Cubs Win, Cubs Win: Rooftops Lawsuit Dismissed

judge gavel courtIt’s over. The Cubs win. If there were a legally appropriate comparison, the Cubs just walked it off in the 4th inning.

A federal judge has dismissed the last remaining lawsuit against the Chicago Cubs over the expansion of Wrigley Field and the signage in the outfield. As you may recall, the court’s decision was heavily telegraphed back in early April when the judge’s opinion denying the two rooftops’ request for an injunction included a lengthy heads up to the rooftops that their arguments lacked merit. Here’s what I wrote then:

The rooftops lost their request for a TRO, and today, the court also denied their request for a preliminary injunction. You can read the court’s decision here (h/t to Crain’s Danny Ecker for the link to the document), which is extremely strongly worded in favor of the Cubs, not only for purposes of the injunction, but also for the entire case. Indeed, the primary reason for refusing to grant the injunction? The court believes the rooftops have not demonstrated a likelihood on the merits of the case because the Cubs have not breached the revenue-sharing agreement and because there is no antitrust violation.

To be sure, this case is not technically over – there is still the motion to dismiss to be decided, and then discovery, and then additional motions, and then trial (and the rooftops could appeal this decision, as well). And technically, the court did not say “dear rooftops, your arguments lose.” But the court laid out, in painstaking detail, the reasons it believes – with everything presently in front of it – the rooftops’ arguments are unlikely to win on legal grounds. In other words, no amount of additional document discovery or research or fighting will help the rooftops on those arguments with this court at this point.

Worse for the rooftops, the court didn’t have to go that far. It ruled that a preliminary injunction was not appropriate at this time for other reasons (essentially, the rooftops don’t need it to survive because they won’t immediately be put out of business and they can be adequately made whole on the back-end if they wind up proving their case). So the court could have just left this as a mostly procedural decision, and left open the legal arguments. It did not.

In other words, the Cubs’ motion to dismiss was looking pretty good, and there’s a reason we didn’t hear much more about the case after that. You can see the court’s opinion here at Crain’s, where you can read that, after some additional briefing, nothing changed the court’s mind, and the rooftops’ suit was dismissed with prejudice, meaning that the rooftops cannot refile their claims.

It’s really over.

It seems that the 2015 season is about ending all kinds of eras. The Cubs and the rooftops have been sparring in various ways and via various vehicles about the present renovation since before the team even announced the precise renovation plans way back in early 2013. It’s been a long and often frustrating road, but the story – at least as far as the rooftops suing the Cubs about the current outfield signage plan – is at an end.

Interplay with the rooftops, of course, is not over, as they remain a notable part of the ambiance at Wrigley Field, and six of them are owned by the Ricketts Family, with an interest in a seventh, and presumable designs on getting on into even more of the 16 total. As the Wrigley expansion continues, and as the Wrigleyville experience evolves, you can expect that the rooftops’ role in that experience will evolve, as well.

written by

Brett Taylor is the Lead Cubs Writer at Bleacher Nation, and you can find him on Twitter at @BleacherNation and on LinkedIn here. Brett is also the founder of Bleacher Nation, which opened up shop in 2008 as an independent blog about the Chicago Cubs. Later growing to incorporate coverage of other Chicago sports, Bleacher Nation is now one of the largest regional sports blogs on the web.

more cubs news

Brennen Davis Rejoined the Cubs’ Top-30 Prospect List and Celebrated with Another Dinger

I don't know where this will ultimately go, and I still think we need to exercise some caution with our hopes, but it's been a very good couple weeks for Brennen Davis. Not only has the outfielder been hitting quite...

Angels Manager Ron Washington Threw Luis Guillorme Under the Bus, Then Drove the Bus, Then Backed Over Him Again

Ron Washington must absolutely hate his new infielder, Luis Guillorme, who was acquired just five days ago. There is no other explanation for what he said after last night's game. I mean, I'm kinda tongue-in-cheek, but this is pretty extreme....

Ronel Blanco, Who Threw the Season’s First No-Hitter, Now Gets the Season’s First Sticky Stuff Ejection

The first sticky stuff ejection of the year has arrived. Houston Astros righty Ronel Blanco, he of the surprising no-hitter earlier this year, got the boot last night. From the look of things, Blanco and his manager were trying to...

Enhanced Box Score: Braves 7, Cubs 0 – May 14, 2024

Not every game is a referendum on a team. Actually, come to think of it, a single game is NEVER a referendum on a team. Anyway, point is, a whole lot of teams are going to get stomped by these...

Pablo Aliendo Goes Way Deep, Alexander Canario Goes Way Grand

Pablo Aliendo gave the Tennessee Smokies an early lead on Tuesday night. Matching up with the Rocket City Trash Pandas, Aliendo sent a ball deep into left field during the 2nd inning. The homer gave the Smokies an early 1-0...

