Reading Up on the Jason Heyward Signing, and How Things Went So Sideways So Quickly

Remember when the Cubs signed 26-year-old free agent stud Jason Heyward to an eight-year contract that was assuredly actually just a three-year deal, since he was obviously going to opt out after three years?

Ah. The whimsy of youth and offseason transaction excitement. It made for a really fun few weeks in the winter of 2015, if nothing else.

Thoughts of that opt out, which has come and gone this offseason, retreated far into the background almost immediately upon Heyward actually taking the field for the Cubs, underperforming in a historically woeful way in 2016. He only barely approached playable at the plate over the two years that followed, and left us to confidently consider the coming five years with Heyward under contract.

So … what in the sweet heck happened?

In an offseason that features two other superstar 26-year-olds hitting free agency, Michael Baumann asked that question at The Ringer, ultimately noting that what happened with Heyward’s performance was “a stark historical outlier,” and not the kind of thing that would give you pause about future contracts. “Throughout baseball history,” Baumann writes, “almost nobody that good and that young got this bad this quickly without suffering an injury far more disastrous than what Heyward has played through.”

Of course, those injuries are not a non-factor in what has happened to Heyward, especially the early-2016 wrist injury that mucked up Heyward’s performance, then mucked up his swing, then mucked up his approach, and then mucked up his mind. Indeed, I don’t think it’s at all unreasonable, with time and distance, to claim that Heyward’s disastrous 2016 debut with the Cubs almost entirely traces its origins to the wrist injury.

But, there have been two years since then, and neither looked anything at all like the Heyward whom the Cubs originally signed to a monster contract. So, again … what in the sweet heck happened?

It’s worth a read, even if it’s going to make you sad to see what Heyward was before coming to the Cubs, and to see what has happened to his ability to just hit the dang ball hard the last few years:

It’s important to point out that Heyward has provided some value in his three years with the Cubs, even if it doesn’t even come close to meeting the expectations of the contract he signed. Such is the risk of big-money free agency, and you take the good with the bad. At least Heyward has continued to play good defense, to run the bases well, and to come close to being a league-average bat in 2018.

It remains plausible that he could be an above-average bat in 2019 and beyond, and thus be an overall very valuable player, starting maybe 70-80% of the games, and moving between right field and center field as the Cubs require.

(Photo by Jonathan Daniel/Getty Images)

These kinds of deals are generally supposed to be at their most valuable and impactful in approximately the first three years. Fortunately, because Heyward was so young when he signed this one, he’s not yet 30 even after those first three years. Hope, in this case, is perhaps a little more reasonable. But that’s most of what we’re left with after three years: just hope.

I don’t really think there’s much of a broader lesson here about free agency, given the idiosyncrasies in Heyward’s fall-off, as noted by Baumann. I guess the only thing would be that the margin for error is slightly reduced if the free agent you’re signing is 26 rather than 31, but then, in the current era, those 31-year-old free agents aren’t getting the kinds of eight-year deals you later come to regret. That now seems the exclusive province of much younger players, so I guess if you’re wrong, you’re paying for it either way.

Heck, it makes me wonder at what point older free agents will become so undervalued that you’re best off just trying to keep signing those guys to short-term deals in free agency.

written by

Brett Taylor is the Lead Cubs Writer at Bleacher Nation, and you can find him on Twitter at @BleacherNation and on LinkedIn here. Brett is also the founder of Bleacher Nation, which opened up shop in 2008 as an independent blog about the Chicago Cubs. Later growing to incorporate coverage of other Chicago sports, Bleacher Nation is now one of the largest regional sports blogs on the web.

more cubs news

Garrett Cooper Reportedly Signing with the Chicago Cubs

The Cubs aren't completely finished making moves even after re-signing Cody Bellinger. But any additional moves they make are MOST LIKELY to be around the edges. Modest moves. Minor moves. No-risk moves. For example, bringing in another right-handed bench bat...

Spring Training Miscellany: Cubs Shut Out, Assad, Palencia, Escobar, Morel

The Cubs lost their first spring game today, shut out by the Padres 7-0. Probably because they didn't have the (old) new guy available yet ... Hand up, I was pretty distracted from this one by all things Cody Bellinger,...

Lisa L Dubbs Scooped Jeff Passan on the Cody Bellinger Signing, and It’s Now Part of Cubs History

Seven years ago, just before the 2017 MLB Trade Deadline, the Chicago Cubs pulled off the exceedingly rare major trade with the crosstown Chicago White Sox. We don't need to get into the particulars of that trade or re-litigate the...

Cubs vs Padres: Lineups, Broadcast Info, Game Thread

Pssh. Why did the Cubs even sign Cody Bellinger? They were already undefeated in the Cactus League. And, no, he's not in there yet. Patience! What's one more day? Chicago Cubs Lineup: Nico Hoerner, 2B Ian Happ, LF Dansby Swanson,...

Teammates QUITE Happy to Have Cody Bellinger Back with the Cubs

Chicago Cubs players have made it known for QUITE some time that they really wanted Cody Bellinger back with the team for 2024. So it's no surprise that they are celebrating the news of his re-signing today. Among the reactions:...

