How Much Money is Brandon McCarthy’s Head Injury Worth? and Other Bullets

I’ll have more thoughts on last evening’s roster moves, as well as the newest Cubs pitching prospect, later this morning. Also, there’s a fresh BN Podcast on the way today. Until then, Bullets …

  • Jeff Sullivan at FanGraphs took a very long look at Brandon McCarthy’s unique free agent situation, which is of note to the Cubs for obvious reasons. Specifically, Sullivan would like to be able to know what kind of impact McCarthy’s concussion/brain surgery thing will have on his contract, if any: “We probably won’t be able to learn much from the contract that McCarthy ends up signing, because he represents a sample size of one. This is a thought experiment because it’s not something we’ll ever be able to observe in real life. Say there are 100 Brandon McCarthys. Of those, 50 are clones of the current Brandon McCarthy. The other 50 are clones of the current Brandon McCarthy, but without the head injury. The line drive just missed, and McCarthy kept on pitching through the end of the season. We’ll refer to the first group as Group A, and to the second group as Group B. On average, Group B signs a free-agent contract worth $X million. On average, Group A signs a free-agent contract worth $Y million. Is $Y million equal to $X million? If not, what is the difference? How much lower is Y than X?”
  • It’s a tricky question that Sullivan asks, and one I’ve wrestled with as well. When discussing this injury, specifically, how do you figure a guy’s value? It’s not like it’s an elbow injury or a shoulder injury, for which there would be an obvious discount on the market. But, at the same time, it’s not your run-of-the-mill concussion (if there is such a thing). It takes only one team to give McCarthy his “full” market value for the discussion to be entirely moot, and Cameron’s right: because of that, we’ll never really know the impact. My question for you: are you expecting that the Cubs would get a discount on McCarthy because of the head injury, specifically? He was already going to sign for less than you might expect, because of his other injury history. But should that number come down even more? I’m still firmly in the pro-McCarthy camp, but that’s because I believe he’ll be signing for something in the two-year, $20 million range, at the top. If it’s more than that, then the “winning” team, to me, clearly isn’t concerned about the head injury (or maybe even the rest of the injury history, either). Obviously this whole discussion feels a little untoward, but it’s a necessary evil.
  • The MLBullets at BCB look at one of the more notable roster moves from yesterday: the Mariners dumping Chone Figgins. And, no, I don’t think he’s worth anything more than a Spring Training invite (and, even then, I’m dubious).
  • A comments reminder: for your own good, and the good of the community, learn to spot trolls and then ignore them. They tend to post incessantly for short bursts of time. They tend to try and bait you into arguments that make no sense. They tend to spell poorly and use a kind of “grammar” that few would recognize as communication. Their sole purpose for commenting is to get a rise out of folks, and not to genuinely discuss the Cubs. When you see someone doing this, please ignore them. When you engage, you’re giving them exactly what they want: your attention. Also remember that just because you disagree with someone doesn’t make them a troll. This Bullet refers to a very specific subset of folks who get their jollies not from actually discussing the Cubs, but instead from baiting stupid fights.
  • But to put the community back in a positive light, here’s something awesome from BN’er TWC:
  • See folks? If you wear your BN shirt everywhere, you might find new friends all across the country.
  • written by

    Brett Taylor is the Lead Cubs Writer at Bleacher Nation, and you can find him on Twitter at @BleacherNation and on LinkedIn here. Brett is also the founder of Bleacher Nation, which opened up shop in 2008 as an independent blog about the Chicago Cubs. Later growing to incorporate coverage of other Chicago sports, Bleacher Nation is now one of the largest regional sports blogs on the web.

    more cubs news

    It Took Two At-Bats for Cody Bellinger’s First Home Run Since Being Activated

    Cody Bellinger's first plate appearance of this game (and first PA since returning from two fractured ribs) may have ended in a fly out to right field, but that was after an impressive 12-pitch at-bat. That, alone, was a welcomed...

    Enhanced Box Score: Cubs 3, Padres 2 – May 7, 2024

    Well ... THANK FREAKIN' GOD, EH? In case you weren't watching tonight, this was one of those games that FELT like the Cubs were up by five runs, even though it was 1-0 through the seventh inning. And that's because...

    MICHAEL BUSCH SAVES THE NIGHT! WALK-OFF HOME RUUUUUUUUUUUN!

    Oh my god, thank you, Michael Busch. After Shota Imanaga's stellar start was looking spoiled by a weak offensive showing, the Cubs were able to tie things up in the 8th inning and shut down the Padres in the top...

    OUCH…Willson Contreras Was Just Hit with a J.D. Martinez Swing (UPDATE: Fractured)

    Oouuuuuch. Anyone who's watched Willson Contreras play - or has read the stories - knows that the former Cubs catcher is one of the toughest players in MLB. He always played through injuries and would hobble up to his post...

    Pre-Gamin’: Padres at Cubs (6:40 CT) – Lineups, Broadcast Info, Game Thread

    CUBS LINEUP — With Dylan Cease scheduled to pitch for the Padres in the finale tomorrow, the Cubs are really going to want to take this game tonight. Fortunately, they have Shota Imanaga on the mound ... and CODY BELLINGER...

