Reactions to the Huge Samardzija-Hammel Deal – How’d the Cubs Fare in the Eyes of Others?

jason hammel featureBecause of the size and importance of this weekend’s big trade, it’s going to take several days to lay out, discuss, and analyze all of the angles to this thing. You’ve already seen it a bit. That’s not me trying to stretch this thing out – it’s just me being realistic about how much there is to look at, and being realistic about how much folks were going to want to be attached to their computer/phone screens over the course of this lovely summer holiday weekend.

That said, I couldn’t really wait another day to check in on the early and immediate reactions around the baseball world, given that this is one of the biggest trades in recent memory.

One miscellaneous preamble thought I’ve had: with the A’s getting both Samardzija and Hammel, how is the rest of the pitching trade market affected? The A’s weren’t necessarily expected to get a pitcher at all, so, them taking two of the top ones off the market? David Price probably just got even more valuable. But, dare I ask … does Edwin Jackson become tradable? If he is, do the Cubs let him go for a song? Or do they prefer to hang onto him, knowing he could bounce back, and knowing they need some arms going forward?

In any case, some of the reactions around baseball …

  • Mike Petriello offers FanGraphs’ write-up on the deal, and, in addition to the obligatory “Wow,” it’s a fantastic take. On the A’s side, not only does the deal make sense given the down AL this year, but it also makes sense because it ensured that the A’s competitors wouldn’t get one of the two most obviously-available top arms on the market. As for the Cubs, the deal is about stockpiling offensive talent in an era of diminished offense.
  • Jeff Passan says the A’s talked to the Rays first about David Price, but couldn’t get a deal done – even with Addison Russell included. Given all considerations (health, financial, effectiveness), I wonder how much more the Rays wanted for Price. If they turned down, for example, Russell and McKinney for Price, I think they may have made a mistake. We’ll find out over the course of the next few weeks.
  • Ken Rosenthal focuses on the ballsy go-for-it nature of the deal from the A’s perspective, which I think it absolutely is. He mentions Wil Myers’ step back this year, Xander Bogaerts’ struggles to adjust in the bigs, and even Bryce Harper’s issues – it was worth the A’s rolling the dice on Russell. Not that it wasn’t worth it for the Cubs, who now have options going forward.
  • Justin Verlander says the A’s made the deal because of the Tigers. I think it’s a fun thought, especially when it’s across divisions like that – competitors and rivalries and planning and jawing and all that. It’s neat. But baseball really isn’t like other sports in the playoffs. You can increase your playoff success odds slightly, but, for the most part, it’s a crapshoot. To think that the A’s would add pitching specifically so that they can beat the Tigers in the playoffs is not realistic. The A’s want to ensure they make the playoffs, and then ensure they have quality, healthy pitching available in the playoffs. That’s about as far as we can go.
  • Keith Law dug the return for the Cubs, and also dug the deal for the A’s.
  • Jon Heyman says the Cubs may have won the deal in the long-term (well, if the A’s go deep in the playoffs this and next year, can’t both sides win?), and looks at the Cubs’ enviable supply of positional talent that could generate a number of future trades.
  • Peter Gammons says this deal was about the A’s recognizing a market inefficiency: the overvaluing of prospects. That allowed them to pull the trigger on giving up a future star like Russell (and a second excellent prospect in McKinney). To that same point, the Cubs could, in the near-term, take advantage of the same inefficiency by dealing prospects for big league talent. Fun note: Gammons says Billy Beane told Theo Epstein, after the deal was done, that the Cubs just got Barry Larkin. Here’s hoping.
  • And now some Twitter fun:
  • https://twitter.com/ProfessorParks/status/485253519893872640

    written by

    Brett Taylor is the Lead Cubs Writer at Bleacher Nation, and you can find him on Twitter at @BleacherNation and on LinkedIn here. Brett is also the founder of Bleacher Nation, which opened up shop in 2008 as an independent blog about the Chicago Cubs. Later growing to incorporate coverage of other Chicago sports, Bleacher Nation is now one of the largest regional sports blogs on the web.

    more cubs news

    Cubs Farm Report | May 13, 2024: Homers by Davis, Mervis Not Enough in Iowa on Sunday

    Brennen Davis and Matt Mervis hit home runs on Sunday for the Iowa Cubs, but it wasn't enough to earn the team a victory against the Columbus Clippers. That and more are in today's Cubs Farm Report. Cubs Farm Report...

    How I Feel About Kyle Hendricks and the Cubs Rotation Plans After Yesterday’s Start

    Yesterday, the Chicago Cubs won a game started by Kyle Hendricks and closed by Adbert Alzolay. Factually, that is what happened. I know. That's wild. Of course, that's what would've been the expected outcome last season for two of the...

    A Very Good Week for Cubs Prospect Brennen Davis

    After two years lost to injuries mixed in with underperformance at Triple-A, I think it's nice to be able to celebrate a great stretch of baseball from Chicago Cubs outfield prospect Brennen Davis. Thanks to a particularly hot week, Davis...

    Cubs Have Some Elite Bat Speed, PCA Elite in Center Field, Elite Injury Rates, and Other Cubs Bullets

    We had a very nice Mother's Day with the kids, who were very kind to her and each other, and sometimes that's all you're looking for. They got a good mom. Starting in 2024, Statcast has begun tracking bat speed,...

