Lukewarm Stove: Prospect Currency, Haren, Koehler, Niese, Hamels, Schwarber, More

old stove featureEarlier, we talked about the Cubs’ presumed pursuit of pitching in the coming month and how the ideal targets may have shifted in recent days, and we also talked about Thursday’s opening of the next IFA period. I mention that here because, well, they’re kind of Lukewarm Stove-y topics, and if you missed them, now you can un-miss them.

Among the other things rolling around out there …

  • It’s a tricky thing for fans to have bought so whole-heartedly into the “acquisition mode” the Cubs employed for the last three years, and then flip a switch on the inevitable prospect affection that followed. Patrick Mooney offers a great read on that very topic, reminding folks that there’s a timing element to trading prospects. The Cubs know they can’t keep everyone (there wouldn’t be spots for everyone if they all did pan out, and, since they won’t all pan out, some have more value right now than they every will again).
  • A reminder: prospects are a kind of baseball currency, and they can help the big league roster in two ways. First, they can blossom into young, big league, cost-controlled talent, and directly help win games. Second, they can serve as assets, used to acquire other big league pieces. The very best teams use their prospects in both of these ways, and the most successful teams have a knack for keeping the best prospects for the former group, and trading the ones who wind up stalling out or never reaching their ceiling. At some point, the Cubs will trade a prospect you love. Brace yourself now. This was always part of the plan (The Plan).
  • A great read from Sahadev Sharma on the men in charge of the Cubs, and how they work with the coaching staff continuously to evaluate strengths and weaknesses, needs and surpluses. Although it’s not the focus of the piece, I can’t help but be struck – again – by just how much Starlin Castro’s struggles are hurting the Cubs’ offense this year, and, moreover, how difficult it really is to make any kind of change there in-season. The Cubs aren’t going to get much value for Castro in trade right now (which might have allowed them not only to get a nice return, but also to shuffle some guys internally, and upgrade a bat at another position externally), so the hope is that he rebounds. Until then, he’s effectively blocking a spot where the Cubs might otherwise be able to upgrade offensively, without actually providing a “blocking”-caliber performance.
  • There’s an implication – though something shy of a clear suggestion – in this Tribune piece that Marlins starters Dan Haren and Tom Koehler could be among the Cubs’ plausible pitching targets this month. Haren, 34, is a very different pitcher than he was a few years ago when the Cubs very nearly traded for him, but he’s still had some success. His 3.38 ERA is fantastic this year, though the 4.26 FIP and 4.31 xFIP mostly hint at the troubles under the surface (a career-low BABIP, 54(!) points below his career mark; and an 80.4% LOB rate (72.6% career mark)). He’s a serious, serious regression candidate. Koehler, 29, is an interesting back-of-the-rotation/depth type, who is not eligible for arbitration for the first time until next year. The career numbers aren’t sexy – 4.03 ERA, 4.18 FIP, 4.20 xFIP – but they are about what you’d hope for out of a depth guy who makes close to the minimum. Would you want to have that guy on the roster? Sure. Would you want him as the 5th starter in a playoff chase? Eh, maybe. Would you want to give up much of anything to get him? Not really.
  • Haren comes in for mention here at ESPN, too, together with this past weekend’s rumored arm, Jon Niese. Jon Heyman later reported that Niese was no longer a current Cubs target, for what it’s worth.
  • Speaking of Niese, I’ve been mulling how he could be a fit for the past couple days, and the best I could come up with for both teams would be a deal where the Mets are getting a player like Javy Baez (huge offensive upside at a spot where they’ve got needs) and they’re saving salary by shedding Niese, and the Cubs get Niese (can use him at the back-of-the-rotation this and next year), together with some risky upside arms like Zack Wheeler (TJS) and Rafael Montero (shoulder questions). I’m not saying, specifically, that that’s a deal the Cubs should consider – and all of this is my own thinking-out-loud speculation. But isn’t that the kind of deal that makes sense? The Cubs improve now and in the future on the pitching side using their positional depth. I know you’d love to see the Cubs get more sure thing young arms, but you’ve got to be a little realistic here.
  • On Niese, Ken Rosenthal previously noted that the Dodgers had also considered him, but he’s since added that there are no active talks.
  • Steve Phillips said today on Kap and Haugh that, if a trade for Cole Hamels involving Kyle Schwarber were presented to the Cubs, they should not refuse to part with Schwarber (Phillips is particularly convinced that Schwarber never catches in the big leagues). This is not a rumor, mind you – it’s just a hypothetical (but not entirely unrealistic) discussion.
  • From where I sit, depending on the money, I won’t fight anyone who says that a package including Schwarber is a fair return in a Hamels deal. The question I have – the one I’ve had even going back to last August when the Cubs claimed Hamels on waivers but did not trade for him – is whether Hamels, in trade, is the best approach for the Cubs to get another high-end arm. Getting a rental now and signing a high-end free agent starter after the season will absolutely cost much, much more money. And that is not a small consideration for the Cubs right now, unfortunately. But, in that scenario, the Cubs would still have Schwarber. So, in some ways, the questions are (1) how much is Schwarber worth in salary (i.e., and very roughly speaking, the difference between what Hamels is owed and what a free agent starter would cost)? and (2) how much value exists in the certainty of having a guy under contract (as opposed to heading into free agency and hoping you can get your guy)? This is a conversation worth having, but I am not sure any deal this year involving Schwarber is going to make sense for the Cubs. Maybe I’m crazy, but I still want to know if he can be a part-time catcher come 2016.
  • written by

