Lukewarm Stove: Garza, Cespedes, Byrd, Soriano, Soler, Marshall

Yesterday afternoon and on through the evening proved to be fertile grounds for the rumor mill…

  • The Detroit Tigers announced that DH/C Victor Martinez would be missing the 2012 season after tearing his ACL, which spent the Cubs’ rumor world into a tizzy: Alfonso Soriano? Marlon Byrd? Increased desire for Matt Garza? It was frenetic, and, at times, thoughtless – but that doesn’t mean it was inaccurate. I have no doubt that these scenarios have been and will be explored … together with many, many other options for the Tigers. GM Dave Dombrowski said the team would like to find a “short-term” solution, which doesn’t quite sound like three years of Soriano. It all depends, of course, on how much money the Cubs are willing to eat on Soriano’s deal, and how strongly the Tigers believe Soriano could succeed as a full-time DH (for me, I think his numbers climb if he’s just DH’ing).
  • Phil Rogers suggests that the best solution for the Tigers would be moving Delmon Young to DH while picking up a strong defensive left fielder, like Marlon Byrd (who would, presumably, be strong in LF). Thus, he thinks the Tigers would be wise to talk to the Cubs about a Byrd and Garza package. He also mentions the same package going to Boston, as Carl Crawford might be out a few months after wrist surgery.
  • On Garza, generally, I’m told that teams (the same names you’ve come to know and love) have started re-approaching the Cubs. The sense I get is that talks with a number of teams were hot and then cold, hot and then cold, based primarily on the Cubs’ high demands. Whether the current re-approaches mean teams are more willing to meet the Cubs’ high demands, or simply mean teams are are still looking to pick up a starter and now wonder if the Cubs have dropped their price, I don’t know.
  • Something to keep in mind on Garza trade talks: if the Cubs would like to net a prospect who was picked in the 2011 draft, they can’t make the trade for a little while yet. Why? Signed draft picks can’t be traded until one year after they sign. They can be players to be named later before that, but a PTBNL has to be “named” within six months of the trade. So, do a little subtraction, and knowing that most of the top prospects in the draft didn’t sign until mid-August, that would mean mid-February is the earliest that such a trade could happen (with the Cubs not officially getting the kid until he is “named” in August).
  • On the Yoenis Cespedes front, the good signs keep popping up. BP’s Kevin Goldstein, after noting that he’d recently been talking to a number of international folks, said he was reordering his likely Cespedes destinations thusly: 1. Cubs, 2. Marlins (and then a big gap), 3. Phillies, 4. Tigers. I’m not crazy about seeing the Cubs getting into a bidding war with the current iteration of the Marlins’ front office, but it’s nice to see them consistently listed as a leader.
  • Cubs’ Scouting Chief Jason McLeod, who’s watched Cespedes a couple times, compared him to a younger, faster Marlon Byrd, and confirmed that he would ideally see about 100 at bats in the minors before you’d think about calling him up.
  • Bruce Levine chatted recently and noted, among other things: (1) The Cubs may try to pick up an outfielder in trade if they move Soriano or Byrd, rather than call Brett Jackson up right away ; (2) once Cespedes and Jorge Soler get residency in the DR, it could still be upwards of two weeks before they are declared free agents; (3) Levine isn’t sure Epstein and Hoyer are sold on Darwin Barney as the starter at second base; (4) Bruce isn’t sure Randy Wells will be the odd man out of the rotation, especially if the Cubs trade Garza (well, yeah); and (5) the Cubs don’t want to do a bad contract swap with Soriano; (6) Bruce still doesn’t completely rule the Cubs out on Prince Fielder.
  • I missed this a little while ago, but Nick Cafardo wondered whether the Yankees’ acquisition of Michael Pineda could be a precursor to flipping him to the Cubs for Matt Garza. Shrug. That seems far-fetched. If Garza is going to the AL East, I’d reckon it’s to the Red Sox or Blue Jays.
  • Tim Kurkjian doesn’t see the Cubs trading Garza, but his reasoning doesn’t paint himself as the most thoughtful guy (which was kind of surprising): “I frankly don’t think Garza is going anywhere. If the Cubs want to get any good here, they’re going to have to do it with their pitching, and to trade one of their best pitchers, at this point, wouldn’t make any sense.”  … unless that pitcher is 28, extremely valuable on the trade market, and under control for two years, during which the Cubs might not be particularly competitive. Come on, Tim. I’m not saying the Cubs have to trade Garza, but “wouldn’t make any sense”?
  • Today at 4pm CT is the deadline for the Rangers to sign Yu Darvish, and there remains general optimism that he’ll sign. If you need me to remind you: you’re hoping he doesn’t sign, which could encourage the Rangers to re-engage the Cubs in Matt Garza trade discussions.
  • Sean Marshall says he hopes he has a chance to return to the Cubs when he’s a free agent after this season.
  • written by

    Brett Taylor is the Lead Cubs Writer at Bleacher Nation, and you can find him on Twitter at @BleacherNation and on LinkedIn here. Brett is also the founder of Bleacher Nation, which opened up shop in 2008 as an independent blog about the Chicago Cubs. Later growing to incorporate coverage of other Chicago sports, Bleacher Nation is now one of the largest regional sports blogs on the web.

    more cubs news

    Enhanced Box Score: Braves 3, Cubs 0 – May 23, 2024

    The vibes are not good. For the 1,000th game in a row, the Chicago Cubs offense failed to do much of anything, wasting yet another (mostly) solid pitching performance from the entire staff. And it's especially a shame, because today...

