Roquan Smith Isn’t Getting the Love From PFF He Probably Deserves

There are times where the eye test, stat sheet, and advanced metrics don’t meet eye-to-eye. And when it comes to Chicago Bears rookie linebacker Roquan Smith, that appears to be the case.

So what gives when it comes to Roquan Smith rankings at PFF? Well, according to the site’s grading scale … everything. Smith’s 58.4 run defense grade and 64.2 coverage grade leaves a ton to be desired, while his 69.9 pass-rush grade isn’t nice enough to push his grade up among the best rookie linebackers. If you were to use only the grades provided by Pro Football Focus, you’d think Smith is struggling in his maiden voyage as a professional football player. But the traditional stats paint a different picture.

Smith is now 14 games into his rookie season and leads the team in total tackles (108) and solo tackles (80), and is tied for fourth in tackles-for-loss (6). And just to show how well-rounded his game is, Smith also has four sacks, four quarterback hits, a forced fumble, and an interception. Judging by those numbers, like Smith’s summertime holdout seems like a distant memory at this point. And from the perspective of the eye test, it’s fair to surmise that Smith has excelled in every facet of the game. He has shown sure-handed tackling ability, pure athleticism, and high-end speed while solidifying the inside linebacker position while playing alongside Danny Trevathan.

While PFF’s grading scale might not buy in to Smith’s game, opposing players and coaches appear to like what they’re seeing from the University of Georgia product. Smith was selected to be a Pro Bowl alternate, which is a fine accomplishment for a rookie. Moreover, because Smith didn’t finish as a top vote-getter at his position in the fan vote, it means votes from players and coaches around the league pushed Smith onto the cusp of playing in the annual all-star game. That’s not nothing, folks.

In the end, having a disconnect between traditional stats, the eye test, and advanced metrics is hardly new. If anything, it’s par for the course when it comes to analysis. But still … the drastic differences makes me wonder if we’re missing something we should be picking up on. Think about it. PFF’s grades aren’t done on a whim. The site has a staff with more than 300 members watching, analyzing, and grading every player and every game. And then those grades are subject to change after reviewing All-22 footage. It’s as comprehensive of a look as it gets. And yet, it leaves us wanting so much more from an explanation standpoint. But until that day comes, the debate rages on.

written by

Luis C. Medina, who you can find on Twitter at lcm1986, has been covering the Chicago Bears at Bleacher Nation since 2017. Since then, he has written about 3 head coaches, 5 play-callers, and 11 starting quarterbacks. Previously, Luis wrote about the Cubs and MLB at BN (2015-16) and worked in the Chicago Tribune sports department (2011-16). He also co-hosted a Cubs postgame show, Outside the Ivy, in 2019.

more bears news

NFLPA Rookie Premiere 2024, Caleb and Rome, Early Fantasy Rankings, and Other Bears Bullets

Wrapping up a weekend of shenanigans with dog-sitting duties. We're going to have walks, belly-rubs, and movie naps today. I'm looking forward to it. But first, I've got to push these BN Bears Bullets across the finish line. Check it...

Bears Watchability, Identifying “Must Win” Games, One Idea For NFL’s International Plan, and Other Bears Bullets

My social calendar unexpectedly filling up in May has been a pleasant surprise. As is projected 80-degree weather on a Saturday afternoon. Cheers, friends. Sure, the Chicago Bears 2024 strength of schedule doesn't look all too daunting. And it sure...

Heads Up! Tyrique Stevenson is Poised For a Breakout

A tip of the cap to the Chicago Bears social media team, which is doing a heckuva job keeping fans engaged in what has turned into a fun offseason. Their latest Q&A endeavor asks Bears players who they would choose...

It’s Here And It’s Perfect: EA Sports College Football 25 Trailer Released

Today EA Sports released the trailer for College Football 25 and it's absolutely perfect. The graphics look amazing, Chris Fowler sets the stage, each team shown has its own unique entrance and tradition, and in just two short months it...

Around the NFL: Get Ready for a Hefty Serving of Aaron Rodgers, How Much Will it Cost to Watch Every NFL Game in 2024? More

The NFL schedule makers felt they were entitled to a re-do when it comes to cramming Aaron Rodgers down our throats, and they took full advantage of it. Plus, how much will it cost to watch every NFL game in...

Bears Defensive Coordinator Eric Washington to Attend NFL’s Coaching Accelerator Program

Chicago Bears Defensive Coordinator Eric Washington will take part in the upcoming NFL Coach Accelerator Program that will take place at the league meetings taking place in Nashville next week. This isn't Washington's first rodeo, as the former Buffalo Bills...

