With Cole Hamels on the Way, Do the Cubs Finally Go with a Six-Man Rotation?

Although it hasn’t been officially announced by the teams yet, it’s coming: Cole Hamels, a starting pitcher, will be joining the Chicago Cubs, who have a full five-man rotation. (UPDATE: It’s official.)

So, then, among the many things to discuss about Hamels is … how exactly does he fit into the rotation?

Well, to dispense with the obvious: even though Hamels is being picked up as a depth/upside/bounceback guy, he is absolutely and unquestionably assured of a rotation spot for the foreseeable future. He’s a veteran starter who is having a down year in the results department, but whom the Cubs clearly want to give chance to pitch in a competitive environment, in a new home ballpark, in front of a better defense, in a DH-less league, etc. There are reasons to believe Hamels can be a solid starter again with the Cubs.

If everyone else in the rotation is healthy, then, what happens?

Well, if the Cubs are determined to stick with a five-man rotation, that means either Tyler Chatwood or Mike Montgomery are bounced. Chatwood makes more sense from a performance standpoint (it is nearly impossible to justify giving him another start right now, let alone another 10). Montgomery makes more sense from a bullpen need standpoint (he’s been very successful there before, and lefty Brian Duensing has been ineffective all year).

Montgomery, to me, has earned the right to stay in the rotation, and also gives the Cubs a better chance to win when he starts than Chatwood. But I understand that Montgomery is getting up in innings, and you don’t want to see him wear down at the end of the year because his leap in innings from 2017 (130.2) to this year was too dramatic.

I question how comfortable the Cubs would be moving Chatwood to the bullpen at this point, given his extreme wildness. He’d go from starting pitcher to pure mop-up man, and is that really worth a bullpen spot? (Which, of course, highlights how crazy it is that he’s getting *starts* right now.)

If there isn’t a phantom injury, I tend to think the best move for the Cubs is a six-man rotation for a stretch. It keeps everyone starting, but gives everyone extra rest (which could allow them to go a little deeper into games, and, in turn, could sharpen up the bullpen). The risk is that the starters all keep going five innings, and then you have either a shorter bullpen to cover the same number of innings, or you have to go with an absurd three-man bench so that you can keep eight in the bullpen.

Of all the options, though, I think I’m willing to take that risk for a little while.

Generally speaking and in the aggregate, through the history of baseball, guys pitch better on extra rest. It’s just a thing. Maybe they don’t like it, maybe they have to adjust routines, but it’s a statistical reality.

Joe Maddon didn’t sound opposed to a six-man rotation this week when discussing what he’d do if the Cubs added another starting pitcher (Sun-Times): I’m not opposed to six [starters] this time of the year. The quality of the guy coming in would matter, also.”

Again, although he’s struggled this year, Hamels is a former ace, a veteran who still has his velocity and stuff, and a “name” who undoubtedly commands some respect in the clubhouse. There won’t be any issues with the Cubs and Maddon saying, “Here’s what we’re doing now because we have this guy.”

If everyone is healthy, my vote is six-man rotation for now. From there, these things tend to sort themselves out quickly anyway.

written by

Brett Taylor is the Lead Cubs Writer at Bleacher Nation, and you can find him on Twitter at @BleacherNation and on LinkedIn here. Brett is also the founder of Bleacher Nation, which opened up shop in 2008 as an independent blog about the Chicago Cubs. Later growing to incorporate coverage of other Chicago sports, Bleacher Nation is now one of the largest regional sports blogs on the web.

more cubs news

Enhanced Box Score: Braves 2, Cubs 0 – May 13, 2024

Well that ninth inning rally started off great, with Cody Bellinger and Christopher Morel reaching, the latter on 12-pitch walk (the longest PA of his career). And then POOF. In just two pitches, the Cubs made three outs and the...

Craig Counsell Was Just Thrown Out from the Dugout … by the First Base Umpire

Well you don't see that very often. Craig Counsell was just thrown out of the game from inside the Cubs dugout *by the FIRST BASE umpire* after a check-swing appeal. Here's what happened. In the bottom of the fourth inning,...

Pre-Gamin’: Cubs at Braves (6:20 CT) – Lineups, Broadcast Info, Game Thread

CUBS LINEUP — The Atlanta Braves are one of, if not the toughest opponent the Cubs will face this season. But Seiya Suzuki is back, Cody Bellinger is back, and Shota Imanaga is on the mound. This Cubs team is...

Cubs Roster Move: Alzolay to the IL, Cuas Returns (UPDATE)

It felt like this situation with Adbert Alzolay could not go on much longer, and it has now resolved itself with an Injured List move. Today, the Cubs placed Alzolay on the 15-day IL with a right forearm strain. Jose...

MLB Has a New Streaming Home For Its ‘Sunday Leadoff’ Games

Fans can now watch MLB games via Roku. Do with that what you will. The "MLB Sunday Leadoff" games will begin this weekend. The first game, featuring the Boston Red Sox and St. Louis Cardinals, starts at 12:05 p.m. CT,...

