A Reminder on the Fickle Nature of Prospects and Other Bullets

epstein and carpenterI haven’t reminded you folks in a while, so I’ll do it now: follow BN on Twitter and like it on Facebook to ensure that you’re getting everything I vomit out there into the interwebz. Clearly, it’s all gold.

  • Patrick Mooney talks to Jeff Samardzija, reflecting back on those Theo Epstein compensation rumors* back in 2011 – remember when Samardzija’s name came up? at the time, he was but a promising young reliever – and he’s got a good memory about it, because he nails rumored players involved. The players mentioned at the time, in addition to Samardzija, were Trey McNutt, Brett Jackson, and Chris Carpenter. The latter was ultimately sent to the Red Sox (together with PTBNL Aaron Kurcz), almost immediately had bone spurs surgery, and now pitches overseas. McNutt, the clear top pitching prospect in the organization at the time, has struggled ever since then, has dealt with injury issues, and was long ago removed from the 40-man roster. Jackson, whom we discussed yesterday, hasn’t been able to overcome his swing issues yet. Remember how vehemently opposed to to idea of losing any of these guys for Epstein we were? How absurd we thought that price to be (setting aside the fact that holding an organization hostage for compensation when a guy is getting a promotion is just lame)? I think those feelings were justified, based on asset value at the time, but it’s a reminder about how quickly value can change when you’re talking about prospects – especially ones who’ve not yet reached, and performed well at, AAA.
  • That’s all worth remembering as we (likely) watch the Cubs pick up some prospects in trade over the next month, and then we (possibly) see the Cubs trading away prospects in the offseason for big league pieces.
  • *(Going back and reading old stuff is always fascinating. For example, that compensation rumor piece – which was one of dozens that offseason – mentions a Bruce Levine report that had Epstein first asking Josh Byrnes, then a VP with the Padres, to come to Chicago to be his GM. When Byrnes declined, according to the report, Epstein then asked San Diego GM Jed Hoyer, who first sought an extension from the Padres, but it wasn’t going to happen, so Hoyer moved on to the Cubs, and Byrnes was elevated to GM. Obviously we can’t know if any of this is true (I think it was all a little more collaborative than that, and wasn’t necessarily a “first choice, second choice” situation), and three years later, everyone’s probably very happy how things worked out. Well, maybe except Byrnes, who was fired by the Padres a couple weeks ago. Wonder whether, given their previous connections and this stuff right here, the Cubs will come calling to see if Byrnes would consider a different front office role.)
  • More from Jesse Rogers on Junior Lake’s contact issues. Most notable are the “low ball” stats, which have Lake doing virtually nothing with anything in the lower third of the strike zone or lower.
  • The Cubs are auctioning off “Favorite Things” baskets for charity, which contain some of the Cubs’ players’ favorite things. You get a little window into the guys as people. Jake Arrieta’s, for example, includes a Leatherman, because he’s a bro who can help you fix your broken cabinet. John Baker, however, wins my heart with, among other things, a coffee stout, a Lego Millennium Falcon, ‘Slaughterhouse Five’, and ‘A Game of Thrones’. Maybe the three of us can hang out some time, and John and I will have a great stout and build a Lego Mos Eisley cantina while Jake fixes a chair.
  • This is genuinely apropos of nothing, and I’m not even sure how I landed on it, but I found this Gawker article on Twitter – and how everything you choose to put on there is public (because obviously) – quite funny and poignant. I do think sometimes folks forget that, and also forget that the Internet is likely to live on much longer than your lack of shame.
  • MLB.com produced a video of Lou Gehrig’s famous Luckiest Man speech on its 75th anniversary, featuring a number of MLB players (mostly first basemen, including Anthony Rizzo) joining in with Gehrig in the speech. Very cool watch.
  • Your BN Blogathon fundraiser for Make-A-Wish visual update – we’re doing really well through two days, but there’s still a long way to go:
  • written by

    Brett Taylor is the Lead Cubs Writer at Bleacher Nation, and you can find him on Twitter at @BleacherNation and on LinkedIn here. Brett is also the founder of Bleacher Nation, which opened up shop in 2008 as an independent blog about the Chicago Cubs. Later growing to incorporate coverage of other Chicago sports, Bleacher Nation is now one of the largest regional sports blogs on the web.

    more cubs news

    Happy Lee Elia Day! The Managerial Rant to End All Managerial Rants

    The Chicago Cubs have, unfortunately, had some bad starts over the years, and late-April is not always a still-hopeful time for the team's fans, as it is this year. Consider the team and the situation back on this day in...

    Chicago Cubs Catching Prospect Pablo Aliendo Getting Some Love

    When I saw that The Athletic had written up 20 "underrated" prospects with a Chicago Cubs tag, I just assumed the prospect was going to be Jefferson Rojas, and I was going to mutter to myself that it's pretty silly...

    Cubs Farm Report | April 29, 2024: Weekend Wrap

    Kevin Alcántara cooled off over the weekend while the rest of Tennessee's offense followed suit. Thankfully for the Smokies, they were able to sprinkle a Cade Horton gem in there on Saturday. That and more in today's Cubs Farm Report....

    Staying East: Cubs vs Mets Series Preview

    Cubs vs Mets — The Cubs are starting a fresh four-game series tonight in New York against the Mets. And, of course, they'll do it without Justin Steele, Jordan Wicks, Kyle Hendricks, Cody Bellinger, Seiya Suzuki, or Julian Merryweather. A...