Nico Hoerner Was Scratched Just Before Tonight’s Game Started

You know that expression, when it rains, it pours? This is like that, except instead of raining, it is pouring deluxe turds. Just an absolute monsoon of shit. Another Cubs injury issue to another key Cubs player: https://twitter.com/maddie_m_lee/status/1790522697002455532 So, Nico...

Pre-Gamin’: Cubs at Braves (6:20 CT) – Lineups, Broadcast Info, Game Thread

CUBS LINEUP — The Cubs were shutout in the opener against the Braves last night. And it doesn't figure to get any easier against a resurgent Chris Sale tonight. Here's how Craig Counsell will line 'em up against the 35-year-old...

Adbert Alzolay Update: Imaging Results, Timeline, and a Sprinkle of (Unexpected) Optimism

I had the weirdest reaction to what is objectively bad injury news on Adbert Alzolay just now. According to Meghan Montemurro, medical imaging confirmed that Adbert Alzolay has a right flexor strain. While I should have been upset to learn...

Jed Hoyer Speaks: New Reliever, Bullpen Issues, Imanaga, Morel, Swanson, Bat Data, More

The Chicago Cubs' President of Baseball Operations just hopped on 670 The Score On the Bernstein & Holmes Show, discussing a number of Cubs-related items. He led things off with a discussion of newly-acquired reliever, Tyson Miller: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hes1lI-8ZCI So, then,...

Shota Imanaga Favored for NL Rookie of the Year, Cy Young, MVP, Nobel Peace Prize, and an Oscar

There is nothing Shota Imanaga can't do. Going up against one of the best teams in baseball — and best overall offenses versus LHP — on the road, without his best stuff, Shota Imanaga tossed 5.0 scoreless innings in Atlanta, with...

Latest News

Brennen Davis Rejoined the Cubs’ Top-30 Prospect List and Celebrated with Another Dinger

I don't know where this will ultimately go, and I still think we need to exercise some caution with our hopes, but it's been a very good couple weeks for Brennen Davis. Not only has the outfielder been hitting quite...

Angels Manager Ron Washington Threw Luis Guillorme Under the Bus, Then Drove the Bus, Then Backed Over Him Again

Ron Washington must absolutely hate his new infielder, Luis Guillorme, who was acquired just five days ago. There is no other explanation for what he said after last night's game. I mean, I'm kinda tongue-in-cheek, but this is pretty extreme....

Ronel Blanco, Who Threw the Season’s First No-Hitter, Now Gets the Season’s First Sticky Stuff Ejection

The first sticky stuff ejection of the year has arrived. Houston Astros righty Ronel Blanco, he of the surprising no-hitter earlier this year, got the boot last night. From the look of things, Blanco and his manager were trying to...

London’s Calling: Bears and Jaguars Are Going International in 2024

The wait is over. We now know who the Chicago Bears will be playing in London. As fate would have it, it is a team that is no stranger to international travel. The Jacksonville Jaguars are set to be the...

Enhanced Box Score: Braves 7, Cubs 0 – May 14, 2024

Not every game is a referendum on a team. Actually, come to think of it, a single game is NEVER a referendum on a team. Anyway, point is, a whole lot of teams are going to get stomped by these...

Pablo Aliendo Goes Way Deep, Alexander Canario Goes Way Grand

Pablo Aliendo gave the Tennessee Smokies an early lead on Tuesday night. Matching up with the Rocket City Trash Pandas, Aliendo sent a ball deep into left field during the 2nd inning. The homer gave the Smokies an early 1-0...

Nico Hoerner Was Scratched Just Before Tonight’s Game Started

You know that expression, when it rains, it pours? This is like that, except instead of raining, it is pouring deluxe turds. Just an absolute monsoon of shit. Another Cubs injury issue to another key Cubs player: https://twitter.com/maddie_m_lee/status/1790522697002455532 So, Nico...

WATCH: Caleb Williams is Already Making Connections with DJ Moore and Keenan Allen at Halas Hall

Caleb Williams clips, however brief, will always grab my attention. Because while I can tell myself over and over again that I will not get googly eyes over spring practice videos, the reality is that I can't wait to see...

How to Watch Phillies Games: Full 2024 Schedule, Live Stream and More

If you are a Philadelphia Phillies fan and looking to catch their games, you can watch most of them on TV with a cable subscription or via streaming with one of the many different apps. Let’s break down the cable...

Connor Bedard Scored Again for Canada

Oh hey! Blackhawks' star Connor Bedard scored his fifth goal of the World Championships for Canada on Tuesday afternoon. https://twitter.com/BN_Blackhawks/status/1790468565675483262 Bedard helped Canada sprint to a 6-1 lead... which evaporated as Austria scored five unanswered goals in the third period...

more cubs news