Obsessive Jon Lester Watch: Unpacking Boston Reactions and More

jon lester feature red soxBack in August, Jon Lester spoke relatively glowingly to the Boston Herald about his time with the Boston Red Sox, despite the low pre-season contract offer and the July trade. Among his comments at that time is something that’s look pretty prescient four months later: “In the greater scheme of things, we’re talking about just a stupid amount of money,” Lester said of free agency. “For me, I want to be comfortable. The way I look at it is, if someone gives you $170 million and someone gives you $150 million, is that $20 million really going to change your lifestyle?” From the sound of things, the Cubs are willing to go to $150 million on Lester, but the question is whether an over-the-top offer from, say, the Dodgers ($170 million, maybe?) could sway him. And, if those same Red Sox are anywhere close to the top of the market for him, will Boston be the place he was talking about being comfortable?

Speaking of Boston, we discussed last evening the owner’s recent visit to continue selling to Lester, his second face-to-face with Lester this offseason, which could have meant any number of things – last ditch effort? final courtesy? increased offer? showing complete commitment? – so I don’t think it’s worth trying to extrapolate meaning beyond “the Red Sox are probably still trying to sign Lester.” I find it interesting, however, that in the wake of that news, there are no fewer than three new articles out of the Boston area about how getting Lester is not really critical for the Red Sox. There’s this Boston Herald piece about how the Red Sox could turn to Max Scherzer if they don’t get Lester. There’s this Providence Journal piece about how the Red Sox could turn to the trade market if they don’t get Lester (with a sprinkling of missing-out-on-big-contracts-is-often-a-blessing-in-disguise stuff). And there’s this Boston.com piece about how the Red Sox just plain don’t need Lester, specifically, given the other options out there.

Three articles with the same tenor coming out of Boston more or less at the same time, immediately after news of an owner visit and no other indication that the Red Sox’s pursuit was in some kind of trouble.

Can we make anything of that? Probably not. It’s conceivable that Red Sox insiders are putting out the word – off the record – that they don’t like their chances on getting Lester, which has prompted various writers to start setting up alternatives, which puts them ahead of the curve. But, even if it’s true that the narrative is emanating with the Red Sox, it’s just as plausible that this has been done to get some word out there that the Red Sox have tons of non-Lester options, so they don’t need to raise whatever offer they have out to Lester. That is to say: it could be part of a negotiating tactic by the Red Sox, who don’t actually think they’re out of this thing at all.

See what I mean when I say we probably can’t make much of it? I just like to think about these things.

Among the other Lester bits out there right now …

  • Are the Red Sox willing to get up into that $150 million range? We don’t know for sure – the last generally-accepted-as-true offer we heard about was six years and $110 to $120 million, and there was probably a willingness to go to $130 million – but Gordon Edes has reported an update. Edes hears from a source that the Red Sox are willing to offer “at least” $132 million. It remains entirely plausible to me that the Red Sox have decided their ceiling on Lester is in that range, and they’re hoping the lure of coming back to Boston will be the deciding factor. The Cubs, then, for their part, may have decided that an extra $20 million or so is as much as they can offer to try and overcome that lure.
  • There’s an interesting FanGraphs piece to remind us why teams are so interested in Lester in the first place – he’s really good. It’s easy to lose sight of that as you start to just focus on the pursuit, itself, and the dollars. Although there will be some regression at the margins from his career-best 2014 season, it doesn’t look like he’s a reasonable candidate for serious regression, because there wasn’t a ton of flukiness to his season. (I suppose this is also a reminder that if the Cubs are fortunate enough to get Lester, they’ll have to seriously consider adding a couple other impact players sooner rather than later, because Lester’s best years are likely to be the next couple, not several years down the road.)
  • Everyone is expecting a deal to be struck between Lester and his new (or old) team this week at the Winter Meetings – though folks were expecting a deal last week, too. Peter Gammons says the decision could come on Wednesday. The meetings last until Thursday, but, historically, folks start to head out by mid-day as the Rule 5 Draft is the focus, and various talks have concluded. Then again, there are sometimes big deals that Thursday morning – word of Albert Pujols’ huge deal with the Angels in 2011 came Thursday morning.
  • written by

    Brett Taylor is the Lead Cubs Writer at Bleacher Nation, and you can find him on Twitter at @BleacherNation and on LinkedIn here. Brett is also the founder of Bleacher Nation, which opened up shop in 2008 as an independent blog about the Chicago Cubs. Later growing to incorporate coverage of other Chicago sports, Bleacher Nation is now one of the largest regional sports blogs on the web.

    more cubs news

    Wake Up and Watch the Cubs Come Back (Again) to Beat the White Sox Late (Again)

    Just like the night before, maybe the Chicago Cubs shouldn't have HAD to pull off a big comeback against the Chicago White Sox - quite literally one of the worst teams in baseball in the last 50 years - but...

    The Palatine Pounder Just Hit a Walk-off Home Run to Sweep the White Sox!

    Well, it wasn't easy and it wasn't pretty, but at least they didn't make us sweat it out for long. Heading into the ninth inning of a tie game against the White Sox at Wrigley Field, Mike Tauchman (a.k.a. The...

    Enhanced Box Score: Cubs 7, White Sox 6 – June 5, 2024

    Well, okay. LOL. The Cubs didn't so much win that game as the White Sox lost it. How do I mean? Well, the first five Cubs runs scored without so much as a hit. And the sixth was a broken...

    James Triantos …. Hooooooome Ruuuuun!

