On the Overall Lack of Extensions in Baseball – Are Players Expecting a Huge Luxury Tax Bump?

While I won’t back away from the idea that the Chicago Cubs were uniquely positioned to obviously get at least one extension done this offseason, I do think it’s fair to point out that their absence of extensions is hardly aberrant. It’s been Fernando Tatis, Jr., Lance McCullers, Jr., Sal Perez, Hunter Dozier, and Randy Dobnak. That’s literally it this offseason.

With a free agent class projected to be loaded, you would’ve expected a ton more movement on the extension front. Yet the whole league has seen a dearth of extension news from last year through now, attributable – according to most – to the pandemic’s impact on finances around baseball.

And not that that isn’t a factor, but I think the coming expiration of the Collective Bargaining Agreement is perhaps an even bigger factor, and Jeff Passan well-articulates part of the reason why:

The expiration of the collective bargaining agreement Dec. 1 looms large. Players believe the competitive-balance tax threshold — the luxury-tax number — will rise significantly, potentially juicing spending. They don’t want to lock into deals that might immediately be seen as under-market.

Many have presumed that the financial landscape in baseball could change significantly next year thanks to the return of fans this year and a newly-minted CBA, but this is the first time I’ve seen articulated a precise angle to how the financial landscape could change: dramatically increased luxury tax levels.

The reason, I think, that we haven’t seen that point offered up before is that the luxury tax in the current CBA serves as a de facto salary cap. It gives owners cover not to spend above it (at least not multiple years in a row) without providing the benefits that typically come with a salary-capped-system (better revenue sharing, salary floors, etc.). Personally, I’d been thinking we might see an entire overhaul of the spending system – including earlier arbitration and/or free agency for players – with a revenue-sharing model implemented a la the NBA and NFL. It’s a huge change, but it’s one that could wind up actually better providing for more younger players than the current system, and could help bring back the middle class of free agency.

But if the players are instead focused on luxury tax levels, that would seem to have much more of an impact on future free agents (and huge-money extension candidates). I won’t tell the players their business, but I sure hope there’s also a big focus on younger/more marginal players in the new system. For the most part, the players at the top of the pyramid have still gotten theirs the last few years. It’s the other guys who’ve been squeezed out.

In any case, a world where the luxury tax is still a thing in the new CBA means Average Annual Value is still a thing, and it means players and teams would be thinking very, very carefully about signing long-term extensions right now. Teams would probably keep their offers artificially low, citing the pandemic, and players would keep their asks artificially high, citing the CBA changes (again, if they’re focused on possible luxury tax movement).

For the Cubs, maybe that’s part of why they haven’t been able to land a deal yet with Anthony Rizzo or Javy Báez, with age/performance/face-of-franchise stuff further complicating matters. It doesn’t mean it’s OK – I want to see DEALS DONE for these guys at fair prices – but it’s clearly a factor that impacts these Cubs talks and extends out much wider than the Cubs.

written by

Brett Taylor is the Lead Cubs Writer at Bleacher Nation, and you can find him on Twitter at @BleacherNation and on LinkedIn here. Brett is also the founder of Bleacher Nation, which opened up shop in 2008 as an independent blog about the Chicago Cubs. Later growing to incorporate coverage of other Chicago sports, Bleacher Nation is now one of the largest regional sports blogs on the web.

more cubs news

The Cubs Walk It Off on a Weird Play at the Plate!

Whew. That game was kinda dumb, but I tell you, the ending sure was fun. And also weird! So, to set the stage, the Pirates and Cubs' offenses could do nothing all day long. The game was still 0-0 in...

Brennen Davis FREAKING DID IT AGAIN! AND THEN HE DID IT AGAIN AFTER THAT!

This guy. What do I even say? I was already kinda buzzy when Brennen Davis homered again - a grand slam - for the fifth time in six games, and sixth time in eight games. THAT IS RIDICULOUS. https://twitter.com/IowaCubs/status/1791967453888598441 Truly...

Enhanced Box Score: Cubs 1, Pirates 0 – May 18, 2024

What matters most is that the Cubs won the game. And it was a fun ending, too. So I'm happy. But I also do feel a little frustrated - or concerned might be the better word - as I'm sure...

Pre-Gamin’: Pirates at Cubs (1:20 CT) – Lineups, Broadcast Info, Game Thread

CUBS LINEUP — Losing to the Braves (and then Jared Jones and Paul Skenes), when you have 10 people on the IL, including your entire middle infield, is not really that concerning to me. It sucks and banking losses is...

REPORT: Cubs Trade Richard Lovelady to the Rays

When the Chicago Cubs traded Jake Slaughter to the Seattle Mariners for reliever Tyson Miller, they needed to open a spot on both the active roster and the 40-man roster. They did that in one move by designating reliever Richard...