HBD Coach Flus, Andy Dalton’s Side Hustle, College Football’s Big July Date, and Other Bears Bullets

It's a Friday. We finally made it. I can't believe I get to see your face. Making it to a warm-weather Friday in spring has me feeling better than I do on other days of the week. And it's got...

The Chicago Bears 2024 Schedule is HERE (Dates, Times, More)

Caleb Williams, DJ Moore, Cole Kmet, Rome Odunze, Kyler Gordon, and Teven Jenkins are among the Chicago Bears players who took starring roles in the team's 2024 schedule release video drop. Here it is in all of its glory: The...

Austin Booker is the Third Bears Draft Pick to Sign Their Rookie Deal

Another one is in the books for the Chicago Bears 2024 NFL Draft class as the team announced that Austin Booker has signed his rookie deal. This is what it looked like when Booker put pen to paper at Halas...

NFL Schedule-makers Gifted Caleb Williams and the Bears a Soft Landing

If Caleb Williams and the Chicago Bears get off to a good start this season, someone at Halas Hall should send a gift basket of Italian beef, tavern-style pizza, hot dogs, sport pepper Malört, and other Chicago delicacies to the...

Latest News

How to Watch Royals vs. Tigers: Live Stream or on TV

On Monday, Michael Wacha will take the mound for the Kansas City Royals (29-19) against Reese Olson and the Detroit Tigers (23-23), with first pitch scheduled for 7:40 PM ET at Kauffman Stadium.The article below will provide you with everything...

Panthers vs. Rangers Stanley Cup Semifinals Game 1 Prediction: Odds, Picks, Best Bets – Wednesday, May 22, 2024

The oddsmakers are predicting a close contest between the Florida Panthers and New York Rangers on Wednesday in New York City, with the Panthers given moneyline odds of -115 and the Rangers at -105.Watch the NHL on Fubo!Panthers vs. Rangers...

How to Watch Astros vs. Angels: Live Stream or on TV

The Houston Astros (21-26), with Framber Valdez on the mound, host the Los Angeles Angels (18-29) who will start Reid Detmers, at 8:10 PM ET on Monday.Keep reading to find out how to watch the Houston-Los Angeles matchup in the...

How to Watch Braves vs. Padres: Live Stream or on TV

The Atlanta Braves (26-15), led by Marcell Ozuna, host Jurickson Profar and the San Diego Padres (23-24) on Monday at 12:20 PM ET.See how to watch the Atlanta-San Diego matchup below.When is Braves vs. Padres and when does it start?This...

Cardinals vs. Orioles: Start Time, Streaming Live, TV Channel, How to Watch

The St. Louis Cardinals (20-26), with Sonny Gray on the hill, host the Baltimore Orioles (29-15) who will start Dean Kremer, at 7:45 PM ET on Monday in a series opener.Find out how to watch the St. Louis-Baltimore matchup below.When...

Twins vs. Nationals: Free Live Stream, TV Channel, How to Watch

Pablo Lopez takes the ball for the Minnesota Twins (24-22) when they visit starter Mitchell Parker and the Washington Nationals (20-25) at 6:45 PM ET on Monday.If you're trying to watch this game, keep reading for streaming and TV options...

Brewers vs. Marlins: Free Live Stream, TV Channel, How to Watch

On Monday, in a series opener at LoanDepot park, Joe Ross takes the mound for the Milwaukee Brewers (27-19) against Ryan Weathers and the Miami Marlins (15-33), with first pitch scheduled for 6:40 PM ET.Keep reading to find out all...

Rays vs. Red Sox: Start Time, Streaming Live, TV Channel, How to Watch

Taj Bradley will take the ball for the Tampa Bay Rays (25-23) when they host starter Tanner Houck and the Boston Red Sox (23-24) in a series opener on Monday, with first pitch at 6:50 PM ET.Keep reading to find...

How to Watch Guardians vs. Mets: Live Stream or on TV

Ben Lively will take the ball for the Cleveland Guardians (30-17) when they host starter Tylor Megill and the New York Mets (21-25) on Monday, with first pitch at 6:10 PM ET.The article below will give you everything you need...

Yankees vs. Mariners: Free Live Stream, TV Channel, How to Watch

Marcus Stroman takes the mound for the New York Yankees (33-15) when they host starter Logan Gilbert and the Seattle Mariners (25-22) at 7:05 PM ET on Monday.Keep reading to find out all the details on how to watch New...

more bears news