    James Triantos must've been miffed that Baseball America left him off their top-100 prospect rankings when the list was updated earlier today. Because tonight, in his first game since May 29 (I didn't even realize he was out to be...

    Pre-Gamin’: Cubs vs White Sox (7:05 CT) – Lineups, Broadcast Info, Game Thread

    CUBS LINEUP — Well, the Cubs pulled one out of their hat to take the opener against the White Sox last night. Now it's time to finish the job/sweep. Here's a look at the Cubs lineup for the short-series finale...

    2024 MLB All-Star Game Voting is Now Open, Which, Ah, Um

    Fan voting for the starters in the 2024 MLB All-Star Game opened up this afternoon, which means you can vote for your favorite Chicago Cubs and/or other players, should you feel they are deserving of your support. https://twitter.com/Cubs/status/1798423694425113082 Such as...

    BA’s Top-100 Update Features SEVEN Cubs Prospects (And So Much Youth)

    When Keith Law refreshed his top-50 prospect rankings earlier this week, the Cubs found themselves with a new top prospect overall, Matt Shaw. Though that's mostly because Pete Crow-Armstrong graduated from the rankings, and not because Shaw surpassed him. In...

    Brennen Davis Gets Back to Hitting Dingers

    It's been a little bit since that crazy Brennen Davis homer binge in mid-May, so I thought we'd all enjoy seeing that Davis hit his first homer in a couple weeks this afternoon. The future is still hazy for the...

    Which Hitters Could Be Available and Fit the Cubs If They Try to Add a Bat This Summer?

    Well, it's still early, but you can probably mark today as the official start of the 2024 MLB Trade Deadline rumor season. Why? Because Jeff Passan's first deadline preview has dropped and it is LOADED with tea. Broadly speaking, Passan...

    The Cubs Will Be Ready to Go the Trade Route to Add Offense if Necessary

    The dramatic win last night notwithstanding, it has been a really, really, really rough stretch for the Chicago Cubs. After peaking in late-April at the top of the NL Central standings, the Cubs have gone 12-20 to fall 6.0 games...

    Latest News

    Dodgers vs. Pirates Probable Starting Pitchers – June 6

    The Los Angeles Dodgers (38-25) visit the Pittsburgh Pirates (29-32). The matchup at PNC Park begins at 6:40 PM ET on Thursday.The probable pitchers are Walker Buehler (1-3) for the Dodgers and Bailey Falter (3-2) for the Pirates.Dodgers vs. Pirates...

    Braves vs. Nationals Probable Starting Pitchers – June 6

    The Washington Nationals (27-34) face off against the Atlanta Braves (34-25) on Thursday at Nationals Park after a three-game losing streak. The contest starts at 6:45 PM ET.The Braves will give the nod to Reynaldo Lopez (3-2, 1.73 ERA), who...

    Yankees vs. Twins Probable Starting Pitchers – June 6

    Following a stretch of seven consecutive wins, the New York Yankees (44-19) meet the Minnesota Twins (33-28) at 7:05 PM ET on Thursday.The Yankees will give the ball to Marcus Stroman (5-2, 2.73 ERA), who is eyeing win No. 6...

    Reds vs. Cubs Probable Starting Pitchers – June 6

    Following a stretch of four consecutive wins, the Cincinnati Reds (29-33) play the Chicago Cubs (31-31) at 7:10 PM ET on Thursday.The Reds will give the nod to Hunter Greene (3-2) versus the Cubs and Javier Assad (4-1).Reds vs. Cubs...

    Vikings Reveal New Winter Warrior Jerseys — Which They’ll Debut vs. the Bears

    A team in the NFC North is set to debut a new uniform this season. Unfortunately, it is not the Chicago Bears. The Minnesota Vikings dropped a video on Thursday morning revealing the eye-popping, fashion-forward new uniform look. Check it...

    Best NBA Prop Bets for Thursday, June 6, 2024

    In a Thursday NBA playoff slate that has just one matchup, the Dallas Mavericks versus the Boston Celtics is the only way to watch the NBA today.NBA prop bets for today's games are available, so if you're interested in placing...

    Mariners vs. Athletics Prediction: Expert Picks, Odds, Stats & Best Bets – Thursday, June 6, 2024

    The Seattle Mariners (35-28) and the Oakland Athletics (25-38) meet in the rubber match of a three-game series on Thursday at 3:37 PM ET. The Mariners are -165 favorites on the moneyline to win the series over the Athletics (+140).Bryan...

    Wake Up and Watch the Cubs Come Back (Again) to Beat the White Sox Late (Again)

    Just like the night before, maybe the Chicago Cubs shouldn't have HAD to pull off a big comeback against the Chicago White Sox - quite literally one of the worst teams in baseball in the last 50 years - but...

    Mariners vs. Athletics Probable Starting Pitchers – June 6

    The Seattle Mariners (35-28) visit the Oakland Athletics (25-38). The contest at Oakland-Alameda County Coliseum begins at 3:37 PM ET on Thursday.This contest's pitching matchup is set, as the Mariners will send Bryan Woo (2-0) to the mound, while JP...

    Padres vs. Diamondbacks: Injury Report, Updates & Probable Starters – June 6

    A pair of clubs in the NL West -- the San Diego Padres (32-33) and the Arizona Diamondbacks (29-33) -- meet on Thursday at 9:40 PM ET, at PETCO Park.Want to see who's playing for the Padres and the Diamondbacks?...

    more cubs news