A Non-Playoff Team Fan’s Guide to Rooting for the MLB Postseason

Both baseball teams in Chicago will, like their fans, be watching the Postseason from their couches this October. While it would be nice to have a hometown rooting interest in the Postseason, there’s no reason why we still shouldn’t enjoy some October baseball.

Now, I – Patrick, a White Sox fan – can guarantee that we’re not going to agree with my top pick for teams to root for (which I’ll explain), but we might see eye-to-eye otherwise. Or not, which should make for some fun discourse in the comments section.

I’m going to rank the teams that I’m rooting for this October in a pyramid tier fashion, and it’ll be based on factors like geographic or divisional rivalry, players on the teams that I enjoy watching, and my general enjoyment in watching underdogs win when I have no real rooting interest.

Without further ado, I shall set the Disqus section ablaze:

Tier 1: Really Want to See them Win it All

St. Louis Cardinals (Last World Series Win: 2011)

I’m sorry. I really am. But, for me (and remember, this is my rankings, and the exercise will hopefully prompt you to build your own and share), I have a family loyalty to the Cardinals. When my Grandpa Jack moved to the Chicagoland area, he was already a Cardinals fan. With no baseball team in that market, he listened to the Cardinals on KMOX on his transistor radio. Grandpa Jack moved from South Carolina to St. Louis, where his affection for the Cardinals grew, and then when he moved to Chicago, he continued to catch the games on the radio, a tradition he shared with my dad.

Grandpa Jack passed when my dad was just out of high school, so the Cardinals fandom (in addition to his White Sox fandom) was something that my dad kept close to his heart over the years and shared with me and my siblings.

So, my rooting for the Cardinals has nothing to do with the Cubs whatsoever – I’m not just trolling – and I’ll apologize the masses here this one time.

Atlanta Braves (Last World Series Win: 2021)

The Braves are another team I have a soft spot for because of their accessibility on the TBS Superstation during my formative years as a baseball fan. I probably watched as much Braves baseball as I did White Sox, because they on TBS every day and, well, they were pretty fun to watch in the mid-to-late 90s. Chipper Jones, Andruw Jones, Maddux, Glavine, Smoltz, Furcal, etc.

Those were some of my fondest baseball-watching memories as a kid during that time of my life, so, I root for the Braves when I have no other rooting interest involved.

Seattle Mariners (Last World Series Win: None)

The Mariners just snapped a two-decade playoff drought and have never appeared in a World Series, even with some of the incredibly talented teams they had in the early 00s, which is just wild to me. Julio Rodriguez is one of baseball’s most exciting young players, and I love rooting for underdogs!

Tampa Bay Rays (Last World Series Win: None)

Despite making two trips to the World Series in recent history, the Rays haven’t been able to finish it off and win their first World Series Championship. The Rays do it right, year in and year out, and play have pioneered many things considered the modern-day norm in baseball. I would love to see them rewarded for those efforts.

Tier 2: Meh

San Diego Padres (Last World Series Win: None)

Like the Rays, the Padres are 0-for-2 in their pair of World Series appearances. San Diego went all in, and I wouldn’t mind seeing them play the underdog card in an absolutely loaded National League playoff field. I also kind of selfishly want them to win it because I’m of the belief that teams should never covet their prospects more than a generational talent like, say, Juan Soto. Like Billy Napier (and later Young Jeezy) said, scared money doesn’t make money.

New York Mets (Last World Series Win: 1986)

For that same logic, I should probably want the biggest chickens (outside of 333 W. 35th St.) at the trade deadline to be in the bottom tier, but I just really loathe that tier, so, by default the Mets are a “meh” team for me.

Seeing Edwin Diaz come into the game to Timmy Trumpet’s ‘Narco’ blasting on a chilly fall night with a packed house erupting in the Postseason seems like a good time to me, so at least they’ve got that going for them.

Toronto Blue Jays (Last World Series Win: 1993)

Another team that could have very easily made it into the bottom tier here (for beating the White Sox in the 1993 ALCS) is the Blue Jays. But I was stilling eating boogers in ’93 (I was three!) and Canadians are so nice, so I’m whatever when it comes to this one.

