursday at 5:00 PM ET? If so, he'll beat his over/under for the game.Tyrese Haliburton's Three-Pointer Prop Odds vs. the BucksTyrese Haliburton's over/under for three-pointers...

Giannis Antetokounmpo Player Props: Three-Pointer Props and Odds vs. the Pacers – Thursday, December 7, 2023

The Milwaukee Bucks face the Indiana Pacers at 5:00 PM ET on Thursday, and one of the 3-pointer props available for this matchup requires just one trifecta from Giannis Antetokounmpo.Giannis Antetokounmpo's Three-Pointer Prop Odds vs. the PacersGiannis Antetokounmpo's over/under for...

Damian Lillard Player Props: Three-Pointer Props and Odds vs. the Pacers – Thursday, December 7, 2023

Will Damian Lillard drain four 3-pointers when the Milwaukee Bucks meet the Indiana Pacers on Thursday at 5:00 PM ET? If so, he'll beat his prop for the game.Damian Lillard's Three-Pointer Prop Odds vs. the PacersDamian Lillard's over/under for three-pointers...

Bruce Brown Player Props: Three-Pointer Props and Odds vs. the Bucks – Thursday, December 7, 2023

Bruce Brown's Indiana Pacers face the Milwaukee Bucks on Thursday at 5:00 PM ET, and to beat his 3-point over/under, he needs to make two from beyond the arc.Bruce Brown's Three-Pointer Prop Odds vs. the BucksBruce Brown's over/under for three-pointers...

more cubs news