Russell Martin Rumor Bits: Pirates “Stretching” to Keep Him? Cubs Still Interested?

russell martin piratesThe tenor of public comments lately from Chicago Cubs executives have painted the picture of an offseason where the organization will focus on picking up at least one impact starting pitcher, a second quality starting pitcher, and then complementary, veteran offensive pieces, rather than an impact starting offensive player. Obviously this front office is never going to say, with 100% certainty, precisely what they’re going to do, but you can understand the factors that lead to this kind of offseason plan: (1) the Cubs need impact pitching, (2) although the offense has been an issue in recent years and could be an issue again next year, offense is probably not the long-term need, (3) available impact offensive pieces are going to be few and far between this offseason, and (4) veteran complementary pieces could really help with the Cubs’ twin desires to compete next year but also develop their young players at the big league level.

All that said … the front office rules nothing out. They know that adding a quality, regular offensive piece could pay huge dividends in the coming years, if it came in the right spot, and the deal made sense. Could that piece be an upgrade behind the plate? Could it be top catching free agent Russell Martin?

We’ve seen the Cubs connected to Martin multiple times already this year, and, even as much as there is to like about Welington Castillo, you wonder if the team as a whole could be upgraded by bringing in someone like Martin (or, since we’re on the subject, Miguel Montero in trade). Earlier this week, we discussed the Cubs’ extreme woes with pitch framing, something at which Martin excels, and he’s obviously a veteran guy who handles a staff well. In some ways, the offense that Martin could bring – don’t bet on a total repeat of this season’s breakout – is merely the cherry on top of his value. Moreover, because the Cubs are at least a couple years away from having a regular catching prospect emerge in the bigs (and, even then, it could be someone like Kyle Schwarber, who projects to be more of a part-time-catching-part-time-outfielding guy), signing someone like Martin doesn’t realistically and immediately block a top prospect.

That is all to say: even as the Cubs rightly focus on pitching this offseason, I’d still like to see them following Martin’s free agency to see if there’s a deal that makes sense. To that end, there are a variety of Martin bits to discuss …

  • Will Martin even get to free agency? Well, Pirates owner Bob Nutting tells TribLive that he is willing to “stretch” to keep Martin in the fold. We’ll see if they can stretch enough to prevent Martin from wanting to see what else is out there. That seems unlikely. Instead, they’ll do some negotiating, he’ll figure out where they stand, and then free agency will proceed. Maybe he comes back to Pittsburgh, or maybe he cashes in on some accelerating value.
  • How about that price, though? My back-of-the-napkin valuation put Martin at something like four years and $66 million, but Joel Sherman suggests that the deal could actually be in the four-year, $52 million range. If that’s where Martin actually ends up, it better be with the Cubs, because that’s a steal, even if Martin winds up the back-up catcher in years three and four.
  • … but as Travis Sawchik points out, recent deals for comparable catchers have been significantly higher. Martin’s age makes for an imperfect comparison, but you can see how Brian McCann’s five-year, $85 million deal is going to be the one Martin seeks to duplicate. Martin is two years older now than McCann was when he inked his deal, however. I still think the final deal winds up in the four-year, $60 to $70 million range.
  • Jon Heyman reports that the Pirates tried to extend Martin mid-season, but it didn’t happen, and it doesn’t look like they’ll get a deal done before free agency. He mentions the Cubs, Red Sox, Rangers, and Dodgers as possible suitors.
  • Mark Gonzales recently wrote that Martin remains an attractive option for the Cubs. Or they could go with a trade option like Kurt Suzuki (to whom they were connected before last season), who had a BABIP-induced offensive resurgence in 2014. I’m not sure his defensive skills are what they once were, and Suzuki rates as one of the worst pitch-framers in baseball. Not sure that’s the route for the Cubs.
  • Yes, Martin projects to regress offensively next year, by the way, after seeing his BABIP on every kind of batted ball spike last year. But he still figures as a very valuable player, even without considering leadership, pitch framing, work with pitchers, etc.
  • written by

    Brett Taylor is the Lead Cubs Writer at Bleacher Nation, and you can find him on Twitter at @BleacherNation and on LinkedIn here. Brett is also the founder of Bleacher Nation, which opened up shop in 2008 as an independent blog about the Chicago Cubs. Later growing to incorporate coverage of other Chicago sports, Bleacher Nation is now one of the largest regional sports blogs on the web.

    more cubs news

    Chicago Cubs Lineup: Ian Happ Back in, PCA Sits

    CUBS LINEUP — The Chicago Cubs are back at Wrigley Field tonight against the Pirates, facing a 22-year-old fireballer who threw six strong innings against them last weekend, Jared Jones. Here's a look at the Cubs lineup for the rematch...

    MLBits: Red-Hot Rockies, Sticky Stuff Suspension, Salvy’s Patience Paying Off, More

    The longest active winning streak in baseball belongs to ... the Rockies. More on the red-hot Rox and more in today's MLB Notes. The Red-Hot Rockies? A little over a week ago, the Rockies were 8-28. Since then, they've won...

    The Cubs Are Coming Home to Face the Pirates

    Cubs vs Pirates — There's going to be a little deja vu here for the next week, as the Cubs play seven straight games against the Pirates and Braves after just wrapping up six games against ... the Pirates and...