Philadelphia Phillies (Last World Series Win: 2008)

The Phillies were a fun story this season until they almost shat the bed and authored their biggest collapse since 1964. Still, they were able to rattle off a series win and a couple more in the final week of the season and backed their way into their first Postseason berth in a decade, so congrats, I suppose.

Tier 3: Good Thing it’s Football Season

Cleveland Guardians (Last World Series Win: 1948)

The Guardians haven’t won a World Series since 1948 and we all know very well around here what happened the last time they played in the Fall Classic. They dribbled down their legs and blew it.

I’m actually envious of the way the Guardians built their roster, defied all expectations, and I think that Terry Francona is a great manager, so I will tip my cap to them for their accomplishments this season. Beyond that, they’ve been a hated division-rival my entire life and unlike the mouth-breathing segment of White Sox fans that rooted for them in the 2016 World Series, I hope they get swept in the first round.

New York Yankees (Last World Series Win: 2009)

I’ll keep this one short and sweet … I hate the Yankees. Always have and always will. If they never win another World Series, we’ll all be better off for it.

Houston Astros (Last World Series Win: 2017)

My favorite memory of the Houston Astros? The White Sox beating them in the 2005 World Series and the Kerry Wood 20 strikeout game. I like nothing else about them.

Los Angeles Dodgers (Last World Series Win: 2020)

Look, I respect the hell out of the decade of dominance that the Dodgers have been riding. Their fans are lucky enough to have aggressive and shrewd owners and front-office members that keep them in the October conversation year after year. They spend, they trade, they develop, and they just win. I respect it.

But for the sake of parity across the game … enough already …

written by

Patrick grew up in Chicago's Bridgeport and Garfield Ridge neighborhoods before moving to the Western Suburbs of Chicago before eventually relocating to the Las Vegas area with his family in 2023. He started with Bleacher Nation in 2021 and has spent time as a Staff Writer and on the Chicago Blackhawks beat. He is currently a writer and editor at Bleacher Nation covering the Chicago Bears and the NFL at large and the author of the Bleacher Nation Newsletter. Patrick is a member of the Pro Football Writers of America (PFWA).

more cubs news

Pete Crow-Armstrong Put on a Show, and Continues to Make a Strong Case for Continued Playing Time

Pete Crow-Armstrong put on a show last night, which I mean in the most literal sense. It was more like a performance than a baseball game. Bases-loaded HBP while showing bunt? OK, sure. Running easily to first on a dropped...

Northwestern Returns to Wrigley Field TWICE This Fall

Northwestern will be making a return to Wrigley Field not just once this season, but twice! Due to the construction of their brand new football stadium, the Cats will be playing five of their seven home games at its temporary...

Impressive Fill-In Guys, Bullpen Health, Roberts, Javy, and Other Cubs Bullets

The Cubs come back home from the Pittsburgh-Atlanta road trip having split it 3-3, and I gotta say, that's a pretty solid outcome when (1) you're facing Jones and Skenes, (2) you're playing three in Atlanta where they'd lost just...

Brennen Davis Homered Again, Back-to-Back with B.J. Murray Jr. (Whom We Should Discuss)

Just about as soon as I could talk about how Brennen Davis had homered for the third time in four games, he homered AGAIN, making it four times in five games. And this time, just for fun, B.J. Murray Jr....

Wake Up and Watch the Cubs Beat the Braves to Salvage the Series

The Chicago Cubs' bats finally came alive last night in Atlanta, albeit with a little bit of help from Braves starting pitcher Charlie Morton. On the other side, Javier Assad was brilliant once again. Good win. Needed win. Enjoy the...

Enhanced Box Score: Cubs 7, Braves 1 – May 15, 2024

The Cubs took the lead on the very first pitch of the game and didn't look back. They needed that. I needed that. Offense up and down the lineup. Two extra-base hits for Seiya Suzuki. Three times on base for...

Curt Casali Has Opted Out of His Cubs Deal and is Already Starting Tonight for the Giants

There's fast, and then there's Curt Casali fast. Er, well, not his basepath speed, but the speed with which he went from catching at Triple-A Iowa for the Cubs to starting behind the plate tonight for the Giants in San...

