The Cubs Just Won the Game on a Crazy-Long, Two-Replay-Reviewed Double-Play at the Plate! (UPDATE)

How do I even write that up. Wow. Oh my god. I am giddy. That was absolutely incredible. Let me just explain what happened (more than usual), because even I am in utter disbelief.

Hector Neris came in to close out a 1-0 game for the Cubs tonight at Citi Field. After getting the first out of the game, he plunked Pete Alonso, who then moved to third on J.D. Martinez’s double (which popped out of PCA’s glove (but it would’ve been an incredible catch … not a gimmie by any means)).

Then, on the fifth pitch of the next at-bat, Jeff McNeil lifted one out to left field. And it looked, to me, like he had WAY more than enough distance to score the game-tying run on a sac fly. But Ian Happ got under it, fired it in to Nick Madrigal, who threw Alonso out at home for the final out of the game. Cubs win….Or did they?

Immediately after that call, the Mets challenged TWO aspects of the play.

  1. First, they were checking if Miguel Amaya blocked the base (something the league is being PARTICULARLY strict about this year).
  2. Second, if he was actually out.

On first glance, it actually looked like Alonso was safe, because his hand got in (over the base) before he was tagged. But in reality, his hand bounced up and was hovering over the bag.

But the drama was only just beginning. Perhaps because it was a potential game-ender, perhaps because it was two calls at once, or perhaps a combination of both, that review took FOREVER. Like truly, the longest replay review I have ever sat through.

Then the ump reached for his mic and everyone got quiet.

Then he didn’t say anything.

Then he reached for it again and used the most confusing language ever to say that Amaya was NOT blocking the bag, while everyone in New York and on the Mets thought that meant the call was in their favor (it was not). “Blocking is confirmed…there is no blocking.” Lol. WHO SAYS IT LIKE THAT.

And then he said the call of “out” on the field stands. Not confirmed, because it wasn’t clear, but stands. So not enough evidence to confirm it, but not enough overturn it. Thank you, home plate umpire. Thank you.

And that was it. Cubs win. I am giddy. I am in shock. That was insane.

Update: The league confirmed the non-blocking call, because the Mets were very upset (and wrong).

written by

Michael Cerami began covering the Chicago Cubs for Bleacher Nation as a part-time contributor in 2015. One year later, he joined Bleacher Nation full-time, covering the Chicago Cubs and Major League Baseball. Today, Michael runs Bleacher Nation, contributing as a writer (Cubs, MLB) and an editor for all sections of the site, including the Chicago Bears, Bulls, and Blackhawks, as well as MLB, NBA, NHL, and NFL. In 2019, Michael was the co-host of NBC Sports Chicago's Cubs Post-Game Show Outside the Ivy. You can find him on Twitter/X @Michael_Cerami

more cubs news

Enhanced Box Score: Pirates 5, Cubs 4 – May 16, 2024

The Cubs had a golden opportunity handed to them in the bottom of the eighth inning when leadoff man Seiya Suzuki was hit by a pitch and reached third on a swinging bunt (+ error) for Cody Bellinger immediately after....

The Mini-Break Pays Off: Ian Happ with a ROCKET Home Run!

After a red-hot first ten games of the season (172 wRC+), Ian Happ had gone ice cold offensively. Aside from continuing to take his walks (he always does), his overall production plummeted to the point where Craig Counsell game him...

Kevin Alcantara Doubles, Matt Shaw Singles, and Moises Ballesteros HOMERS THEM ALL IN!

Brennen Davis isn't the only hot Cubs prospect. In fact, Moises Ballesteros is basically THE hot Cubs prospect of the season so far. And tonight, after two of the Cubs top prospects — Kevin Alcantara (on a double) and Matt...

Pre-Gamin’: Pirates at Cubs (6:40 CT) – Lineups, Broadcast Info, Game Thread

CUBS LINEUP — The Chicago Cubs are back at Wrigley Field tonight against the Pirates, facing a 22-year-old fireballer who threw six strong innings against them last weekend, Jared Jones. Here's a look at the Cubs lineup for the rematch...

Brennen Davis Just Homered AGAIN

For a moment, it seemed like we were in for another round of terrible Brennen Davis luck. Just as the Cubs outfield prospect was heating back up, this happened: https://twitter.com/thats_so_cub/status/1791239496777760989 Davis is just a magnet for HBPs, even when it's...

MLBits: Red-Hot Rockies, Sticky Stuff Suspension, Salvy’s Patience Paying Off, More

The longest active winning streak in baseball belongs to ... the Rockies. More on the red-hot Rox and more in today's MLB Notes. The Red-Hot Rockies? A little over a week ago, the Rockies were 8-28. Since then, they've won...