Cubs Set a Target Date for Dansby Swanson’s Return, Daniel Palencia Also On His Way

First, a quick update I kept out of the headline: Nico Hoerner is not in the Cubs lineup today, as he continues to deal with left hamstring tightness. The Cubs have now blown past the maximum IL backdate optimization, which...

Hendricks Will Get More Chances, Many Injury Updates, A Possible New Scandal, and Other Cubs Bullets

Sports Saturday around the Taylor household, so it's time to run all over to soccer fields and baseball fields and dance centers. First, Cubs Bullets ... Kyle Hendricks may not have made a load of terrible pitches in yesterday's game...

Enhanced Box Score: Pirates 9, Cubs 3 – May 17, 2024

For six hitless, profoundly dominant innings, Paul Skenes today looked like the best pitching prospect I've seen since maybe Stephen Strasburg. The other two who came to mind as I watched were Matt Harvey and Jose Fernandez. Those three, when...

MLBits: Elly De La Cruz Continues to Electrify, Yanks Want Soto for Long Haul, More

Elly De La Cruz continues to dazzle and the Yankees want Juan Soto in New York for the rest of his career. That and more in today's MLB Notes! Elly De La Cruz's Four Steal Night Cincinnati Reds shortstop Elly...

Cubs Farm Report | May 17, 2024: I-Cubs’ Homer Party Helps Cade Horton Get His First Triple-A Win

The Iowa Cubs mashed four home runs and scored 10 runs, as Cade Horton made his best start at Triple-A on Thursday. That and more in today's Cubs Farm Report. Cubs Farm Report | May 17, 2024 Triple-A Iowa Cubs...

Latest News

Red Sox vs. Cardinals: Free Live Stream, TV Channel, How to Watch

Nick Pivetta takes the mound for the Boston Red Sox (22-23) when they visit starter Matthew Liberatore and the St. Louis Cardinals (19-25) at 1:05 PM ET on Sunday.The article below will provide you with everything you need to know...

How to Watch Royals vs. Athletics: Live Stream or on TV

On Sunday, aiming to finish off a series sweep, Brady Singer takes the mound for the Kansas City Royals (27-19) against JP Sears and the Oakland Athletics (19-28), with first pitch scheduled for 2:10 PM ET.The article below will give...

Astros vs. Brewers: Free Live Stream, TV Channel, How to Watch

On Sunday, aiming for a series sweep, Kyle Tucker and the Houston Astros (20-25) play William Contreras and the Milwaukee Brewers (26-18), with first pitch scheduled for 2:10 PM ET at Minute Maid Park.The article below will give you everything...

Rangers vs. Angels: Free Live Stream, TV Channel, How to Watch

The Los Angeles Angels (17-28), led by Taylor Ward and looking for a series sweep, visit Marcus Semien and the Texas Rangers (23-23) at 2:35 PM ET on Sunday.The article below will give you everything you need to watch Texas...

How to Watch Phillies vs. Nationals: Live Stream or on TV

Aaron Nola will take the mound for the Philadelphia Phillies (32-14) when they host starter Trevor Williams and the Washington Nationals (20-23) on Sunday, with first pitch at 1:35 PM ET and the Phillies aiming for a series sweep.The article...

How to Watch Orioles vs. Mariners: Live Stream or on TV

Gunnar Henderson and the Baltimore Orioles (28-14) host Caleb Raleigh and the Seattle Mariners (24-21) on Sunday, with first pitch at 1:35 PM ET, and the Orioles aiming for a series sweep.The article below will give you everything you need...

How to Watch Guardians vs. Twins: Live Stream or on TV

On Sunday, going for a series sweep, Jose Ramirez and the Cleveland Guardians (28-17) play Ryan Jeffers and the Minnesota Twins (24-20), with first pitch scheduled for 1:40 PM ET at Progressive Field.Keep scrolling to find out all the details...

How to Watch Cubs vs. Pirates: Live Stream or on TV

The Chicago Cubs (26-21), with Jameson Taillon on the mound, host the Pittsburgh Pirates (21-26) who will counter with Mitch Keller, at 2:20 PM ET on Sunday.Keep scrolling to find out all the details on how to watch Chicago play...

Knicks vs. Pacers Predictions, Best Bets and Odds: Eastern Conference Semifinals Game 7 – Sunday, May 19, 2024

The New York Knicks and the Indiana Pacers take the court in a decisive Game 7 of the second round of the NBA Playoffs. The Knicks are favored by 2.5 points in the contest, which will be broadcast on ABC...

Brennen Davis FREAKING DID IT AGAIN! AND THEN HE DID IT AGAIN AFTER THAT!

This guy. What do I even say? I was already kinda buzzy when Brennen Davis homered again - a grand slam - for the fifth time in six games, and sixth time in eight games. THAT IS RIDICULOUS. https://twitter.com/IowaCubs/status/1791967453888598441 Truly...

more cubs news