Let’s See How They Measure Up in Atlanta: Cubs vs Braves Series Preview

Cubs vs Braves — Six of the Cubs next ten games come against the Atlanta Braves, and the first three are on the road starting tonight. And while the Cubs did recently get Seiya Suzuki, Cody Bellinger, and Justin Steele...

MLB Pipeline Added Two MORE Cubs to Their Top-100

Over the weekend, MLB Pipeline updated their top-100 MLB Prospect Rankings, with eight new players making the list after graduations and other considerations. And TWO of those players, Moises Ballesteros and Jefferson Rojas, are Chicago Cubs prospects. All together, that...

For the Second Time in a Few Days, Birthday Boy Nico Hoerner Saved the Game

A happy 27th birthday to Chicago Cubs second baseman, and fill-in shortstop, Nico Hoerner. He is currently hitting a career-best .275/.364/.399/122 wRC+, and walking more often (9.7%) than he's striking out (9.1%). He has been absolutely scorching over the past...

MLBits: Padres Best the Dodgers, Skenes Debut Reactions, Guardians New Threads, More

The Dodgers have a comfortable lead in the NL West, but the Padres are proving to themselves that they can make this a two-horse race. Plus, reactions from Paul Skenes' major league debut and more in today's MLB Notes. Padres...

David Peralta Has Opted Out of His Minor League Deal with the Cubs

The Chicago Cubs have had veteran outfielder David Peralta around as emergency depth going back to Spring Training, when he was working his way back from offseason arm surgery. But he might now be heading off to join another organization....

Latest News

Cardinals vs. Angels: Free Live Stream, TV Channel, How to Watch

In a series opener on Tuesday, Sonny Gray will take the mound for the St. Louis Cardinals (16-24) against Reid Detmers and the Los Angeles Angels (15-26), with first pitch scheduled for 9:38 PM ET at Angel Stadium of Anaheim.The...

Diamondbacks vs. Reds: Start Time, Streaming Live, TV Channel, How to Watch

On Tuesday at 9:40 PM ET, Ketel Marte and the Arizona Diamondbacks (19-22) face Elly De La Cruz and the Cincinnati Reds (17-23) at Chase Field.Find out how to watch the Arizona-Cincinnati matchup below.When is Diamondbacks vs. Reds and when...

Mariners vs. Royals: Start Time, Streaming Live, TV Channel, How to Watch

On Tuesday, Logan Gilbert will start for the Seattle Mariners (22-19) versus Michael Wacha and the Kansas City Royals (25-17), with first pitch scheduled for 9:40 PM ET at T-Mobile Park.Keep reading to find out how to watch the Seattle-Kansas...

How to Watch Padres vs. Rockies: Live Stream or on TV

The San Diego Padres (22-21), who will give the ball to Dylan Cease, host the Colorado Rockies (12-28) with Cal Quantrill on the mound, Tuesday at 9:40 PM ET.If you're trying to watch this game, keep reading for TV and...

Minnesota Twins vs. New York Yankees Series May 14-16: Odds, Starting Pitchers & Predictions

A three-game series featuring the Minnesota Twins and the visiting New York Yankees will begin on Tuesday, May 14 at 7:40 PM ET.Twins vs. Yankees Series Info Yankees @ Twins Time: Tuesday, May 14 at 7:40 PM ET Twins Starting...

Rangers vs. Guardians: Free Live Stream, TV Channel, How to Watch

On Tuesday, Jack Leiter will start for the Texas Rangers (22-20) against Ben Lively and the Cleveland Guardians (25-16), with first pitch scheduled for 8:05 PM ET at Globe Life Field.Keep reading to find out all the details on how...

How to Watch Astros vs. Athletics: Live Stream or on TV

On Tuesday at 8:10 PM ET, Kyle Tucker and the Houston Astros (15-25) play Brent Rooker and the Oakland Athletics (19-23) at Minute Maid Park.The article below will provide you with everything you need to know to watch Houston take...

Craig Counsell Was Just Thrown Out from the Dugout … by the First Base Umpire

Well you don't see that very often. Craig Counsell was just thrown out of the game from inside the Cubs dugout *by the FIRST BASE umpire* after a check-swing appeal. Here's what happened. In the bottom of the fourth inning,...

Red Sox vs. Rays: Start Time, Streaming Live, TV Channel, How to Watch

In a series opener on Tuesday, Jarren Duran and the Boston Red Sox (21-19) play Isaac Paredes and the Tampa Bay Rays (20-21), with first pitch scheduled for 7:10 PM ET at Fenway Park.Find out how to watch the Boston-Tampa...

Brewers vs. Pirates: Free Live Stream, TV Channel, How to Watch

On Tuesday, Joe Ross will start for the Milwaukee Brewers (24-16) versus Quinn Priester and the Pittsburgh Pirates (18-23), with first pitch scheduled for 7:40 PM ET at American Family Field.Find out how to watch the Milwaukee-Pittsburgh matchup below.When is...

more cubs news