Love it or Hate it? The Ha Ha Clinton-Dix and Buster Skrine Signings Are Drawing Very Different Reviews

Losing Adrian Amos was always going to hurt, but signing Ha Ha Clinton-Dix appears to have already softened the blow. Pro Football Focus’ team of analysts placed the Clinton-Dix signing among the highest-graded class of signings this offseason, giving the move an “elite” grade on that particular scale.

Elsewhere at PFF, Michael Renner viewed the shrewd, albeit low-key move one that could have a big impact. And that’s not all! Pete Prisco of CBS Sports gave a tip of the cap to Chicago for inserting Clinton-Dix to fill the vacancy left behind by Amos, giving the Bears a “B-minus” grade. Hooray for mostly praise.

The Clinton-Dix signing headlines a second consecutive heralded Bears offseason, especially from PFF. Because in addition to bringing Clinton-Dix aboard, the site also shares positive grades for the Cordarrelle Patterson and Mike Davis signings. Patterson’s arrival grades out as “very good” as PFF’s Josh Liskiewitz believes Matt Nagy’s creativity will allow the Bears to get the most out of Patterson’s skills the way the Patriots did in 2018. Davis’ deal received an “average” grade from PFF, but Cam Mellor sees the the reserve rusher as a possible pivotal piece to Chicago’s backfield trio. In fact, Mellor thinks the Bears might have signed a player who could be their top ball-carrier to what looks like a team-friendly deal.

(Photo by Kevin C. Cox/Getty Images)

And on the opposite end of the grading scale is the deal that brought nickel cornerback Buster Skrine to Chicago. Skrine’s deal isn’t the worst that was given out to a free agent this offseason, but grading as “below average” isn’t what anyone had in mind when the team was courting Bryce Callahan’s replacement.

PFF’s assessment: “Skrine has massive shoes to fill as Bryce Callahan was the top slot cornerback in the league last year but will not be returning to the Bears in 2019. Reliable in terms of health (he has logged over 400 coverage snaps each of the past seven seasons), he has surrendered 39 touchdowns into his coverage over the past seven years. That’s good money to a player who allows over five touchdowns a season in coverage.”

Yikes! Not only is that far from a glowing review, it makes me wonder how that guy can be the same as the one Nagy once said was “one of the better nickels in the league, if not the best.” What gives!?

Skrine took home PFF’s seventh worst coverage grade among corners, but was stellar elsewhere as he picked up the site’s 12th best pass-rush grade and 17th best grade against the run last season. Clearly, Skrine’s coverage grade leaves much to be desired. But perhaps new DC Chuck Pagano (who has long been revered as one of the best when it comes to coaching defensive backs) can raise his level of play. It’s possible that a different scheme loaded with big-play defenders makes things easier for Skrine in the slot. There is definitely room for upside and growth, even if there is notable cause for concern.

In the end, the Bears are still looking at an offseason in which they have satisfied some glaring positional needs. GM Ryan Pace entered the offseason with minimal holes to fill on a roster that won the NFC North and has received some positive reviews with how he has patched up perceived soft spots. This offseason is far from over, but the Bears are off to go a good start – even if one move appears to be less-than-flattering.

written by

Luis C. Medina, who you can find on Twitter at lcm1986, has been covering the Chicago Bears at Bleacher Nation since 2017. Since then, he has written about 3 head coaches, 5 play-callers, and 11 starting quarterbacks. Previously, Luis wrote about the Cubs and MLB at BN (2015-16) and worked in the Chicago Tribune sports department (2011-16). He also co-hosted a Cubs postgame show, Outside the Ivy, in 2019.

more bears news

NFL Schedule Notes, When Should Bears Debut? Goff, Winfield, Parks, and Other Bears Bullets

Coming home to a wonky wifi wasn't on my to-do list. But at least I'm home in one piece. Anyway, apologies if this set of BN Bears Bullets is brief because I can't spend all day on mobile hotspot. The...

Bears Rookie Minicamp Takeaways: Caleb Williams and the Best of the Rest

I've said it, and I'll continue to say it: this chapter of Chicago Bears football feels different. Perhaps it's because the last time we did this, we were in a pandemic, and when the Bears jumped up to No. 11...

Jared Goff Becomes the Highest-Paid Lion Ever!

The Detroit Lions have been busy in recent weeks securing their core after a run to the NFC title game last season. Jared Goff became the latest player to get a new deal in Detroit, and he became the highest-paid...

Antoine Winfield Jr Signs Record-Breaking Extension

The Buccaneers have made Antoine Winfield Jr the highest-paid defensive back in the history of the NFL. On Monday afternoon, Winfield Jr and Tampa Bay agreed to a four-year, $84.1 million deal. It also guarantees the Bucs' star $45 million....