The Cubs Are Coming Home to Face the Pirates

Cubs vs Pirates — There's going to be a little deja vu here for the next week, as the Cubs play seven straight games against the Pirates and Braves after just wrapping up six games against ... the Pirates and...

Cubs Farm Report | May 16, 2024: Brennan Davis Goes Yard in Iowa Loss

Brennan Davis' fifth home run of the season was not enough for the Iowa Cubs on Wednesday as they fell to the Syracuse Mets in a rain-shortened affair. That and more in today's Cubs Farm Report. Cubs Farm Report |...

Javier Assad is the Definition of Pitchability

Like his rotation-mate Shota Imanaga, Javier Assad has reached the point where, after every single start, you want to say the same thing: wow, that was awesome, this guy is good. It gets a little stale, in an extremely desirable...

Joe Buck is Returning to the Booth to Call a Cubs-Cardinals Game

I know that Joe Buck is a polarizing broadcaster. Some people love him. Some people hate him. I also know that he seems to have gone through phases in his career where there were stretches I thought he was mutably...

Latest News

Brewers vs. Astros: Free Live Stream, TV Channel, How to Watch

William Contreras and the Milwaukee Brewers (26-17) visit Kyle Tucker and the Houston Astros (18-25) at 8:10 PM ET on Friday.If you're planning on watching this game, keep reading for TV and streaming options for the Milwaukee-Houston matchup.When is Brewers...

Red Sox vs. Cardinals: Free Live Stream, TV Channel, How to Watch

The Boston Red Sox (22-21), led by Jarren Duran, visit Brendan Donovan and the St. Louis Cardinals (18-25) at 8:15 PM ET on Friday.If you're planning on watching this game, keep reading for TV and streaming options for the Boston-St....

How to Watch Rangers vs. Angels: Live Stream or on TV

In a series opener on Friday, Andrew Heaney will take the mound for the Texas Rangers (23-22) against Tyler Anderson and the Los Angeles Angels (16-28), with first pitch scheduled for 8:05 PM ET at Globe Life Field.Find out how...

Pirates vs. Cubs: Start Time, Streaming Live, TV Channel, How to Watch

On Friday, Connor Joe and the Pittsburgh Pirates (19-25) take on Nico Hoerner and the Chicago Cubs (25-19), with first pitch scheduled for 2:20 PM ET at Wrigley Field.Keep reading to find out all the details on how to watch...

The Mini-Break Pays Off: Ian Happ with a ROCKET Home Run!

After a red-hot first ten games of the season (172 wRC+), Ian Happ had gone ice cold offensively. Aside from continuing to take his walks (he always does), his overall production plummeted to the point where Craig Counsell game him...

Kevin Alcantara Doubles, Matt Shaw Singles, and Moises Ballesteros HOMERS THEM ALL IN!

Brennen Davis isn't the only hot Cubs prospect. In fact, Moises Ballesteros is basically THE hot Cubs prospect of the season so far. And tonight, after two of the Cubs top prospects — Kevin Alcantara (on a double) and Matt...

New York Yankees vs. Chicago White Sox Series May 17-19: Odds, Starting Pitchers & Predictions

The New York Yankees will be hosting the Chicago White Sox for a three-game series, with the first matchup getting underway at 7:05 PM ET on Friday, May 17.Yankees vs. White Sox Series Info White Sox @ Yankees Time: Friday,...

Baltimore Orioles vs. Seattle Mariners Series May 17-19: Odds, Starting Pitchers & Predictions

A three-game series featuring the Baltimore Orioles and the visiting Seattle Mariners will begin on Friday, May 17 at 7:05 PM ET.Orioles vs. Mariners Series Info Mariners @ Orioles Time: Friday, May 17 at 7:05 PM ET Orioles Starting Pitcher:...

Toronto Blue Jays vs. Tampa Bay Rays Series May 17-19: Odds, Starting Pitchers & Predictions

In the opener of a three-game series, on Friday, May 17 at 7:07 PM ET, the Toronto Blue Jays are hosting the Tampa Bay Rays.Blue Jays vs. Rays Series Info Rays @ Blue Jays Time: Friday, May 17 at 7:07...

Atlanta Braves vs. San Diego Padres Series May 17-20: Odds, Starting Pitchers & Predictions

The Atlanta Braves will be hosting the San Diego Padres for a four-game series, with the action getting underway at 7:20 PM ET on Friday, May 17.Braves vs. Padres Series Info Padres @ Braves Time: Friday, May 17 at 7:20...

more cubs news