    Riding the Roller Coaster, Cubs Optimism on Wicks, Pinch-Hitting for Mervis, and Other Cubs Bullets

    This weekend sure was a roller coaster, eh? We were riding high Friday night, with a convincing win against the Red Sox following a series sweep of the Astros. But just 48-hours after that, the Cubs had lost twice (once...

    REPORT: The MLB Uniforms Are Being Addressed

    I imagine it was a fire drill for all involved ever since it became clear that the new Nike-designed, Fanatics-manufactured MLB jerseys (and pants) were a problem for many players. What was intended to be an improvement turned out to...

    Cody Bellinger Already Playing Catch, Taking Swings

    When a guy fractures his rib(s), that's not an injury where we have a pretty well-set idea in our minds about how long he'll be out. It depends on the extent and location of the fracture(s), the natural healing speed...

    Enhanced Box Score: Red Sox 5, Cubs 4 – April 28, 2024

    Yeah, I don't know how that could have ended any other way....an in-between blooper that bounces of Dansby Swanson's glove*, which simultaneously leads to the first earned run Mark Leiter Jr. has allowed this year and a walk-off win for...

    Mike Tauchman Ties the Game with an 8th-Inning, Three-Run BLAST!

    Nothing about this game so far had been enjoyable. From the broadcast, to the Cubs prouduction, to all the luck seemingly going the Red Sox way. But after finally chasing Tanner Houck out of the game, the Cubs were able...

    Pre-Gamin’: Cubs at Red Sox (6:10 CT) – Lineups, Pitching Matchup, Broadcast Info, Game Thread

    CUBS LINEUP — Before today's finale, the Chicago Cubs have won three of four Rubber Matches this season: Dodgers (win), Padres (loss), Mariners (win), and Diamondbacks (win). Let's see if they can make it four out of five. Chicago Cubs...

    Latest News

    Phillies vs. Angels Prediction: Expert Picks, Odds, Stats & Best Bets – Monday, April 29, 2024

    Following a two-homer game in a win over the Padres, Bryson Stott leads the Philadelphia Phillies (19-10) into action as -144 favorites against the Los Angeles Angels (10-18). First pitch from Angel Stadium of Anaheim at 9:38 PM ET on...

    Happy Lee Elia Day! The Managerial Rant to End All Managerial Rants

    The Chicago Cubs have, unfortunately, had some bad starts over the years, and late-April is not always a still-hopeful time for the team's fans, as it is this year. Consider the team and the situation back on this day in...

    Reds vs. Padres Prediction: Expert Picks, Odds, Stats & Best Bets – Monday, April 29, 2024

    The San Diego Padres (14-17) hope to avoid their fifth straight defeat when they host the Cincinnati Reds (15-13) Monday at 9:40 PM ET on BSOH. The Reds are listed as -110 favorites, while the Padres are -109 underdogs as...

    Braves vs. Mariners Prediction: Expert Picks, Odds, Stats & Best Bets – Monday, April 29, 2024

    The leaders of the NL East and AL West meet Monday at 9:40 PM ET, with the Atlanta Braves (19-7) visiting the Seattle Mariners (15-13). Bookmakers favor the Braves for the contest, installing them as -145 moneyline favorites.Atlanta's Max Fried...

    Pirates vs. Athletics Prediction: Expert Picks, Odds, Stats & Best Bets – Monday, April 29, 2024

    The Oakland Athletics (12-17) enter Monday's matchup with the Pittsburgh Pirates (14-15) following their 2-1 series victory over the Orioles. The Pirates, coming off of a series loss against the Giants, are listed as -128 favorites for Game 1. The...

    Dodgers vs. Diamondbacks Prediction: Expert Picks, Odds, Stats & Best Bets – Monday, April 29, 2024

    The Los Angeles Dodgers (18-12) are favorites (-131) on the moneyline when they square off against the Arizona Diamondbacks (13-16) Monday at 9:40 PM ET, live on SportsNet LA.Los Angeles' James Paxton gets the start, and he'll go against Arizona's...

    CJ McCollum Player Props: Three-Pointer Props and Odds vs. the Thunder – NBA Playoffs Game 4, Monday, April 29, 2024

    To beat his 3-point prop, CJ McCollum must make three from downtown on Monday, when his New Orleans Pelicans face the Oklahoma City Thunder in Game 4 of the opening round of the NBA playoffs, starting at 8:30 PM ET.CJ...

    Shai Gilgeous-Alexander Player Props: Three-Pointer Props and Odds vs. the Pelicans – NBA Playoffs Game 4, Monday, April 29, 2024

    At 8:30 PM ET on Monday, in Game 4 of the opening round of the NBA playoffs, it'll be the Oklahoma City Thunder versus the New Orleans Pelicans, with Shai Gilgeous-Alexander needing two treys to beat his 3-pointer over/under.Shai Gilgeous-Alexander's...

    Brandon Ingram Player Props: Three-Pointer Props and Odds vs. the Thunder – NBA Playoffs Game 4, Monday, April 29, 2024

    The New Orleans Pelicans meet the Oklahoma City Thunder on Monday at 8:30 PM ET in Game 4 of the opening round of the NBA playoffs, and if the Pelicans' Brandon Ingram makes two 3-pointers, he'll beat his over/under.Brandon Ingram's...

    Atlanta Falcons NFL Draft Grade: Falcons Fumble Draft with 8 Shocking Picks Starting with Michael Penix

    The 2024 NFL Draft was supposed to be a turning point for the Atlanta Falcons. I couldn’t imagine anyone giving a positive Atlanta Falcons NFL Draft Grade after what we witnessed. With the 8th overall pick, hope fluttered in the...

    more cubs news