Bears Sign 6 Players After Rookie Minicamp Weekend Tryouts

The Chicago Bears offseason roster churn continues. In addition to their five-player draft class headlined by Caleb Williams and Rome Odunze (plus nine more players who were signed as undrafted free agents), the Bears have signed six free agents who...

They’re No. 1: Bears Wide Receivers Room Ranks as NFL’s Best

One of my biggest frustrations with the Ryan Pace regime was how the former Chicago Bears general manager didn't invest in wide receiver upgrades the way you'd expect a team building around a young quarterback should. Meanwhile, his replacement, Ryan...

The Cost of Being a Football Fan (And Other Bears Bullets)

In yet another reminder that nothing in life is free, the folks at Awful Announcing put the total cost to access NFL games this season projects to be $855.86. With 272 games on the NFL schedule, that comes out to...

Rome Odunze Missed Saturday’s Bears Rookie Minicamp Practice

I was rounding up this morning's set of Bears Bullets when I saw this note from the Chicago Tribune's Dan Wiederer on rookie wide receiver Rome Odunze sitting out Saturday's practice with hamstring tightness and I knew I had to...

A New Tight End, Day 2 Camp Pics and Vids, Edge Market Developing, and Other Bears Bullets

It's Mother's Day today. And while my mother passed away in 2017, I try to use this day to remember and honor her memory. Do something nice for the moms in your life today. You only get one. Chicago Bears...

Caleb to Rome, First Day Notes, Big LSU Bet Is Off, and Other Bears Bullets

I'm off to Springfield to play the role of Uncle Lu this weekend, so we'll have an abridged version of Bears Bullets today. Caleb Williams survived his first practice as Chicago Bears QB1. And all was right with the football...

Latest News

Did You Ever Wonder What Happened to Frank Schwindel?

I've gotten back into baseball cards, which, among other things, sends me down a lot of Memory Lanes. You pull a particular card, you think about that player, and you have various memories. It's part of the fun. The other...

Bruins Get Bad Brad Marchand Update Ahead Of Game 5

Bad news for the Boston Bruins this morning. Trailing 3-1 in their second-round series with the Florida Panthers, it was revealed that captain Brad Marchand will again not be available for tonight's win-or-go-home matchup in South Florida. https://twitter.com/FlutoShinzawa/status/1790401949998706932 Brad Marchand...

Cubs Roster Moves: Lovelady DFA’d, Miller Acquired, Slaughter Sent Out

The Tyson Miller trade is now official, with the Chicago Cubs sending minor league utility man Jake Slaughter to the Seattle Mariners for Miller, who figures to be mostly a match-up righty/middle reliever in the bullpen. More on the trade...

Oilers Reportedly Making A Big Change Prior To Game 4

Heading into the Oilers and Canucks second-round series, Vancouver was thought to be the team with the bigger concern in between the pipes. Vezina Trophy finalist Thatcher Demko was ruled out for at least the first four games of the...

Playing Rookies More, 2025 Draft Pick Concerns, Lonzo’s New Podcast, and Other Bulls Bullets

With the 2024 NBA Draft Combine off to a hot start in their own backyard, I hope the Chicago Bulls have learned from their many past mistakes. More on the importance of these next few days ... https://www.bleachernation.com/bulls/2024/05/14/draft-combine-bulls-work-5/ For a...

NFL Schedule Notes, When Should Bears Debut? Goff, Winfield, Parks, and Other Bears Bullets

Coming home to a wonky wifi wasn't on my to-do list. But at least I'm home in one piece. Anyway, apologies if this set of BN Bears Bullets is brief because I can't spend all day on mobile hotspot. The...

The Luckiest Dude at the Ballpark

I have been to more Cubs and MLB games than I could realistically remember. And not ONCE — not even once — have I caught a ball. No homers, no foul balls, no outfielders chucking it to me. Nothing. And...

Shotamania, Counsell Boot, Rotation, Wesneski, Happ, and Other Cubs Bullets

I hope your Tuesday is treating you well. So far so good on my end ... Shota Imanaga dealt with more traffic last night than he has thus far in his debut MLB season, but hey, that's a ridiculous Braves...

Cubs Injury Notes: Morel, Almonte, Alzolay, Smyly, Wicks

We don't yet know if there's an "injury" here, but it's a pretty scary possibility, so I'm leading with it. If you didn't catch the moment in last night's game, Christopher Morel fouled a ball off his toe in the...

A Reliever Trade! Chicago Cubs Acquiring Tyson Miller from the Mariners

The Chicago Cubs are acquiring righty reliever Tyson Miller from the Seattle Mariners for minor league utility man Jake Slaughter, per Jeff Passan. The Cubs did it! An early-May bullpen trade! It can be done! ... ok, there are some...

more bears news