    Let’s See How They Measured Up in Atlanta: Cubs vs Braves Series Preview

    Cubs vs Braves — Six of the Cubs next ten games come against the Atlanta Braves, and the first three are on the road starting tonight. And while the Cubs did recently get Seiya Suzuki, Cody Bellinger, and Justin Steele...

    Cubs Announce (Part of) the Rotation for Atlanta

    Meaning no offense to Kyle Hendricks, but if you had to choose a veteran right-handed in the Cubs' rotation to face the Atlanta Braves this week, you're probably going with Jameson Taillon. We may never know if that was part...

    Wake Up and Watch the Cubs Make Their Mothers Proud

    There is something about seeing Cubs players homer with pink bats that makes me smile extra wide. I suppose it's PROBABLY at least a little because this is one of my favorite Cubs memories: https://twitter.com/ChiSportsDay/status/1788291377333170611 Javy Báez, with the pink...

    Enhanced Box Score: Cubs 5, Pirates 4 – May 12, 2024

    It's Mother's Day. I'm hanging with the family. I don't feel like being as pissed off as a game like that threatened to make me. So I am QUITE relieved by that 10th inning (and the fact that the Cubs...

    Christopher Morel Kicks Off Mother’s Day With Some Love

    I'll just presume he was sending this one out for mom. And I'll also presume that the knee is indeed feeling good. Home run number nine on the season for Christopher Morel: https://twitter.com/MLB/status/1789713524052087082

    Pre-Gamin’: Cubs at Pirates (12:35 CT) – Lineups, Broadcast Info, Game Thread

    CUBS LINEUP — The Cubs have played thirteen series so far this season, and this is already their eighth rubber match. Let's see if Kyle Hendricks and the Cubs can bring this one in. Chicago Cubs Lineup: Nico Hoerner, SS...

    Latest News

    Diamondbacks vs. Reds Prediction: Expert Picks, Odds, Stats & Best Bets – Monday, May 13, 2024

    Ketel Marte will look to extend his 13-game hitting streak when the Arizona Diamondbacks (19-22) take on the Cincinnati Reds (17-23). The Diamondbacks are listed as -151 favorites on the moneyline for the contest, which starts at 9:40 PM ET...

    Angels vs. Cardinals Prediction: Expert Picks, Odds, Stats & Best Bets – Monday, May 13, 2024

    The St. Louis Cardinals (16-24) serve as underdogs on the moneyline (-109) in Monday's contest with the Los Angeles Angels (15-26). The game starts at 9:38 PM ET on BSMW. The Cardinals are favored against the spread in this one...

    Mariners vs. Royals Prediction: Expert Picks, Odds, Stats & Best Bets – Monday, May 13, 2024

    The Seattle Mariners will take the field against the Kansas City Royals (25-17) on Monday. The game begins at 9:40 PM ET on ROOT Sports NW, with the Mariners listed as -147 favorites on the moneyline.George Kirby will get the...

    Padres vs. Rockies Prediction: Expert Picks, Odds, Stats & Best Bets – Monday, May 13, 2024

    The Colorado Rockies (12-28) will put their four-game win streak to the test when they visit the San Diego Padres (22-21) Monday at 9:40 PM ET on SDPA. Oddsmakers consider the Padres to be -221 favorites, while the Rockies are...

    Dodgers vs. Giants Prediction: Expert Picks, Odds, Stats & Best Bets – Monday, May 13, 2024

    The Los Angeles Dodgers will take the field against the San Francisco Giants (19-23) on Monday. The game begins at 9:45 PM ET on SportsNet LA, with the Dodgers listed as -193 favorites on the moneyline.Los Angeles' Yoshinobu Yamamoto gets...

    Elevate Your Betting Game with Best Vivid Picks Promo Code: BETSPERTSGOLF

    By signing up using the Vivid Picks promo code BETSPERTSGOLF and making a minimum deposit of $10, users can unlock an exclusive 90-day subscription to Betsperts Golf. In sports betting and daily fantasy sports (DFS) competitive landscape, gaining an edge...

    Mariners vs. Royals Probable Starting Pitchers – May 13

    The Seattle Mariners (22-19) and the Kansas City Royals (25-17) square off at T-Mobile Park on Monday at 9:40 PM ET, starting a three-game series.The Mariners will give the ball to George Kirby (3-3, 4.15 ERA), who is eyeing win...

    Padres vs. Rockies Probable Starting Pitchers – May 13

    The San Diego Padres (22-21) play on Monday at 9:40 PM ET against the Colorado Rockies (12-28), who enter the contest with a four-game winning streak.The Padres will give the nod to Randy Vasquez (0-1, 4.50 ERA), who is eyeing...

    Dodgers vs. Giants Probable Starting Pitchers – May 13

    The San Francisco Giants (19-23) kick off a three-game series on Monday against the Los Angeles Dodgers (27-15). The contest starts at 9:45 PM ET at Oracle Park.The Dodgers will give the ball to Gavin Stone (3-1, 3.55 ERA), who...

    Diamondbacks vs. Reds Probable Starting Pitchers – May 13

    The Cincinnati Reds (17-23) begin a three-game series against the Arizona Diamondbacks (19-22) on Monday at Chase Field. First pitch is at 9:40 PM.The Diamondbacks will give the ball to Jordan Montgomery (2-2, 4.70 ERA), who is eyeing win No....

    more cubs news