    Marcus Semien is a Triple Shy of the Cycle … in the 2nd Inning!

    Well, have yourself a day, Marcus Semien. The Rangers infielder is 3-3 with a home run, double, single, four RBI, and a run scored today against the Oakland Athletics, and they're only in the second inning! Semien led the game...

    Thinking About the Cubs Lineup AFTER Cody Bellinger and Seiya Suzuki Return

    UPDATE: Cody Bellinger is officially back with the Chicago Cubs, having been called up after publication of this article. Original post follows. *** According to Taylor McGregor on last night's broadcast, we are maybe a day away from Cody Bellinger...

    CODY BELLINGER IS BACK (Plus Several Other Cubs Roster Moves and Injury Updates)

    No point in burying the lede! The Chicago Cubs center fielder, Cody Bellinger, is officially back with the team just TWO WEEKS after fracturing multiple ribs on a collision with the center field wall. I'd say that's as "best case...

    Keegan Thompson is at Wrigley Field, So Apparently a Move is Coming

    Sam Bernero has an eagle-eye and a steady camera, so when there are players newly in town around Wrigley Field, she is frequently the first person to have it. So it is today, with the return of Keegan Thompson to...

    MLBits: Surprising AL Central, Wheeler Rolls, Shōta’s Fastball, Buehler’s Back, More

    One of baseball's biggest surprises through six weeks? The AL Central has been pretty good this season. Plus, Walker Buehler returns to a major league mound after 22 months, Shōta Imanaga's four-seamer draws national attention, and more in today's MLB...

    Latest News

    The Myrtle Beach Classic Betting Odds, Streaming Live, TV Channel – Round 1

    Erik van Rooyen is the favorite (+2500) at the 2024 Myrtle Beach Classic ($4M purse), from May 9-12 at The Dunes Golf and Beach Club in Myrtle Beach, SC.Taylor Pendrith shot -23 at the AT&T Byron Nelson to notch a...

    Dodgers vs. Marlins Prediction: Expert Picks, Odds, Stats & Best Bets – Wednesday, May 8, 2024

    The Los Angeles Dodgers (25-13) roll into Wednesday's matchup with the Miami Marlins (10-28) looking to extend a six-game winning streak. The contest starts at 3:10 PM ET on SportsNet LA with the Dodgers listed as -283 favorites on the...

    Rangers vs. Athletics Probable Starting Pitchers – May 8

    The Oakland Athletics (17-20) face the Texas Rangers (21-16) at 3:37 PM ET on Wednesday following a three-game losing streak.The Rangers will give the ball to Michael Lorenzen (2-1, 3.52 ERA), who is eyeing win No. 3 on the season,...

    Padres vs. Cubs Prediction: Expert Picks, Odds, Stats & Best Bets – Wednesday, May 8, 2024

    Jake Cronenworth will look to extend his 11-game hitting streak when the San Diego Padres (19-20) take on the Chicago Cubs (22-15). The Padres are listed as -125 favorites on the moneyline for the contest, which starts at 2:20 PM...

    Royals vs. Brewers Prediction: Expert Picks, Odds, Stats & Best Bets – Wednesday, May 8, 2024

    Michael Massey (10 games) will look to add to his hitting streak when the Kansas City Royals (21-16) and Milwaukee Brewers (21-14) meet Wednesday at 2:10 PM ET, live on BSWI from Kauffman Stadium. Massey and the Royals are favored...

    Best MLB Prop Bets Today, May 8, 2024

    The MLB's 16-game schedule today should provide some fireworks. The matchups include the Boston Red Sox squaring off against the Atlanta Braves at Truist Park.Keep reading and you'll discover MLB player prop bets for each and every contest on Wednesday's...

    Dodgers vs. Marlins Probable Starting Pitchers – May 8

    Following a stretch of six consecutive wins, the Los Angeles Dodgers (25-13) meet the Miami Marlins (10-28) at 3:10 PM ET on Wednesday.The Dodgers will look to Gavin Stone (2-1) versus the Marlins and Ryan Weathers (2-3).Dodgers vs. Marlins Pitcher...

    Pirates vs. Angels Prediction: Expert Picks, Odds, Stats & Best Bets – Wednesday, May 8, 2024

    The Los Angeles Angels (13-23) and Logan O'Hoppe, coming off a four-hit game, are underdogs (+111) on the moneyline and will look to upset the Pittsburgh Pirates (17-20) on Wednesday at 12:35 PM ET on SportsNet PT.Pittsburgh's Martin Perez and...

    Phillies vs. Blue Jays Prediction: Expert Picks, Odds, Stats & Best Bets – Wednesday, May 8, 2024

    The Philadelphia Phillies (26-11) will look to complete a series sweep as they take a 1-0 lead into their final matchup against the Toronto Blue Jays (16-20) at 1:05 PM ET Wednesday from Citizens Bank Park. The Phillies are favored...

    Cardinals vs. Mets Prediction: Expert Picks, Odds, Stats & Best Bets – Wednesday, May 8, 2024

    The St. Louis Cardinals (15-21) stumble into Wednesday's matchup with the New York Mets (18-18) looking to break a four-game losing streak. The contest starts at 1:15 PM ET on SNY with the Cardinals listed as -167 favorites to right...

    more cubs news