My Favorite Part About Having Cody Bellinger Back on the Cubs

There are a dozen reasons this overnight deal with Cody Bellinger is good news for the 2024 Chicago Cubs. In terms of performance, they needed his bat, his left-handedness, and his general ability and leadership. And from a financial/roster standpoint,...

HE’S COMING BACK!!! CUBS RE-SIGN CODY BELLINGER!!!

What a news drop to wake up to on a Sunday morning. WOW. Jeff Passan just dropping the major Cody Bellinger report in the middle of the freaking night. The Chicago Cubs and Cody Bellinger have agreed to a new...

Cody Bellinger’s Return to the Cubs and the Ensuing Roster Fallout

Eight years ago today, beloved one-year center fielder Dexter Fowler shocked everyone at Cubs camp in Arizona by strolling onto the practice fields to tell them he'd just re-signed and would be returning to the team in 2016. You go,...

Spring Training Miscellany: Another Win, Smyly, Brown, Thompson, Davis, Mastrobuoni, More

The Cubs will (1) never lose this spring, and (2) blow it out every game. Cubs beat the Giants 8-4 on the strength of a few homers (Brennen Davis, David Bote, Chase Strumpf), and pitching that just kinda allowed nothing...

Brennen Davis is Having a DAY, and That Makes Me Happy

We are all hoping that, after two years mostly lost to core/back injuries and surgeries, former top-50 prospect Brennen Davis could find his way back onto the radar this year. Being healthy is the first step. So far, so good...

Latest News

Lehigh vs. Boston University: Free Live Stream, TV Channel, How to Watch

The Lehigh Mountain Hawks (12-15, 9-7 Patriot League) will look to build on a five-game win streak when they host the Boston University Terriers (13-16, 8-8 Patriot League) on February 28, 2024. The Terriers have won three games in a...

Lehigh vs. Boston University: Free Live Stream, TV Channel, How to Watch

The Lehigh Mountain Hawks (12-15, 9-7 Patriot League) will look to build on a five-game win streak when they host the Boston University Terriers (13-16, 8-8 Patriot League) on February 28, 2024. The Terriers have won three games in a...

Lehigh vs. Boston University: Free Live Stream, TV Channel, How to Watch

The Lehigh Mountain Hawks (12-15, 9-7 Patriot League) will look to build on a five-game win streak when they host the Boston University Terriers (13-16, 8-8 Patriot League) on February 28, 2024. The Terriers have won three games in a...

How to Watch Rice Owls vs. Temple Owls: Live Stream or on TV

AAC action features the Rice Owls (11-16, 5-9 AAC) at home against the Temple Owls (10-17, 3-11 AAC) on Wednesday, February 28, 2024 at 8:00 PM ET.Rice won its previous game versus East Carolina, 70-52, on Saturday. Travis Evee starred...

How to Watch Rice Owls vs. Temple Owls: Live Stream or on TV

AAC action features the Rice Owls (11-16, 5-9 AAC) at home against the Temple Owls (10-17, 3-11 AAC) on Wednesday, February 28, 2024 at 8:00 PM ET.Rice won its previous game versus East Carolina, 70-52, on Saturday. Travis Evee starred...

How to Watch Rice Owls vs. Temple Owls: Live Stream or on TV

AAC action features the Rice Owls (11-16, 5-9 AAC) at home against the Temple Owls (10-17, 3-11 AAC) on Wednesday, February 28, 2024 at 8:00 PM ET.Rice won its previous game versus East Carolina, 70-52, on Saturday. Travis Evee starred...

Robert Morris vs. Northern Kentucky: Start Time, Streaming Live, TV Channel, How to Watch

The Robert Morris Colonials (10-19, 6-12 Horizon League) will look to halt a four-game losing streak when they host the Northern Kentucky Norse (16-13, 11-7 Horizon League) on February 28, 2024 at UPMC Events Center.Robert Morris dropped its most recent...

Robert Morris vs. Northern Kentucky: Start Time, Streaming Live, TV Channel, How to Watch

The Robert Morris Colonials (10-19, 6-12 Horizon League) will look to halt a four-game losing streak when they host the Northern Kentucky Norse (16-13, 11-7 Horizon League) on February 28, 2024 at UPMC Events Center.Robert Morris dropped its most recent...

Robert Morris vs. Northern Kentucky: Start Time, Streaming Live, TV Channel, How to Watch

The Robert Morris Colonials (10-19, 6-12 Horizon League) will look to halt a four-game losing streak when they host the Northern Kentucky Norse (16-13, 11-7 Horizon League) on February 28, 2024 at UPMC Events Center.Robert Morris dropped its most recent...

Youngstown State vs. Detroit Mercy: Free Live Stream, TV Channel, How to Watch

The Detroit Mercy Titans (1-28, 1-17 Horizon League) aim to stop a 17-game road losing streak when they visit the Youngstown State Penguins (21-9, 13-6 Horizon League) on February 28, 2024.Youngstown State was victorious in its previous game versus Green...

more cubs news