    Robo Umps, World Baseball Classic Sites, and More MLB Owners Meetings Nuggets

    It's clear that Major League Baseball needs to move to an automated balls-and-strikes system, and it's also clear that it will happen at some point. Unfortunately, it sounds like that system will not arrive in 2025. A report by the...

    MLBits: Yanks to Slash Payroll, Coming Up on the “Worst” Draft Class, Bogaerts, Skenes, More

    Yankees' Hal Steinbrenner is crying broke, the Padres' depth will be tested without Xander Bogaerts for the foreseeable future, and Keith Law has some strong words for the 2024 MLB Draft class in today's MLB Notes. Hal Steinbrenner Says Current...

    Pre-Gamin’: Braves at Cubs (1:20 CT) – Lineups, Broadcast Info, Game Thread

    CUBS LINEUP — For as rough as it has felt at times against the Braves this season, the Cubs still have a chance to split the season-series with a win this afternoon. And while the Cubs are rolling with a...

    Cubs Farm Report | May 23, 2024: Horton’s Impressive Start Helps Iowa Down Indianapolis

    Cade Horton made his best start yet at Triple-A as the Iowa Cubs downed Indianapolis in 11 innings on Wednesday. That and more in today's Cubs Farm Report. Cubs Farm Report | May 23, 2024 Triple-A Iowa Cubs The Iowa...

    Steele is Feeling Really Good Overall, Offensive Lull, Pitcher Updates, and Other Cubs Bullets

    The Little Boy has a special ceremony at school today, so the schedule is a little atypical for me. Hopefully the Cubs beat the Braves, take the series, and that'll put a great cap on the day. The 7th inning...

    Cade Horton Continues to Improve at Triple-A Iowa, and His Latest Start Was His Best

    I'd forgotten that, in addition to the talent and experience difference in jumping from Double-A competition to Triple-A competition, there are a couple logistical changes for players. First, there is the automated balls and strikes system (fully automated half the...

    Kyle Hendricks Takes His Bullpen Demotion Like an Absolute Champ

    Is there a more model Major Leaguer or better example-setter than Kyle Hendricks? I really don't think so. Two days ago, the Cubs bounced the veteran right-hander from their starting rotation. It was a true demotion, as his general ineffectiveness...

    At Least Porter Hodge’s Debut Was Incredible

    There's not a whole lot you're gonna want to take away from last night's loss to the Atlanta Braves, outside of the first six innings from Justin Steele, which were actually pretty good (just pretend in your mind that he...

    Enhanced Box Score: Braves 9, Cubs 2 – May 22, 2024

    If you didn't actually watch this game, you might be worried about Justin Steele. After all, how can anyone have been anything other than "really bad" with five earned runs to their name? Well, I'm here to tell you he...

    Latest News

    Around the NFL: Dak’s Not About the Dollar, Rookie Sleepers, Leaner Lamar, More

    NFL Notes — Despite not having a contract extension in place (or even in sight), Dak Prescott doesn't plan on skipping any Cowboys offseason activities. Dak Prescott on Extension Talks: "I don't play for money" Despite entering the final year...

    Bears OTAs: Tough Day for Caleb Williams and the Offense

    Are you ready for the premature panic on social media because Caleb Williams and the Chicago Bears offense had a tough day in shorts and tee shirts on May 23? Prepare yourself because it happened. The word out of Lake...

    Robo Umps, World Baseball Classic Sites, and More MLB Owners Meetings Nuggets

    It's clear that Major League Baseball needs to move to an automated balls-and-strikes system, and it's also clear that it will happen at some point. Unfortunately, it sounds like that system will not arrive in 2025. A report by the...

    NFL Futures: Latest 2024 NFC Division Winner Odds and More

    As the NFL season approaches, fans and bettors alike are eagerly analyzing the latest Division Winner Odds. With each division presenting its own set of challenges and potential surprises, the race for the top spot is more thrilling than ever....

    Enhanced Box Score: Braves 3, Cubs 0 – May 23, 2024

    The vibes are not good. For the 1,000th game in a row, the Chicago Cubs offense failed to do much of anything, wasting yet another (mostly) solid pitching performance from the entire staff. And it's especially a shame, because today...

    Indy 500 Lineup: Starting Order, Pole Based on Qualifying Results

    The Greatest Spectacle in Racing returns this weekend as Indy Car hits the hallowed grounds of the Indianapolis Motor Speedway. The Indy 500 lineup welcomes one of NASCAR’s top talents to the mix and is primed for another epic chapter...

    A Door Could Reportedly Open for 76ers to Show Interest in Zach LaVine

    The moment Zach LaVine opted for season-ending foot surgery was the moment the trade market fell silent. What little action there was surrounding the two-time All-Star would be put on silent until at least the offseason. And, well, here we...

    Top Player Prop Bets for Celtics vs. Pacers Eastern Conference Finals Game 2 on May 23, 2024

    Jayson Tatum and Pascal Siakam are among the players with prop bets on the table when the Boston Celtics and the Indiana Pacers meet at TD Garden on Thursday (tipping at 8:00 PM ET).How to Watch Celtics vs. PacersDate: Thursday,...

    MLBits: Yanks to Slash Payroll, Coming Up on the “Worst” Draft Class, Bogaerts, Skenes, More

    Yankees' Hal Steinbrenner is crying broke, the Padres' depth will be tested without Xander Bogaerts for the foreseeable future, and Keith Law has some strong words for the 2024 MLB Draft class in today's MLB Notes. Hal Steinbrenner Says Current...

    Guess Who Zach LaVine Was Spotted With at Bronny James’ Pro Day

    The Zach LaVine to the Lakers hoopla will never die, will it? The Chicago Bulls' max player has long been linked to the marquee franchise. Part of the reason for that has been his West Coast roots. Not only did...

    more cubs news