    Brett Taylor is the Lead Cubs Writer at Bleacher Nation, and you can find him on Twitter at @BleacherNation and on LinkedIn here. Brett is also the founder of Bleacher Nation, which opened up shop in 2008 as an independent blog about the Chicago Cubs. Later growing to incorporate coverage of other Chicago sports, Bleacher Nation is now one of the largest regional sports blogs on the web.

    more cubs news

    Spring Training Miscellany: Cubs Beat Brewers, Wicks, Kilian, Canario, Wieck, More

    Here's hoping today's outcome against the Brewers is a preview for the regular season. Cubs win 6-1. Jordan Wicks looked pretty good today, using all of his pitches, getting a ton of grounders, and striking out two through three scoreless....

    Cubs vs Brewers: Lineups, Broadcast Info, Game Thread

    *HOMAGE is excited to reissue the iconic CUBS STARTER SATIN JACKET in an exclusive limited edition release. A certified nineties throwback, these exclusive vintage-inspired jackets are built for the dugout, with all the classic details of the original. Get your...

    Notes and Thoughts from Cody Bellinger’s Return Press Conference

    If you weren't able to watch the Cody Bellinger re-introductory press conference, the Chicago Cubs streamed it on Twitter, so you can catch up if you like (I am embedding it at the bottom of this post). Some of the...

    Everyone Jokes (They Are Jokes, Right?) About the Cubs Doing Another Deal with Scott Boras

    The Cody Bellinger re-introductory press conference is happening right now, complete with his agent Scott Boras, but there are a couple things I had to note right now. They are jokes. Just jokes. Almost certainly just jokes. First was this,...

    Cody Bellinger is Back and Working with the Team, But Don’t Expect to See Him in a Cubs Game Right Away

    With his new three-year deal officially official, Cody Bellinger is back with the Chicago Cubs, working out today at Sloan Park in Mesa, Arizona. https://twitter.com/WatchMarquee/status/1762869431930102066 Bellinger got right out on the practice fields to work with his mates, which was...

    Insight Into Craig Counsell’s Relationship with the Chicago Cubs’ Front Office

    Back when he was hired to be the new manager of the Chicago Cubs, replacing David Ross and receiving the largest managerial contract in baseball history, one of the main talking point about Craig Counsell was that he is more...

    Cubs All Done in the Bullpen? Out on Ryne Stanek?

    I'd wanted to touch on this yesterday, but since we knew a pitcher trade was likely to happen, I figured I would wait to see what the fallout there suggested. That trade happened - Bailey Horn for Matt Thompson -...

    Big Free Agents, Tough Divisions, Belli Back, PCA and Bunting, and Other Cubs Bullets

    Like everyone else in the Midwest, it seems, we dealt with tornado warnings and sirens in the wee hours. And because there were reports of actual tornados in the area, we did the whole get-the-kids-and-go-to-the-basement thing. So we're all gonna...