    Cubs Farm Report | May 16, 2024: Brennan Davis Goes Yard in Iowa Loss

    Brennan Davis' fifth home run of the season was not enough for the Iowa Cubs on Wednesday as they fell to the Syracuse Mets in a rain-shortened affair. That and more in today's Cubs Farm Report. Cubs Farm Report |...

    Javier Assad is the Definition of Pitchability

    Like his rotation-mate Shota Imanaga, Javier Assad has reached the point where, after every single start, you want to say the same thing: wow, that was awesome, this guy is good. It gets a little stale, in an extremely desirable...

    Joe Buck is Returning to the Booth to Call a Cubs-Cardinals Game

    I know that Joe Buck is a polarizing broadcaster. Some people love him. Some people hate him. I also know that he seems to have gone through phases in his career where there were stretches I thought he was mutably...

    Pete Crow-Armstrong Put on a Show, and Continues to Make a Strong Case for Continued Playing Time

    Pete Crow-Armstrong put on a show last night, which I mean in the most literal sense. It was more like a performance than a baseball game. Bases-loaded HBP while showing bunt? OK, sure. Running easily to first on a dropped...

    Northwestern Returns to Wrigley Field TWICE This Fall

    Northwestern will be making a return to Wrigley Field not just once this season, but twice! Due to the construction of their brand new football stadium, the Cats will be playing five of their seven home games at its temporary...

    Impressive Fill-In Guys, Bullpen Health, Roberts, Javy, and Other Cubs Bullets

    The Cubs come back home from the Pittsburgh-Atlanta road trip having split it 3-3, and I gotta say, that's a pretty solid outcome when (1) you're facing Jones and Skenes, (2) you're playing three in Atlanta where they'd lost just...

    Brennen Davis Homered Again, Back-to-Back with B.J. Murray Jr. (Whom We Should Discuss)

    Just about as soon as I could talk about how Brennen Davis had homered for the third time in four games, he homered AGAIN, making it four times in five games. And this time, just for fun, B.J. Murray Jr....

    Latest News

    Minnesota Vikings Schedule: Dates and Times for All 17 Games, Strength of Schedule, Record Prediction

    Under the helm of third-year coach Kevin O'Connell, the Minnesota Vikings embark on a new chapter. The departure of veteran quarterback Kirk Cousins, who led the team for six years, marks a significant transition. During Cousins' tenure, the Vikings attained...

    Chicago Cubs Lineup: Ian Happ Back in, PCA Sits

    CUBS LINEUP — The Chicago Cubs are back at Wrigley Field tonight against the Pirates, facing a 22-year-old fireballer who threw six strong innings against them last weekend, Jared Jones. Here's a look at the Cubs lineup for the rematch...

    Miami Dolphins Schedule: Dates and Times for All 17 Games, Strength of Schedule, Record Prediction

    The top-ranked offense in the NFL from last season is back, led by quarterback Tua Tagovailoa and wide receivers Tyreek Hill and Jaylen Waddle. Additionally, they've bolstered their roster during the offseason by adding talent such as Odell Beckham Jr.,...

    Indianapolis Colts Schedule: Dates and Times for All 17 Games, Strength of Schedule, Record Prediction

    The Indianapolis Colts enter the 2024 season with their eyes set on the playoffs. With a healthy Anthony Richardson at quarterback and a bolstered receiving core, optimism hangs heavy over Lucas Oil Stadium. Let's delve into their 2024 NFL schedule...

    NFL Schedule-makers Gifted Caleb Williams and the Bears a Soft Landing

    If Caleb Williams and the Chicago Bears get off to a good start this season, someone at Halas Hall should send a gift basket of Italian beef, tavern-style pizza, hot dogs, sport pepper Malört, and other Chicago delicacies to the...

    Houston Texans Schedule: Dates and Times for All 17 Games, Strength of Schedule, Record Prediction

    The Houston Texans were the surprise team of the season last year thanks to the emergence of rookies C.J. Stroud and Will Anderson Jr. and an excellent job by rookie head coach and offensive coordinator DeMeco Ryans and Bobby Slowik....

    New England Patriots Schedule: Dates and Times for All 17 Games, Strength of Schedule, Record Prediction

    The New England Patriots are coming off their worst season in over three decades and have officially turned the page on the Belichick-Brady era by hiring Jerod Mayo as their new head coach. They’ve also hit the reset button at...

    My Favorite 2024 NFL Schedule Release Videos

    Schedule release day in the NFL is one of my favorite non-game days of the year. NFL social media teams work hard to create entertaining videos revealing their teams' schedules for the upcoming season. Here are my favorite 2024 NFL...

    San Francisco 49ers Schedule: Dates and Times for All 17 Games, Strength of Schedule, Record Prediction

    Brock Purdy led the San Francisco 49ers to an NFC Championship and their second Super Bowl appearance in the last five years in 2023. Will they pick up where they left off and continue to dominate the NFC this season?...

    Ope! The Bears Also Announced Their 2024 Preseason Schedule

    ESPN's Monday Night Football team will call the first game of the Caleb Williams Era when the Chicago Bears play the Houston Texans in the Pro Football Hall of Fame Game. This will mark the first time the Hall of...

    more cubs news