Mike Tauchman Ends the Cubs Scoreless Streak on the First Pitch of the Game!

The Cubs scored exactly zero runs in their last 18 innings in Atlanta. But Mike Tauchman did not let that streak continue long tonight. On the first pitch of the game, Tauchman lifted one over the left field wall for...

Chicago Cubs Lineup: Happ Sits Again, Still No Nico

CUBS LINEUP — The Cubs have dropped each of the first two games in this series, failing to score a single run. Let's see if the following Cubs lineup can have any more luck against Charlie Morton and the Braves...

Cubs Roster Move: Thompson to the IL, Little Comes Back

Another day, another Injured List move for the Chicago Cubs. And it's another reliever. That's 15 total Cubs hitting the IL at some point already this year. It's May 15. This time, it's Keegan Thompson going on the IL with...

Latest News

Party’s Over? Michael Block Having Rough Go Of It In Round 1 Of The PGA Championship

It appears we won't be getting a repeat performance from last year's PGA Championship darling Michael Block. The club pro from Mission Viejo, California had an epic underdog run during last year's event at Oak Hill Country Club in Rochester....

Pete Crow-Armstrong Put on a Show, and Continues to Make a Strong Case for Continued Playing Time

Pete Crow-Armstrong put on a show last night, which I mean in the most literal sense. It was more like a performance than a baseball game. Bases-loaded HBP while showing bunt? OK, sure. Running easily to first on a dropped...

Phillies vs. Mets Prediction: Expert Picks, Odds, Stats & Best Bets – Thursday, May 16, 2024

The Philadelphia Phillies (31-13) will vie for their fourth straight victory when they host the New York Mets (19-23) on Thursday at 6:40 PM ET on MLB Network. The Phillies are listed as -144 favorites by bookmakers, while the Mets...

Red Sox vs. Rays Prediction: Expert Picks, Odds, Stats & Best Bets – Thursday, May 16, 2024

Thursday's matchup between the Boston Red Sox (22-21) and Tampa Bay Rays (22-22) could go either way, as sportsbooks have declared the game a pick 'em (both teams are even on the moneyline). Action gets underway from Fenway Park at...

Cubs vs. Pirates Probable Starting Pitchers – May 16

The Chicago Cubs (25-19) and the Pittsburgh Pirates (19-25) square off at Wrigley Field on Thursday at 7:40 PM ET, starting a four-game series.The probable starters are Justin Steele for the Cubs and Jared Jones (2-4) for the Pirates.Cubs vs....

Astros vs. Athletics Probable Starting Pitchers – May 16

The Oakland Athletics (19-26), who lost their previous four games, take on the Houston Astros (18-25) at Minute Maid Park on Thursday. First pitch is at 8:10 PM ET.The probable pitchers are Cristian Javier (2-1) for the Astros and Joey...

Detroit Lions Schedule: Dates and Times for All 17 Games, Strength of Schedule, Record Prediction

The Lions are ready for a new season after blowing a 17-point lead in the second half of the NFC Championship game to the 49ers. After a solid draft, they look to reach the Super Bowl in 2024. Check out...

Phillies vs. Mets Probable Starting Pitchers – May 16

After winning their past three games, the Philadelphia Phillies (31-13) host the New York Mets (19-23) at Citizens Bank Park on Thursday at 6:40 PM ET.The Phillies will call on Taijuan Walker (3-0) against the Mets and Jose Quintana (1-4).Phillies...

Red Sox vs. Rays Probable Starting Pitchers – May 16

The Boston Red Sox (22-21) have a home game at Fenway Park against the Tampa Bay Rays (22-22) at 7:10 PM ET on Thursday.This contest's pitching matchup is set, as the Red Sox will send Cooper Criswell (2-1) to the...

Green Bay Packers Schedule: Dates and Times for All 17 Games, Strength of Schedule, Record Prediction

Jordan Love and the Green Bay Packers caught the attention of NFL fans in the playoffs last season and hope to build on that success. What will they do this year? Check out their full schedule, record prediction, and more...

more cubs news