    Officially Official: Cody Bellinger is Back

    With the Bailey Horn trade executed and a 40-man roster spot opened, the Chicago Cubs were free today to finalized Cody Bellinger's re-signing. The team announced it as officially official: https://twitter.com/Cubs/status/1762614686384628199 Cody Bellinger was a stud for the Cubs last...

    Spring Training Miscellany: Fly The T, Youngsters Come Back, Hendricks, Shaw, PCA, More

    The Cubs came back from a 6-0 deficit in the late innings to tie this one up, and that's where it ended, a 6-6 tie with the Reds. It's Spring Training after all. It took 7+ innings today after a...

    Latest News

    Arizona vs. Oregon: Start Time, Streaming Live, TV Channel, How to Watch

    The No. 6 Arizona Wildcats (22-6, 13-4 Pac-12) host the Oregon Ducks (19-9, 11-6 Pac-12) in Pac-12 play at McKale Center, beginning at 2:00 PM ET on Saturday, March 2, 2024.In its most recent game, Arizona defeated Arizona State on...

    Austin Peay vs. Bellarmine: Free Live Stream, TV Channel, How to Watch

    The Bellarmine Knights (8-22, 4-11 ASUN) will visit the Austin Peay Governors (16-14, 9-6 ASUN) after losing three straight road games.Austin Peay won its previous game against Eastern Kentucky, 83-79, on Wednesday. Sai Witt led the way with 26 points,...

    How to Watch La Salle Explorers vs. George Washington Revolutionaries: Live Stream or on TV

    The George Washington Revolutionaries (14-14, 3-12 A-10) will try to end an 11-game losing streak when they hit the road to play the La Salle Explorers (14-15, 5-11 A-10) on March 2, 2024 at Tom Gola Arena.In its most recent...

    Radford vs. UNC Asheville: Free Live Stream, TV Channel, How to Watch

    The Radford Highlanders (15-15, 5-10 Big South) host the UNC Asheville Bulldogs (19-11, 11-4 Big South) in Big South action at Donald N. Dedmon Center, beginning at 2:00 PM ET on Saturday, March 2, 2024.Radford dropped its previous game to...

    Big Ten Basketball Predictions, Computer Picks and Best Bets | February 29

    The Michigan Wolverines versus the Rutgers Scarlet Knights is one of two games on Thursday's college basketball slate that features a Big Ten team in play, and we've got best bets tips for you.How to Bet on Big Ten Games[lasso...

    AAC Basketball Predictions, Computer Picks and Best Bets | February 29

    Just one AAC game is on Thursday's college basketball schedule. That matchup is the Memphis Tigers squaring off against the East Carolina Pirates at Minges Coliseum, and we have best bets recommendations across the board.How to Bet on AAC Games[lasso...

    Pac-12 Basketball Predictions, Computer Picks and Best Bets | February 29

    The UCLA Bruins versus the Washington Huskies is one of three games on the Thursday college basketball schedule that features a Pac-12 team. If you look below, you can see our best bets for that conference action.How to Bet on...

    CUSA Basketball Predictions, Computer Picks and Best Bets | February 29

    The UTEP Miners versus the Jacksonville State Gamecocks is one of two games on Thursday's college basketball slate that features a CUSA team in action, and we've got best bets tips for you.How to Bet on CUSA Games[lasso ref="draftkings-promo-1" id="299003"...

    Top 25 College Basketball Picks and Best Bets: February 29

    Top-25 teams will hit the court in three games on Thursday's college basketball slate. That includes the Saint Mary's Gaels playing the Pepperdine Waves at Firestone Fieldhouse.How to Bet on Top 25 Games[lasso ref="draftkings-promo-1" id="299003" link_id="1439000"]Top 25 Games for February...

    Lakers vs. Wizards Prediction: Expert Picks, Odds, Stats and Best Bets – Thursday, February 29, 2024

    The Washington Wizards (9-49) visit the Los Angeles Lakers (32-28) after losing five straight road games. The Lakers are favored by 9.5 points in the contest, which begins at 10:30 PM ET on Thursday, February 29, 2024. The matchup's over/under...

    more cubs news